Grant Report on SCH: Personalized Depression Treatment Supported by Mobile Sensor Analytics

Jayesh Kamath, Jinbo Bi, Alexander Russell, Bin WangJournal of Psychiatry and Brain Science 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces DepWatch, a novel mHealth system that leverages smartphone sensor data and machine learning to provide clinicians with real-time, objective insights into a patient's depression status. The goal is to move beyond subjective self-reports and infrequent clinical assessments to enable more personalized and timely treatment adjustments, ultimately improving patient outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current depression treatment often relies on a "trial and error" approach, with infrequent clinical follow-ups (typically every four weeks). This leads to delayed detection of treatment ineffectiveness or worsening symptoms, potentially causing significant harm to patients, including increased impairment, higher suicide risk, and premature treatment dropout. Furthermore, existing self-report questionnaires are subjective and prone to recall bias, failing to capture the day-to-day fluctuations in a patient's condition. The paper highlights the urgent need for a system that provides frequent, objective measurements and can predict treatment outcomes early on, allowing clinicians to make informed decisions and personalize care.

Methods

DepWatch is designed as a two-phase system. Phase I focuses on data collection and model development. It involves passively collecting sensory data (location, activity, social interaction) from participants' smartphones and wearable devices (Fitbit), alongside brief self-report questionnaires on mood, anxiety, medication adherence, tolerability, and safety. This data will be used to train machine learning models for assessing depression symptoms and predicting treatment response. A key aspect is the development of a web portal that will present these assessments and predictions to clinicians.

Phase II involves deploying the DepWatch system in a real-world clinical setting. Three clinicians will use the system to support their decision-making process for a cohort of 128 participants. The study will evaluate the usability and efficacy of DepWatch in assisting clinicians with treatment adjustments. The paper also mentions the development of new machine learning techniques, specifically focusing on longitudinal prediction and multi-task feature learning to handle complex, heterogeneous data.

Datasets

The study utilizes data collected from participants in two phases:

  • Phase I: Data from 250 adult participants with unstable depression initiating treatment. This includes:
  • Passive sensory data from smartphones (location, activity, social interaction).
  • Data from wearable devices (Fitbit) for physiological information (sleep, heart rate, activity).
  • Ecological Momentary Assessments (EMA) via daily questionnaires on mood and anxiety.
  • Weekly questionnaires on medication adherence, tolerability, and safety.
  • Clinical data, including QIDS (Quick Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology) scores and clinician assessments.
  • Phase II: Data from 128 participants treated by three clinicians. This phase focuses on evaluating the DepWatch system's usability and efficacy in a clinical setting.

The paper does not explicitly introduce new benchmark datasets but rather leverages data collected from participants for the development and validation of their models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging "Human Sensors": Smartphones and wearable devices can act as passive "human sensors," continuously collecting objective behavioral data that offers a more nuanced view of a patient's condition than infrequent self-reports.
  • Predicting Treatment Response Early: The presence or absence of early improvement (within the first two weeks) is a strong predictor of later treatment outcomes, highlighting the importance of timely assessment.
  • Personalized Treatment through Data Analytics: By integrating objective sensor data with self-reports and clinical assessments, DepWatch aims to provide clinicians with actionable insights to tailor treatment plans to individual patient needs.
  • Addressing Clinician Burden: The system is designed to be a decision support tool, prioritizing efficiency by identifying patients who require earlier evaluation, thus optimizing the use of limited clinical resources.
  • Moving Beyond Subjectivity: The core idea is to move away from subjective symptom reporting and towards objective, behavioral correlates of depression, offering a more reliable basis for clinical decisions.

Key Results

As this is a grant report on a newly started project, specific quantitative results from the completed studies are not yet available. The paper outlines the planned methodology and expected outcomes. The project is currently in its first year, with Phase I data collection and model development underway, and Phase II recruitment planned. The paper anticipates that DepWatch will be able to predict treatment response/non-response by capturing changes in behavioral patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Data Quality and Missing Data: The paper acknowledges that missing sensory data is a prevalent and severe problem, which will be further amplified by the diverse data collected in this project. Imputing missing data for entire views (e.g., a whole day of location data) is a significant challenge.
  • Complexity of Data: The data is complex and heterogeneous, requiring sophisticated machine learning techniques to handle.
  • Longitudinal Data Challenges: Longitudinal data is not independently and identically distributed, posing challenges for predictive modeling.

Future Work:

  • Robust Feature Extraction: Developing more robust feature extraction techniques to identify higher-level structures and semantic information from sensor data that are more strongly correlated with depression.
  • Advanced Machine Learning: Exploring multi-task feature learning (MTFL) and generative adversarial networks (GANs) for data imputation to address missing data challenges.
  • Clinical Integration: Designing the web portal in close collaboration with clinicians to ensure it is easily incorporated into clinical practice and provides valuable decision support.
  • Patient-Facing Features: Extending the system to provide information to patients for self-monitoring is identified as future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report on the newly started project "SCH: Personalized Depression Treatment Supported by Mobile Sensor Analytics". The current best practice guidelines for treating depression call for close monitoring of patients, and periodically adjusting treatment as needed. This project will advance personalized depression treatment by developing a system, DepWatch, that leverages mobile health technologies and machine learning tools. The objective of DepWatch is to assist clinicians with their decision making process in the management of depression. The project comprises two studies. Phase I collects sensory data and other data, e.g., clinical data, ecological momentary assessments (EMA), tolerability and safety data from 250 adult participants with unstable depression symptomatology initiating depression treatment. The data thus collected will be used to develop and validate assessment and prediction models, which will be incorporated into DepWatch system. In Phase II, three clinicians will use DepWatch to support their clinical decision making process. A total of 128 participants under treatment by the three participating clinicians will be recruited for the study. A number of new machine learning techniques will be developed.
BibTeX
@article{kamath2020grant,
  author = {Jayesh Kamath and Jinbo Bi and Alexander Russell and Bin Wang},
  title = {{Grant Report on SCH: Personalized Depression Treatment Supported by Mobile Sensor Analytics}},
  journal = {Journal of Psychiatry and Brain Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.20900/jpbs.20200010},
}
Figure