Governance Research of Chinese Rural Finance Exclusion Based on Peasant Survey

Cheng Hui-xia, Wentai WuAmerican 2014 · DOI

Abstract: The construction of people’s livelihood in rural areas not only needs to meet their basic requirements such as elders’ care, medical care, and insurance and so on, but also needs to encourage people living in rural areas and make them have confidence to earn a better live through the improvement of self-development ability. “Insufficiency of self-development ability” and “the lack of opportunity of development” are two of the most important barricades, which interact rural “finance exclusion” as both cause and effect and exert reciprocal intensification as well. The interviewing result from the 1938 random samples of local citizens living in villages and towns, which belong to 5 provinces and 26 counties and cities, shows that “lack of funds” is the hugest barricade that prevents peasants improving their self-development ability. The situation is mostly caused by “non-physical finance exclusion”. To govern this situation, the diversity of rural finance requirements and financial ecology cannot be separated and combination usage of different kinds of governance tools is needed.

Introduction: The Paradox of Rural Finance

For decades, the prevailing strategy for rural development in China was "supply-driven": the assumption was that building more banks would naturally eliminate poverty. However, while the number of rural financial outlets has surged, the income gap between urban and rural areas continues to widen. This paper addresses the paradox of financial exclusion—a state where individuals or groups cannot access necessary financial services like savings, loans, and insurance through formal channels despite physical proximity to institutions.

The authors argue that simply placing a bank in a village is insufficient. If the bank’s products do not match the peasants' self-development needs, or if social barriers prevent them from utilizing these services, the physical presence is moot. This study seeks to identify specific non-physical barriers and propose a governance framework to dismantle them.

Methodology

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach centered on a large-scale field survey conducted in the summer of 2012. The theoretical framework utilized the "Six Dimensions Model of Finance Exclusion" (developed by Kempson & Whyley), which categorizes exclusion into Physical, Access, Condition, Price, Marketing, and Self-Exclusion.

Using structural questionnaires and open-ended interviews, they gathered data from 1,938 random samples across five provinces: Jilin, Hubei, Sichuan, Gansu, and Qinghai. These regions represent diverse geographic and economic zones. The resulting data was analyzed using SPSS 11.0, focusing on how income levels and regional differences correlate with specific financial barriers.

Key Results: Borrowing Sources and Barriers

The survey revealed that "lack of funds" is the single largest obstacle to becoming wealthy across all surveyed provinces. While physical distance has decreased as a barrier, "Access Exclusion" (complicated procedures) and "Condition Exclusion" (lack of guarantors) have become the new gatekeepers.

Borrowing sources and institutional engagement across surveyed regions.

As shown in the survey data, "relatives and friends" remain the most accessible source of loans for peasants in most areas. However, formal institutions like Rural Credit Cooperatives and newly established "village banks" are gaining traction, particularly in provinces like Sichuan. Despite this, a significant service gap remains: while 59% of peasants had experience borrowing money, only 21% received "extra help" from financial institutions, such as investment knowledge or technical skills. The most frequently cited problems with formal rural finance were high interest rates, small credit amounts, and cumbersome loan procedures.

The Shift to Non-Physical Exclusion

A critical finding is the role of social capital, or Guanxi. In provinces like Jilin and Hubei, peasants identified social connections and "rake-offs" (informal fees or bribes) as significant barriers to securing loans. This suggests that rural finance is still heavily mediated by social networks rather than objective creditworthiness.

Furthermore, the authors argue that finance must transition from being a mere "safety net" for basic needs to a catalyst for "self-development ability." This means providing capital that allows peasants to transition from subsistence farming to entrepreneurship or specialized production. This requires a "demand-following" model where governance adapts to the specific financial "ecology" of different income groups.

Governance and Policy Implications

The paper provides a detailed matrix matching four peasant income levels—from "severely poor" to "rich"—with their specific financial demands. To govern this complex landscape, the authors suggest several institutional shifts:

  1. Institutionalizing Community Reinvestment: Drawing inspiration from the US Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), the authors suggest mandating that banks provide services in low-income areas to prevent capital flight from rural to urban centers.
  2. Diverse Governance Tools: Exploring how tax preferences and direct subsidies can encourage commercial banks to serve the "middle-income" group, who are currently caught between policy-based aid and commercial viability.
  3. Digital and Social Integration: Addressing the burgeoning factor of internet popularity and dismantling the Guanxi-based gatekeeping that currently defines access.

In conclusion, governing rural financial exclusion requires a combination of tools that respect the diversity of rural requirements. By focusing on non-physical barriers and fostering self-development, China can move toward a more inclusive and effective rural financial system.

Summary updated

Abstract

The construction of people’s livelihood in rural areas not only needs to meet their basic requirements such as elders’ care, medical care, and insurance and so on, but also needs to encourage people living in rural areas and make them have confidence to earn a better live through the improvement of self-development ability. “Insufficiency of self-development ability” and “the lack of opportunity of development” are two of the most important barricades, which interact rural “finance exclusion” as both cause and effect and exert reciprocal intensification as well. The interviewing result from the 1938 random samples of local citizens living in villages and towns, which belong to 5 provinces and 26 counties and cities, shows that “lack of funds” is the hugest barricade that prevents peasants improving their self-development ability. The situation is mostly caused by “non-physical finance exclusion”. To govern this situation, the diversity of rural finance requirements and financial ecology cannot be separated and combination usage of different kinds of governance tools is needed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huixia2014governance,
  author = {Cheng Hui-xia and Wentai Wu},
  title = {{Governance Research of Chinese Rural Finance Exclusion Based on Peasant Survey}},
  booktitle = {American},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.4236/ajibm.2014.410063},
}
Figure