Gravitational redshift profiles of MaNGA BCGs

Hongyu Zhu, Shadab Alam, Rupert A. C. Croft, Shirley Ho, Elena Giusarma, Alexie Leauthaud, M. R. MerrifieldarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The gravitational potential well of a massive galaxy ($M > 10^{13} M_\odot$) induces a gravitational redshift differential of approximately 1 km/s between its core and outskirts. With the advent of large-scale spatially resolved spectroscopy surveys like MaNGA, detecting this relativistic effect within individual galaxies has become a tangible goal. We present an attempt to measure the averaged stellar redshift profile of 272 massive elliptical galaxies. While standard data pipelines are limited by sub-km/s systematic effects—likely originating from charge transfer inefficiencies and wavelength calibration—we develop a custom cross-correlation technique to mitigate these errors. We achieve a $1\sigma$ precision of $\sim 0.5$ km/s. Although a statistically significant detection remains elusive, our results place a new upper limit on the dark matter content in galaxy cores, constraining it to less than 1.2 times the stellar mass within the half-light radius at the 68% confidence level.

Introduction: Probing the Potential Well

General Relativity posits that clocks run slower in stronger gravitational fields. Consequently, light escaping from the dense center of a massive galaxy is redshifted relative to light emitted from its less dense outskirts. This internal gravitational redshift is a direct probe of the galaxy's gravitational potential, offering a unique perspective on mass distribution that is independent of traditional kinematic or lensing methods.

However, the signal is incredibly faint. For a typical massive elliptical galaxy, the expected shift is roughly 1 km/s. This must be disentangled from stellar velocities that reach hundreds of km/s and instrumental uncertainties that typically exceed 10 km/s. Detecting this "slow tick" of gravity requires pushing current astronomical data to its absolute limits.

Datasets and Sample Selection

We utilize data from the Mapping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory (MaNGA) survey, which provides Integral Field Unit (IFU) spectroscopy for thousands of galaxies. To maximize the signal, we targeted Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs) located in massive dark matter halos ($\log M/M_\odot > 13$), identified via the Yang et al. catalog.

Distribution of the galaxy sample in mass and scale.

Our final sample consists of 272 "clean" elliptical galaxies. These were selected after a rigorous manual inspection process to ensure they were well-centered and free from ongoing mergers or significant structural irregularities that could bias the redshift measurement.

Methodology: Beyond the Standard Pipeline

The standard MaNGA Data Analysis Pipeline (DAP) is designed for a velocity accuracy of ~20 km/s. When searching for a 1 km/s signal, we found that the DAP introduced spurious systematic shifts. To overcome this, we developed a specialized analysis using the raw-ish Data Reduction Pipeline (DRP) outputs.

Visual inspection of target elliptical galaxies.

Our approach involved stacking the spectra of the entire sample to suppress random noise and employing a small-window cross-correlation technique. By using wavelength windows as narrow as 4 Å, we ensured that instrumental artifacts—such as those caused by CCD charge transfer—would affect the reference and target spectra identically, allowing the systematic errors to cancel out. Furthermore, we modeled and subtracted other relativistic effects, including the Transverse Doppler Effect and relativistic beaming, to isolate the gravitational component.

Results and Dark Matter Constraints

We achieved a measurement precision of approximately 0.5 km/s, a significant improvement over standard pipeline results. Despite this high precision, the measured redshift profile was consistent with a null result within our error bars.

While we did not achieve a definitive detection of gravitational redshift, the data allowed us to place competitive constraints on the dark matter distribution in these galaxies. At a 68% confidence level, we determined that the dark matter mass within the half-light radius must be less than 1.2 times the stellar mass. This "gravity-only" constraint provides a valuable independent check on galaxy formation models and the nature of dark matter in high-density environments.

Future Outlook

The primary bottleneck for this research is the instrumental floor of current-generation spectrographs. However, the techniques developed here—particularly the systematic mitigation through narrow-window cross-correlation—provide a roadmap for future studies. Next-generation instruments like HECTOR, or high-resolution spectrographs on 30-meter class telescopes, will likely provide the data necessary to turn gravitational redshift profiles into a standard tool for galactic archaeology and tests of gravity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The gravitational potential well of an $M>10^{13}$ $M_\odot$ galaxy will lead to a gravitational redshift differential of order 1 km/s between the galaxy core and its outskirts. Current surveys of massive galaxies with spatially resolved spectroscopy have reached a size which makes feasible attempts to detect gravitational redshifts within galaxies. We use spectra from the Mapping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory (MaNGA) experiment to attempt a measurement of the averaged stellar redshift profile of large elliptical galaxies. We find that systematic effects (possibly related to charge transfer or wavelength calibration accuracy) make the standard MaNGA data pipeline unsuitable for measuring the relevant sub km/s wavelength shifts. We therefore develop a cross-correlation technique to mitigate these effects, but caution that we are working beyond the design accuracy of the MaNGA experiment. With a sample of $272$ galaxies in halos with $\log (M/M_\odot)>13$, we attempt a measurement of the gravitational redshift profile, achieving $1 σ$ errors of size $\sim 0.5$ km/s, but are unable to make a significant detection of the signal. Even without a detection, our measurement can be used to limit the dark matter mass within the half light radius of elliptical galaxies to $1.2$ times the stellar mass, at the 68% confidence level. We also perform weighting scheme tests and split sample tests, and address target selection issues and other relativistic effects, including the transverse Doppler effect and relativistic beaming of stars. Future detections could lead to new constraints on the galaxy mass distribution that are different from kinematic and lensing determinations and open a window on galaxy properties and tests of gravity.
BibTeX
@misc{zhu2019gravitational,
  author = {Hongyu Zhu and Shadab Alam and Rupert A. C. Croft and Shirley Ho and Elena Giusarma and Alexie Leauthaud and M. R. Merrifield},
  title = {{Gravitational redshift profiles of MaNGA BCGs}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1901.05616},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.05616},
}

Loading related content...

Figure