TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel "agricultural water scarcity index" (WSI<sub>AW</sub>) that accounts for both "blue water" (surface and groundwater) and "green water" (soil moisture) to provide a more comprehensive assessment of water scarcity in crop production. This new index reveals that water scarcity is more widespread than previously thought, particularly in rainfed agricultural regions, and highlights the increasing severity of this issue globally.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Global water scarcity is a growing concern, impacting food security and economic development. Traditional assessments of water scarcity have primarily focused on "blue water" resources, overlooking the crucial role of "green water" (soil moisture) in supporting rainfed agriculture, which accounts for a significant portion of global cropland. This oversight leads to an underestimation of water scarcity, especially in regions heavily reliant on rainfed farming. Furthermore, the long-term trends and drivers of water scarcity, particularly when considering both water types, have remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and applying a more holistic water scarcity index.
Methods
The core of this research is the development of the Agricultural Green + Blue Water Scarcity Index (WSI<sub>AW</sub>). This index is defined as the ratio of crop water demand (specifically, potential evapotranspiration, ET<sub>c</sub>, under non-stressed conditions) to the total available water for crops, which includes both green water availability for ET (GWA<sub>ET</sub>) and blue water availability for ET (BWA<sub>ET</sub>).
- Crop Water Demand (ET<sub>c</sub>): Calculated using potential evapotranspiration (PET) and crop-specific coefficients that vary across different growth stages (initial, development, middle, late).
- Green Water Availability (GWA<sub>ET</sub>): Estimated based on soil moisture content, wilting point, and field capacity, representing the water available from soil moisture within the rooting depth. This method converts green water from a "stock" to a "flow" to be consistent with blue water assessments.
- Blue Water Availability for ET (BWA<sub>ET</sub>): Calculated by subtracting environmental flow requirements (EFR) and withdrawals for other sectors (BWW<sub>OS</sub>) from total renewable blue water availability (BWA), and then adjusted for irrigation efficiency (IE).
The researchers then applied this WSI<sub>AW</sub> to assess water scarcity globally at a 0.5 arc degree spatial resolution for the period 1971-2010. They also compared these results with the traditional blue water scarcity index (WSI<sub>BW</sub>) and analyzed trends and uncertainties at both grid cell and river basin levels.
Datasets
The study utilized several global datasets:
- Hydrological Models: Monthly potential evapotranspiration (PET) and blue water availability (BWA) were simulated by four large-scale hydrological models: H08, LPJmL, PCR-GLOBWB, and WaterGAP2. These models were forced by WFDEI climate data.
- Water Withdrawal Data: Monthly water withdrawal data for irrigation (IWW) and other sectors (BWW<sub>OS</sub>) were provided by Huang et al. (2018), reconstructed from FAO AQUASTAT, USGS data, and ISIMIP2a simulations.
- Cropland Area Data: Annual cropland area data for the assessment period were based on land use datasets from ISIMIP2a, derived from HYDE 3.0 and MIRCA2000.
- Crop Growing Season Data: Growing season lengths for 19 major crops were obtained from the MIRCA2000 dataset.
- Soil Moisture Data: Monthly rooting zone soil moisture was provided by the PCR-GLOBWB model.
- River Basin Boundaries: Data for 228 hydrological basins were obtained from the FAO GeoNetwork.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Green Water Matters: The most significant insight is the critical role of green water in agricultural water scarcity. Ignoring it leads to a substantial underestimation of water-stressed regions, particularly those relying on rainfed agriculture.
- Broader Scarcity: The WSI<sub>AW</sub> reveals that water scarcity affects a much larger geographical area than traditional blue water-only assessments. This highlights the vulnerability of rainfed agriculture to water limitations.
- Increasing Severity: The study demonstrates a clear trend of increasing water scarcity globally over the study period, driven by factors like expanding croplands and competing water demands from other sectors.
- Rainfed vs. Irrigated: The WSI<sub>AW</sub> effectively differentiates between water scarcity in rainfed and irrigated areas, a distinction often blurred in blue water-only assessments.
- Drivers of Scarcity: The research pinpoints expanding cropland and increasing non-agricultural water withdrawals as key drivers of intensifying water scarcity, especially in Asia and Africa.
Key Results
- Wider Coverage: Approximately 22% of the 228 river basins studied experienced water scarcity (WSI<sub>AW</sub> > 1), compared to only 8% when considering blue water alone (WSI<sub>BW</sub> > 1).
- Global Trends: The WSI<sub>AW</sub> showed a clear trend of increasing severity over the 1971-2010 period, particularly in major agricultural regions.
- Regional Differences: While WSI<sub>BW</sub> was high in intensively irrigated areas, WSI<sub>AW</sub> indicated higher scarcity in rainfed crop areas, such as parts of sub-Saharan Africa, Spain, and eastern Brazil.
- Specific River Basins: The Niger River basin, dominated by rainfed agriculture, showed a significant increase in WSI<sub>AW</sub>, highlighting the impact of cropland expansion. In contrast, the Haihe basin, with high non-agricultural water withdrawals, showed a different scarcity pattern.
Limitations and Future Work
- Crop Water Demand Assumption: The study used potential evapotranspiration (ET<sub>c</sub>) as crop water demand, assuming no stress. This might overestimate demand in regions where crop growth is limited by other factors like nutrient stress. Future work could explore ET<sub>c</sub> estimation based on reference evapotranspiration (ET<sub>o</sub>) or incorporate other limiting factors.
- Environmental Flow Requirements (EFR): The EFR was estimated using a single method (VMF). The authors acknowledge that different EFR methods can lead to varying scarcity assessments, suggesting basin-specific EFR analysis as a future research direction.
- Irrigation Efficiency (IE): The use of fixed IE values and the potential overestimation of WSI<sub>AW</sub> due to the inclusion of leaching losses in IE were noted. Future studies could benefit from more refined IE data and a clearer distinction between recoverable and non-recoverable losses.
- Other Sectoral Demands: The WSI<sub>AW</sub> primarily focuses on agricultural water scarcity. While this is a major driver, it doesn't explicitly reflect scarcity caused by other sectors. The authors suggest that using both WSI<sub>AW</sub> and WSI<sub>BW</sub> provides a more complete picture for water resource management.
- Spatial Scales: The methods are applicable across various spatial scales, but uncertainties in input data and estimation remain a challenge.
Summary updated