TL;DR
This paper explores the governance challenges of "IP-izing" (turning into Intellectual Property) rural sports events in China, which have exploded in popularity due to digital empowerment. It argues that traditional governance models are insufficient and proposes a novel "five-in-one" collaborative mechanism to balance cultural authenticity with commercialization, ensuring sustainable development and community benefit.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In recent years, rural sports events in China, like the "Village Super League" and "Village BA," have gained immense popularity, becoming cultural phenomena with significant potential for IP development and rural revitalization. However, this rapid growth has outpaced existing governance structures. The paper identifies several key problems:
- Cultural Authenticity vs. Commercialization: Balancing the preservation of genuine local culture with the need for capital and professional operation to monetize IP.
- Short-Term Traffic vs. Long-Term Sustainability: Managing the ephemeral nature of digital attention to build lasting value beyond fleeting trends.
- Interest Imbalances: Ensuring fair distribution of benefits among diverse stakeholders (villagers, government, platforms, capital) and preventing the marginalization of villagers.
- The "Technological Paradox": Digital technology, while empowering, also introduces challenges like the digital divide, platform dependency, and potential cultural alienation.
Traditional governance models, whether government-led, market-driven, or villager-autonomous, are proving inadequate for this complex, digitally-infused ecosystem. The paper seeks to establish a new governance logic and mechanism for sustainable rural sports IP development.
Methods
This study employs a qualitative research paradigm, drawing on established theories to analyze the phenomenon. The core methodologies include:
- Governance Theory: To understand the principles and structures of managing complex systems.
- Digital Empowerment Theory: To analyze how digital technologies reshape power dynamics, production relations, and value chains.
- Co-evolutionary Theory: To examine the dynamic and interdependent development between rural sports events, digital technology, and governance.
- Grounded Theory Approaches: Used for theoretical speculation and qualitative exploration through logical deduction and mechanism analysis.
The paper doesn't rely on quantitative data or empirical modeling but rather on theoretical speculation and qualitative exploration to construct a conceptual framework.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Digital Technology as a Fundamental Force: Digital technology is not just a communication tool but a transformative force that reshapes production relations, organizational forms, and value chains for rural sports IP. It moves beyond "instrumental rationality" (efficiency) to "value rationality" (cultural and emotional resonance).
- The "Glocal" Value of Rural Sports IP: Digital empowerment helps connect the "glocal" (global and local) value of rural sports, making local culture accessible and appealing globally while retaining its local essence.
- Governance Paradoxes: Digitalization introduces complex paradoxes:
- Empowerment/Disempowerment: While giving voice, it can also create digital divides and dependency on platforms.
- Decentralization/Recentralization: The potential for decentralization is often countered by the concentration of power and data on major digital platforms.
- Authenticity/Performativity: The demand for "spectacular" content can lead to performative "rurality" rather than genuine authenticity.
- Efficiency/Alienation: Over-reliance on technology can lead to a focus on metrics over fundamental goals and a disconnect from humanistic values.
- Shift in Governance Logic is Crucial: The paper argues for a fundamental shift from "singular control" to "pluralistic collaboration," from "empirical decision-making" to "data-driven" governance, and from "rigid regulation" to "resilient good governance."
Key Results
The paper proposes a "five-in-one" collaborative governance mechanism framework designed to address the identified challenges. This framework includes:
- Subject-Responsibility Mechanism: Clearly defines the roles of five key actors:
- Government: "Helmsman" and "Servant" (design, regulation, public service).
- Villagers: "Protagonists" and "Inheritors" (cultural custodians, participants, supervisors).
- Digital Platforms: "Connectors" and "Amplifiers" (technical support, traffic distribution, ecosystem building).
- Market Capital: "Booster" and "Enabler" (funding, professional operation, market expansion).
- Professional Elites: "Think Tank" and "Supervisor" (consultation, third-party evaluation).
- Dynamic Mechanism: Focuses on "value co-creation and benefit sharing," promoting integration of rural sports IP with tourism, agriculture, education, and creative industries, and establishing "villager-centric" benefit distribution models (e.g., resource-as-shares, blockchain for transparent revenue).
- Coordination Mechanism: Emphasizes "digital negotiation and platform regulation" through integrated online-offline platforms and strengthening collaborative regulation of digital platforms.
- Guarantee Mechanism: Centers on "digital infrastructure and digital literacy," ensuring robust network coverage and systematic cultivation of villagers' digital skills.
- Deviation Correction Mechanism: Guided by "culture-centrism and risk prevention," establishing a "Culture-Centric" Dynamic Protection Principle and a "Technology + Humanities" Risk Early Warning System.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that this study is a theoretical speculative exploration and lacks in-depth fieldwork or embedded analysis of specific cases. They suggest that future research should:
- Combine concrete qualitative case studies to empirically test and refine the proposed governance framework.
- Continuously track the impact of rapidly evolving digital technologies (like AIGC and Metaverse) on rural society and adapt governance mechanisms accordingly, maintaining a high degree of openness and dynamic adaptability.
Summary updated