Abstract
This paper focuses on the question of what makes a good disciplinary or interdisciplinary problem. Drawing from literature across the STEM disciplines and two conference sessions, we provide insight into what makes a good problem within a specific discipline and across the disciplines. We use various frameworks to analyze a variety of problems that were nominated as exemplars by STEM education research experts. Common features identified include real-world connections, reinforcement of conceptual understanding, a "low floor and high ceiling," multiple solution paths, and building dispositions of professionals in the discipline. While a good problem need not have all of these features, in general, good problems have more of them. We also recognize that these problems are context-specific, as what may be considered a problem for one learner could be a trivial exercise for another. We discuss some of the challenges of designing good interdisciplinary problems and identify features that can make a problem interdisciplinary, including use of cross-cutting concepts and drawing on the specific expertise of each discipline.
Introduction: The Gap Between Exercises and Problems
In STEM education, there is a persistent gap between the "exercises" students usually perform—rote, algorithmic tasks—and the "problems" professionals actually solve, which are complex, ambiguous, and conceptually deep. While instructors intuitively seek "good" problems, there is little consensus on what that actually means across different fields. This research defines the anatomy of a "good" problem, distinguishing between rote exercises and tasks that foster authentic disciplinary thinking.
Methodology and Frameworks
The study is a qualitative synthesis based on two interdisciplinary conferences: Breaking Boundaries in STEM Education and Transforming Research in Undergraduate STEM Education (TRUSE). Utilizing a Discipline-Based Education Research (DBER) approach, experts from mathematics, physics, chemistry, and biology nominated exemplar problems. These exemplars—including the "Filling Bottles" calculus task, the physics-based "Superman: The Ride," the "Dino Problem" in biology, and the interdisciplinary "Fat Problem" (tracking mass loss)—were deconstructed using established educational frameworks, including Schoenfeld’s problem aesthetics and Bloom’s Taxonomy.
Key Insights
The Relativity of Problems
A central finding is that "problem-ness" is relative to the solver. If a student already possesses a ready-made mental schema to solve a task, it is merely an "exercise." A true problem must be calibrated to the learner's current expertise to require genuine cognitive effort and model-building.
Disciplinary Signatures and Interdisciplinarity
Different fields value different types of "goodness." Mathematics often favors deductive proof and theory building, while physics focuses on building simplified models of complex phenomena. True interdisciplinary problems are particularly challenging to design; they must avoid simply "skinning" one discipline's problem with another's context. Instead, they should require "cross-cutting concepts" (e.g., energy or conservation of mass) where the expertise of multiple fields is necessary for a complete solution.
Features of High-Quality STEM Problems
The synthesis identified five common features of high-quality problems:
- Real-world connections: Situating the problem in a recognizable, relevant context.
- Reinforcement of conceptual understanding: Moving beyond procedural "plug-and-chug" methods.
- Low floor and high ceiling: Ensuring the task is accessible to all students initially while offering nearly limitless depth for exploration.
- Multiple solution paths: Allowing students to reach answers through different logical frameworks (e.g., solving via forces vs. energy conservation).
- Building professional dispositions: Encouraging students to think and act like practitioners in their respective fields.
Challenges and Future Directions
A major hurdle is the "trivialization" of good problems during classroom implementation. Over-scaffolding by instructors can inadvertently turn a complex problem back into a rote exercise. Furthermore, mainstream textbooks remain dominated by "impoverished" tasks; research indicates that up to 90% of tasks in some calculus textbooks can be solved with superficial reasoning. Future work must focus on developing robust repositories of these problems and training instructors to facilitate them without stripping away their inherent cognitive demand.
Summary updated