Gluteus maximus tendon transfer as a salvage option for painful chronic hip abductor insufficiency: clinical and MRI results with a minimum follow-up of 24 months

Dominik Kaiser, Armando Hoch, Reto Sutter, Patrick O. ZinggHip 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness of transferring a portion of the gluteus maximus tendon as a last-resort surgical option for chronic, painful hip abductor insufficiency. While the procedure significantly reduced pain in patients, it had a limited impact on hip abductor strength and functional outcomes, suggesting it's a valuable pain-management tool rather than a functional restoration technique.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Chronic hip abductor insufficiency, often stemming from tears or degeneration of the gluteus medius and minimus muscles, is a debilitating condition that can lead to pain, instability, and gait abnormalities. When conservative treatments fail and direct repair of the damaged tendons isn't feasible due to advanced muscle degeneration (marked fatty infiltration), surgeons need salvage options. This paper addresses the need to evaluate a specific salvage technique: the gluteus maximus tendon transfer, to understand its clinical and imaging outcomes over a minimum of 24 months.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective review of 8 patients who underwent a gluteus maximus tendon transfer for chronic hip abductor insufficiency. These patients had failed conservative management, exhibited a positive Trendelenburg sign, and showed significant fatty degeneration of their hip abductor muscles on MRI. The surgical technique involved transferring the anterior third of the gluteus maximus tendon. Post-operatively, patients were evaluated using clinical assessments (pain scores via VAS, hip abductor strength via MRC, functional scores like Harris Hip Score and WOMAC, and gait analysis) and MRI to assess the integrity of the transferred tendon and the condition of the native abductor muscles.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on a small cohort of 8 patients treated at a single institution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pain Relief is the Primary Benefit: The most significant takeaway is that this transfer procedure excels at reducing pain, even in cases with severe muscle degeneration where direct repair is impossible. This highlights its value as a pain-management strategy.
  • Functional Restoration is Limited: While pain is reduced, the transfer doesn't substantially improve hip abductor strength or gait. This suggests the transferred tendon's biomechanical contribution is not a perfect replacement for the native abductors.
  • Tendon Healing is Reliable: MRI confirmed complete healing of the transferred tendon in all patients, indicating the surgical technique is robust in terms of graft integration.
  • No Stopping Muscle Degeneration: The fatty degeneration of the native gluteus medius and minimus muscles continued post-surgery, implying the transfer doesn't reverse or halt this underlying pathological process.
  • Realistic Expectations are Crucial: The authors emphasize the importance of managing patient expectations, as the goal is pain reduction, not necessarily a return to full hip abductor function.

Key Results

  • Pain Reduction: Postoperative VAS scores significantly decreased from an average of 5 to 2.5 (p=0.046).
  • Pain Medication: The need for daily painkillers decreased from 5 patients preoperatively to none postoperatively (p<0.026).
  • Hip Abductor Strength: Hip abductor strength showed a non-significant improvement from an average of 2.4 to 3.1 (p=0.19) on the MRC scale.
  • Trendelenburg Sign: The Trendelenburg sign remained positive in all patients postoperatively, indicating persistent pelvic instability during single-leg stance.
  • Functional Scores: Harris Hip Score (HHS) and WOMAC scores showed non-significant improvements.
  • Tendon Integrity: MRI confirmed complete healing of the transferred tendon in all patients with no re-ruptures.
  • Muscle Degeneration: Fatty degeneration of the gluteus medius and minimus muscles progressed in some patients post-surgery. The gluteus maximus muscle (both transferred and retained portions) showed no change in atrophy or fatty degeneration.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective Design: The study design is retrospective, which can introduce biases.
  • Small Sample Size: With only 8 patients, the study has limited statistical power, especially given the rarity of the condition.
  • Lack of Control Group: The absence of a control group makes it harder to definitively attribute all observed changes solely to the surgical intervention.

Future work should focus on larger, prospective studies to confirm these findings and potentially explore variations in the surgical technique or patient selection criteria. Further investigation into the reasons for continued muscle degeneration and the biomechanical limitations of the transfer would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the setting of painful chronic hip abductor insufficiency refractory to conservative treatment with advanced muscle degeneration without the possibility of a direct reconstruction the gluteus maximus tendon transfer significantly decreased pain. The effect on hip abductor strength and patient-reported functional outcome scores is limited. Despite the modest results it remains our preferred salvage treatment option for lack of better alternatives. Larger studies are necessary to confirm these findings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kaiser2023gluteus,
  author = {Dominik Kaiser and Armando Hoch and Reto Sutter and Patrick O. Zingg},
  title = {{Gluteus maximus tendon transfer as a salvage option for painful chronic hip abductor insufficiency: clinical and MRI results with a minimum follow-up of 24 months}},
  booktitle = {Hip},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1177/11207000231197760},
}
Figure