Gratian North of the Alps: New Evidence of the First Recension in the Archdiocese of Salzburg
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
Gratian North of the Alps:New Evidence of the First Recension in the Archdiocese of Salzburg John Burden1 Since the discovery of an earlier recension of Gratian's Decretum more than twenty years ago, scholars have identified a steadily increasing number of manuscripts which bear witness to it.2 Anders Winroth's initial study on this "first recension" focused on four copies preserved in Admont (Aa), Barcelona (Bc), Florence (Fd), and Paris (P).3 Soon after, Carlos Larrainzar found [End Page 89] an abbreviated version in St. Gall (Sg) and a fragment in Paris (Pfr).4 More recently, Atria Larson has identified several folios of [End Page 90] another abbreviation in Munich (Mw).5 While editing the first recension, Winroth also came to the exciting (but for the purposes of the edition, troubling) conclusion that several twelfth-century manuscripts which appear to contain later versions of the Decretum actually preserve the 'first recension in disguise'.6 To this list of first-recension witnesses can now be added Göttweig, SB 181 (88) (henceforth Gw), which contains an abbreviated 'capitulatio' consisting of first-recension rubrics and inscriptions. Although Gw was known to scholars as early as the 1860s, it is only now, under closer scrutiny, that its true nature is revealed. This paper will analyze Gw and its first-recension 'capitulatio', compare it to other early manuscripts of the Decretum, and, in the process, provide new insights into the early history of the Decretum in the archdiocese of Salzburg.7 Göttweig, SB 181 (88) (Gw) dates to the latter half of the twelfth century and has resided as long as anyone knows in Göttweig Abbey, which lies about 60 kilometers up the Danube to the west of Vienna.8 Gw contains several texts including two [End Page 91] abbreviated versions of the Decretum, the Tractatus de sacrilegiis et immunitatibus, and a short treatise on marriage.9 The two Decretum abbreviations first received scholarly attention from Johann F. von Schulte, who noted that they excerpt the Decretum in strange ways.10 The second abbreviation (fol. 25ra-95ra, henceforth Gw2) is missing all the 'paleae' and only partially divides the first part (Distinctiones) and third part (De consecratione) into distinctions.11 The first abbreviation (fol. 2ra-23vb, henceforth Gw1) is even more interesting. Not only does it lack the 'paleae', it has no distinction divisions in the first part and the De consecratione is entirely absent.12 Because of these oddities, Schulte suspected that both abbreviations were important for the early history of the Decretum. He wrote that Gw1 'was made not long at all after Gratian's Decretum itself' and that Gw2 was 'younger but still reaching deep into the twelfth century'.13 [End Page 92] Since Schulte, Gw2 has received significant scholarly attention under the title Exceptiones ecclesiasticarum regularum. Rudolf Weigand studied its contents and its glosses, revealing its presence in a total of ten manuscripts from Germany and Austria.14 Weigand also showed that its glosses rely on the Summa of Rufinus.15 Gw1, however, has received little scholarly attention since Schulte. Weigand touched on it only briefly, correcting Schulte's claim that Bamberg, SB Msc. Can. 35 (P. II. 29) contains the same abbreviation as Gw1.16 The Bamberg manuscript does indeed contain an early Decretum abbreviation, but it is unrelated to either of the Göttweig texts.17 Schulte may have been wrong on this count, but as the following analysis will show, he was right to suspect that Gw1 reflects an early form of the Decretum. A First Recension Capitulatio Gw1 consists of twenty-two folios and bears the title Liber aureus decretorum concordatorum. It is written in two columns of thirty lines and records the Decretum in a peculiar form: it contains only the rubrics and inscriptions to the canons without their actual texts.18 The rubrics form the main body while the inscriptions [End Page 93] appear in the margins. Although Schulte called it a Summa, and Kuttner and Weigand an Abbreviatio, Gw1 does not fit neatly into either category. The term which probably describes it best is a 'capitulatio'. As others have noted, it was common in the twelfth and thirteenth...
BibTeX
@article{burden2017gratian,
author = {John Burden},
title = {{Gratian North of the Alps: New Evidence of the First Recension in the Archdiocese of Salzburg}},
journal = {Bulletin},
year = {2017},
doi = {10.1353/bmc.2017.0003},
}Loading related content...