Graph-Structured Topic Modeling for Documents with Spatial or Covariate Dependencies

Yeo Jin Jung, Claire DonnatarXiv 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces Graph-Aligned Probabilistic Latent Semantic Indexing (GpLSI), a novel topic modeling approach that leverages document similarity information encoded in a graph to improve topic estimation. By extending the frequentist pLSI framework with graph regularization and an iterative SVD algorithm, GpLSI achieves more accurate topic models, especially for short documents, and offers theoretical guarantees.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional topic modeling methods, like Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) and Probabilistic Latent Semantic Indexing (pLSI), primarily rely on word frequencies within documents to discover latent topics. However, these methods often struggle when documents are short (i.e., have few words), leading to noisy topic estimations. Furthermore, they typically ignore valuable external information, such as spatial proximity or known relationships between documents, which could significantly enhance topic discovery. Existing Bayesian approaches that incorporate such metadata often face computational challenges and lack theoretical guarantees. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a frequentist topic model that effectively integrates document similarity information from a graph structure, providing both improved performance and theoretical backing.

Methods

The core of GpLSI is a graph-regularized iterative singular value decomposition (SVD) applied to the document-word matrix. This approach extends the standard pLSI framework by incorporating a graph that represents similarities between documents.

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological contributions:

  • Graph Formalism: Documents are treated as nodes in a graph, and edges represent their similarity. This graph structure is used to enforce a "smoothness" constraint on the topic mixture matrix (W), meaning that similar documents should have similar topic proportions.
  • Graph-Aligned SVD: The paper proposes an iterative algorithm that modifies the standard SVD. This iterative process denoises the singular vectors by leveraging the graph structure, ensuring that the estimated topic representations for similar documents are aligned. This is achieved by solving an optimization problem that includes a graph-total variation penalty.
  • Cross-Validation for Regularization: A novel graph cross-validation method is introduced to automatically select the optimal graph regularization parameter. This method uses a minimum spanning tree to partition documents into folds, preserving the graph structure during cross-validation.
  • Theoretical Guarantees: The authors derive high-probability error bounds for the estimated topic mixture matrix (W) and topic-word matrix (A), providing theoretical justification for the method's performance.

Datasets

The paper evaluates GpLSI on:

  • Synthetic Datasets: Generated to specifically test the model's ability to leverage spatial information and handle short documents.
  • Three Real-World Corpora:
    • Stanford Colorectal Cancer dataset: Analyzing tumor microenvironments, where documents are tissue samples and words are immune cell types. Spatial proximity of samples is used to construct the graph.
  • Mouse Spleen Samples: Identifying immune topics in mouse spleen, where documents are B cell microenvironments.
  • "What's Cooking" dataset: A recipe dataset where documents are recipes and words are ingredients. A graph is constructed based on the geographical proximity of cuisines.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Document Similarity is Crucial: The paper strongly demonstrates that incorporating known relationships between documents (via a graph) significantly improves topic modeling performance, especially in challenging scenarios like short documents.
  • Frequentist Approach with Theoretical Guarantees: By extending pLSI, the authors provide a theoretically grounded frequentist alternative to existing Bayesian methods, addressing limitations in computational complexity and theoretical guarantees.
  • Iterative Denoising for Robustness: The iterative graph-aligned SVD approach effectively denoises the data by leveraging the graph structure, leading to more accurate singular vector estimates and subsequently better topic models.
  • Graph Structure Matters: The performance of GpLSI is shown to be influenced by the graph topology, performing well on well-connected graphs and demonstrating the importance of the regularization term.
  • Short Documents are No Longer a Major Hurdle: GpLSI's ability to smooth topic proportions across neighboring documents makes it particularly effective for datasets with short documents, a common limitation for traditional topic models.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy: GpLSI consistently achieves lower $l_2$ and $l_1$ errors for estimating both the topic mixture matrix (W) and the topic-word matrix (A) compared to established methods like LDA, pLSI, and SLDA, especially in low-N (short document) and low-p (small vocabulary) regimes.
  • Faster Inference: The iterative nature of the GpLSI algorithm is shown to be computationally efficient, offering faster inference times compared to some existing Bayesian methods.
  • Real-World Applicability: GpLSI successfully identifies meaningful topics in diverse real-world applications, including tumor microenvironment analysis, mouse spleen immune cell identification, and cuisine style discovery from recipes. For instance, in the cancer dataset, GpLSI identified topics associated with lower cancer recurrence risk.
  • Theoretical Bounds: The paper provides high-probability error bounds for the estimated matrices, demonstrating that GpLSI's performance scales favorably with dataset size and graph properties.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low-p Regime Assumption: The theoretical analysis primarily focuses on a "low-p" regime (small vocabulary size). While the authors suggest solutions for larger vocabularies (e.g., thresholding rare terms), this remains an area for further investigation.
  • Incorporating Structure into Topic Matrix (A): The current work focuses on graph-based regularization for the document-topic mixture matrix (W). The authors suggest a promising future direction is to incorporate structure into the topic-word matrix (A) as well, potentially by introducing sparsity.
  • Generalizing to Weighted Graphs: While the method is discussed as being extendable to weighted graphs, the theoretical analysis and experiments primarily focus on binary graphs.

Note: The PDF was readable and contained a research paper.

Summary updated

Abstract

We address the challenge of incorporating document-level metadata into topic modeling to improve topic mixture estimation. To overcome the computational complexity and lack of theoretical guarantees in existing Bayesian methods, we extend probabilistic latent semantic indexing (pLSI), a frequentist framework for topic modeling, by incorporating document-level covariates or known similarities between documents through a graph formalism. Modeling documents as nodes and edges denoting similarities, we propose a new estimator based on a fast graph-regularized iterative singular value decomposition (SVD) that encourages similar documents to share similar topic mixture proportions. We characterize the estimation error of our proposed method by deriving high-probability bounds and develop a specialized cross-validation method to optimize our regularization parameters. We validate our model through comprehensive experiments on synthetic datasets and three real-world corpora, demonstrating improved performance and faster inference compared to existing Bayesian methods.
BibTeX
@misc{jung2024graph,
  author = {Yeo Jin Jung and Claire Donnat},
  title = {{Graph-Structured Topic Modeling for Documents with Spatial or Covariate Dependencies}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2412.14477},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.14477},
}
Figure