Grassroots Organizational Capacity in Community Crisis Governance: A Case Study of Nanhai, China

Jun Tan, Yuan YuanLand 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals how land ownership and spatial configurations fundamentally shape the crisis response capacity of grassroots organizations in China. By analyzing urban and rural neighborhoods during a COVID-19 lockdown, the research demonstrates that collective land ownership and open spaces foster "Embedded Autonomy" and proactive governance, while state land dependency and fragmented spaces lead to "Reactive Co-Governance" reliant on top-down intervention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Public health emergencies (PHEs) are a critical test for how well local communities can respond. While existing research often focuses on resource mobilization or state-society relationships to explain the effectiveness of grassroots organizations like China's Residential Committees (RCs), this paper argues that these explanations are incomplete. The authors identify a significant gap: the under-explored role of deeper structural foundations, specifically land regimes and spatial configurations, in shaping these capacities, particularly in rapidly urbanizing contexts of the Global South. They contend that these material conditions are not just passive backdrops but actively condition how RCs can govern during crises.

Methods

The study develops a novel analytical framework called "Grassroots Organizational Capacity" (GOC). This framework breaks down capacity into four key dimensions: Information Capacity, Implementation Capacity, Mobilization and Cooperation Capacity, and Coercive Capacity. To test this framework, the researchers conducted a comparative case study of two neighborhoods in Nanhai, China: Hedong (rural) and Jiayi (urban), during the 2022 lockdown. Data was collected through semi-structured interviews with ten key stakeholders, employing an "elite interviewing" strategy to gain insights from decision-makers. The analysis used a deductive thematic approach, initially coding based on the GOC framework and theoretical archetypes, followed by an inductive analysis to identify emergent themes and nuances. Methodological triangulation, including cross-verification with documentary evidence and ensuring inter-coder reliability, was used to enhance validity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on qualitative data from semi-structured interviews.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Land as a Structural Determinant: The core insight is that land regimes (collective vs. state ownership) and spatial configurations (open vs. enclosed) are not mere contextual factors but actively shape the very nature and effectiveness of grassroots crisis governance.
  • Two Divergent Governance Logics: The study identifies two distinct models:
  • Embedded Autonomy (Rural Archetype): Characterized by collective land ownership and open spaces, this model fosters proactive governance through financial autonomy and dense, identity-driven social networks.
  • Reactive Co-Governance (Urban Archetype): Driven by state land dependency and fragmented, enclosed spaces, this model leads to reactive governance, heavily reliant on top-down state intervention and mediated by formal structures.
  • Resource Pathway Matters: Collective land ownership in rural areas provides financial autonomy, enabling RCs to hire staff and fund responses independently. In contrast, state land dependency in urban areas limits RCs' ability to procure resources and motivate volunteers, making them reactive.
  • Spatial Configuration Shapes Social Networks: Open, interconnected rural spaces foster dense, trust-based social networks that enhance information flow and informal control. Enclosed urban spaces fragment social ties, necessitating reliance on intermediaries like Property Management Companies (PMCs) and leading to delayed responses.
  • Informal Leverage and Risks: While rural embedded networks offer strong coercive capacity (e.g., through landlord-tenant relationships), this also carries risks of elite capture and informal coercion. Urban areas, while offering more formal equity, struggle with weak social cohesion and reliance on transactional incentives.

Key Results

The study found significant differences in the GOC dimensions between the rural Hedong and urban Jiayi neighborhoods:

  • Information Capacity: High and efficient in Hedong via landlord-tenant networks; low and delayed in Jiayi due to reliance on formal, top-down WeChat groups.
  • Implementation Capacity: Strong and autonomous in Hedong with sufficient staff; weak and reactive in Jiayi, dependent on external state support and understaffed.
  • Mobilization and Cooperation Capacity: Proactive and robust in Hedong, fueled by self-raised funds and strong community identity; constrained and transactional in Jiayi, relying on formal hukou benefits for volunteers.
  • Coercive Capacity: Effective and informal in Hedong through landlord leverage; limited and formal in Jiayi, relying on persuasion.

These findings directly support the conceptualization of "Embedded Autonomy" in rural areas and "Reactive Co-Governance" in urban areas.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge the primary limitation of a small sample size (N=10) due to the strict constraints of the 2022 lockdown. They emphasize that the findings should be interpreted as "analytical generalizations" proposing theoretical logics rather than statistical inferences about population frequencies.

Future research could:

  • Expand to more cases in the Global South to further validate these mechanisms.
  • Investigate practical policy recommendations, such as establishing "Institutionalized Discretionary Funds" for urban RCs and implementing "micro-regeneration" strategies for urban spaces.
  • Develop regulatory frameworks for rural areas to mitigate the risks of elite capture within informal networks, potentially by co-opting key landlords into formal systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Public health emergencies (PHEs) test the crisis response capacity of grassroots organizations like China’s Residential Committees (RCs). While existing research attributes this capacity to factors like resource mobilization or state-society relations, its deeper structural foundations in land regimes and spatial configurations remain underexplored, particularly in Global South urbanization contexts. To fill this gap, this study develops a “Grassroots Organizational Capacity” (GOC) analytical framework, which disaggregates capacity into four dimensions: information, implementation, mobilization and cooperation, and coercion. We then employ this framework in a comparative case study of urban (Jiayi) and rural (Hedong) neighbourhoods in Nanhai, China, during the 2022 lockdown. Drawing on semi-structured interviews with ten key stakeholders in 2022, the findings reveal divergent types of governance. In the rural case, collective land ownership and open spaces foster an “Embedded Autonomy” type, enabling a proactive response through dense social networks. In the urban case, state land dependency and spatial fragmentation lead to a “Reactive Co-Governance” type, which relies on top-down state intervention. This study’s contribution is to provide a case-based illustration of how land and space structures are actively associated with grassroots crisis response effectiveness, rather than serving as passive backdrops.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2025grassroots,
  author = {Jun Tan and Yuan Yuan},
  title = {{Grassroots Organizational Capacity in Community Crisis Governance: A Case Study of Nanhai, China}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/land14122434},
}
Figure