Global Weak Rigidity of the Gauss–Codazzi–Ricci Equations and Isometric Immersions of Riemannian Manifolds with Lower Regularity

Gui‐Qiang Chen, Siran LiJournal of Geometric Analysis 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the fundamental problem of whether geometric structures on manifolds, specifically the Gauss-Codazzi-Ricci (GCR) equations and isometric immersions, can be uniquely determined even when the underlying data is "rough" (lower regularity). The authors introduce a novel, intrinsic approach using div-curl structures and compensated compactness to prove global weak rigidity, offering new insights and extending previous local results.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper investigates the "rigidity" of geometric structures on Riemannian manifolds. Specifically, it asks: if we have a sequence of "rough" geometric objects (like metrics or immersions) that satisfy certain equations (the GCR equations), do they necessarily converge to a "smooth" object that also satisfies these equations? This is crucial for understanding how geometric properties behave under approximations and has implications for fields like nonlinear elasticity, where materials might not have perfectly smooth properties. Previous work focused on local rigidity and often relied on local coordinate systems. This paper aims to establish global weak rigidity in an intrinsic way, meaning the results hold across the entire manifold without needing to pick specific coordinate systems.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in developing a unified, intrinsic approach. Key techniques include:

  • Intrinsic Formulation of GCR Equations: The authors reformulate the GCR equations directly on the manifold, avoiding local coordinates.
  • Div-Curl Structure and Compensated Compactness: They leverage the div-curl structure inherent in the GCR equations and develop a global, intrinsic version of the div-curl lemma. This is a powerful tool from nonlinear analysis that helps control the convergence of sequences of functions.
  • General Functional-Analytic Compensated Compactness Theorem: A central contribution is a general theorem on Banach spaces that provides sufficient conditions for the convergence of sequences. This theorem is abstract but has the intrinsic div-curl lemma as a special case.
  • Cartan Formalism: The paper utilizes the Cartan formalism, a geometric tool for studying differential forms and connections, to establish equivalences between different formulations of the problem.
  • Analysis of Critical Cases: The authors specifically analyze the "critical case" where the regularity assumptions are at their limit (n=p=2 for 2D manifolds), which presents unique challenges.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intrinsic Global Rigidity: The most significant insight is the development of a method to prove global weak rigidity intrinsically. This means the results are independent of the observer's viewpoint (local coordinates) and apply to the entire manifold.
  • Unified Approach: The paper provides a single framework to tackle both the rigidity of the GCR equations and the rigidity of isometric immersions, highlighting their deep connection.
  • Div-Curl as a Geometric Tool: The paper demonstrates how the div-curl structure, typically used in fluid mechanics, can be a powerful intrinsic tool for analyzing geometric PDEs on manifolds.
  • Lower Regularity Matters: By focusing on "lower regularity" (e.g., $W^{1,p}$ metrics), the work addresses more realistic scenarios where geometric data might not be perfectly smooth, which is relevant for applications.

Key Results

  • Global Weak Rigidity Theorem for GCR Equations: The paper establishes a theorem proving the global weak rigidity of the GCR equations on Riemannian manifolds with $W^{1,p}$ metrics ($p>2$). This means that sequences of approximate solutions to these equations, even with rough data, converge to true solutions.
  • Equivalence of Formulations: The paper proves the equivalence of three key concepts: the GCR equations, the Cartan formalism, and the existence of isometric immersions, all under lower regularity conditions.
  • Analysis of Critical Case: The authors analyze the critical case ($n=p=2$) for 2D manifolds, showing that even with limited regularity, certain rigidity results can still be obtained, particularly for immersions into $\mathbb{R}^3$.
  • Alternative Proofs: The work provides new, intrinsic, and global proofs for existing results, offering deeper understanding and potentially simpler approaches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simply-Connected Manifolds: Many of the global results, particularly for isometric immersions, are established for simply-connected manifolds. The paper notes that extending these to general manifolds with non-trivial homotopy is an open problem due to topological obstructions.
  • Minimal Target Dimension: The paper touches upon the problem of global isometric immersions for minimal target dimensions (Janet dimension), acknowledging it remains largely open for general manifolds.
  • Higher Regularity for Immersions: While the GCR equations are analyzed for $W^{1,p}$ metrics, the resulting isometric immersions are shown to be $C^1$ (or $W^{2,p}$ for some results), which is a higher regularity than the input metric. The paper notes that achieving $C^1$ immersions from $W^{1,p}$ metrics is a standard requirement in differential geometry.

Summary updated

Abstract

We are concerned with the global weak rigidity of the Gauss-Codazzi-Ricci (GCR) equations on Riemannian manifolds and the corresponding isometric immersions of Riemannian manifolds into the Euclidean spaces. We develop a unified intrinsic approach to establish the global weak rigidity of both the GCR equations and isometric immersions of the Riemannian manifolds, independent of the local coordinates, and provide further insights of the previous local results and arguments. The critical case has also been analyzed. To achieve this, we first reformulate the GCR equations with div-curl structure intrinsically on Riemannian manifolds and develop a global, intrinsic version of the div-curl lemma and other nonlinear techniques to tackle the global weak rigidity on manifolds. In particular, a general functional-analytic compensated compactness theorem on Banach spaces has been established, which includes the intrinsic div-curl lemma on Riemannian manifolds as a special case. The equivalence of global isometric immersions, the Cartan formalism, and the GCR equations on the Riemannian manifolds with lower regularity is established. We also prove a new weak rigidity result along the way, pertaining to the Cartan formalism, for Riemannian manifolds with lower regularity, and extend the weak rigidity results for Riemannian manifolds with corresponding different metrics.
BibTeX
@article{chen2017global,
  author = {Gui‐Qiang Chen and Siran Li},
  title = {{Global Weak Rigidity of the Gauss–Codazzi–Ricci Equations and Isometric Immersions of Riemannian Manifolds with Lower Regularity}},
  journal = {Journal of Geometric Analysis},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/s12220-017-9893-1},
}
Figure