Graduate Education of Christian Universities in Modern China: A Case Study of Nanking University

Qi Liu, Xuemeng Cao, Chuanyi WangReligions 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the pioneering role of Christian universities in establishing graduate education in modern China, focusing on Nanking University as a case study. It argues that these institutions were not merely foreign imports but actively adapted Western educational models to a Chinese context, contributing significantly to the modernization of Chinese higher education and cultural exchange.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a gap in the existing literature on Christian universities in modern China. While much research has focused on their role in cultural exchange and broader societal modernization, the specific development and institutionalization of graduate education within these universities have been largely overlooked. The authors aim to shed light on how these institutions navigated the complexities of establishing degree-granting capabilities, adapting Western academic structures, and integrating them into the unique socio-historical landscape of China during a period of immense change. This includes understanding the motivations behind their pursuit of graduate education, the challenges they faced, and their eventual contributions to the nascent Chinese higher education system.

Methods

The study employs a case study approach, focusing on the University of Nanking as a representative example of Christian universities in modern China. The researchers utilized first-hand historical materials to conduct an in-depth analysis. This involved examining archival documents, university publications, and historical records to reconstruct the process of graduate education development. The methodology emphasizes historical analysis and narrative research to understand the evolution of Nanking University's graduate programs, from their inception to their institutionalization.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The research relies on historical documents and archives rather than quantitative datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Sinicization" of Western Education: Christian universities in China were not simply replicas of Western institutions. They actively adapted and integrated Western educational models with Chinese cultural contexts, a process the authors term "sinicization." This involved a dynamic exchange and collision of cultures.
  • Pioneering Graduate Education: Christian universities, particularly Nanking University, were at the forefront of establishing graduate education in China. They laid the groundwork for degree-granting systems and postgraduate training at a time when China's own higher education infrastructure was still developing.
  • Dual Identity and Legitimacy: These universities navigated a complex "dual identity," being funded by foreign entities while also seeking recognition and registration with the Chinese government. This quest for legitimacy was crucial for their development and the acceptance of their degrees.
  • Cultural Exchange and Modernization: Beyond academic pursuits, Christian universities served as vital conduits for Western scientific and cultural knowledge, bridging intellectual gaps and contributing to China's broader modernization efforts.
  • Adaptation of Curriculum and Pedagogy: The paper highlights how Nanking University, for instance, adapted its curriculum to include both Western scientific disciplines and Chinese cultural studies, reflecting a conscious effort to integrate diverse knowledge systems.

Key Results

  • The University of Nanking was one of the earliest Christian universities to develop graduate education, with efforts dating back to the early 20th century.
  • Nanking University obtained the right to award degrees through foreign accreditation (specifically, recognition by the University of New York), which provided a crucial foundation for its graduate programs.
  • The university established graduate training institutions and research institutes, such as the Research Institute of Chinese Culture, to foster specialized study and research.
  • By the 1930s, Nanking University had established graduate programs in fields like history, chemistry, and agricultural economics, adhering to government regulations for research institutes.
  • The University of Nanking was recognized as a Class A university by a 1928 U.S. standard classification, indicating its high academic standing and the eligibility of its graduates for American graduate programs.
  • By 1952, Nanking University had graduated 4475 students, including 26 postgraduates, who achieved notable success in their fields.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while Christian universities played a significant role, their contributions are sometimes viewed through the lens of cultural invasion. They suggest that further research is needed to fully explore the remarkable role Christian universities played in the nascent stages of graduate education in modern China. The paper itself focuses on Nanking University, and while presented as a case study, further comparative analyses of other Christian institutions could provide a more comprehensive understanding. The paper also implicitly points to the ongoing need to understand the complex interplay between foreign influence and indigenous development in shaping educational systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

From the late 19th century to the early 20th century, traditional Chinese society experienced a significant period of gradual development toward modernization. Along with the transformation of social institutions, people’s thoughts were also changing. Christian missionaries in China began to continue their mission by establishing Christian universities in the midst of the drastic changes in modern Chinese society. These Christian universities brought Western scientific and cultural knowledge to China, and gradually bridged the gap between the Chinese intellectual community and the outside world. From the acquisition of the right to award degrees to the approval of the Chinese government and, subsequently, to the development of graduate education localized in modern China, Christian universities have made new attempts on the ancient Chinese land. The existing literature, however, often ignores the cultural value and ideological enlightenment contributions made by these Christian universities. This paper attempts to describe the arduous exploration process of Christian universities, employing historical examples to analyze the motivations of Christian universities to develop degree education. The key argument of this article is that Christian universities in modern China are not only “imported” but also a product of “sinicization”, which represents the exchange and collision between Chinese and Western cultures during a special period of time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021graduate,
  author = {Qi Liu and Xuemeng Cao and Chuanyi Wang},
  title = {{Graduate Education of Christian Universities in Modern China: A Case Study of Nanking University}},
  booktitle = {Religions},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/rel12121095},
}
Figure