Global trends and predictors of face mask usage during the COVID-19 pandemic

Badillo-Goicoechea Elena, Chang Ting-Hsuan, Kim Esther, LaRocca Sarah, Morris Katherine, Deng Xiaoyi, Chiu Samantha, Bradford Adrianne, Garcia Andres, Kern Christoph, Cobb Curtiss, Kreuter Frauke, Stuart Elizabeth A.BMC Public Health 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This study leverages a massive dataset of over 13 million responses from 38 countries to map global trends in face mask usage during the COVID-19 pandemic. It reveals that while mask-wearing increased over time, its adoption varied significantly by country, with individual demographics, risky social behaviors, and policy stringency being key predictors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the COVID-19 pandemic unfolded, face masks became a critical public health tool. However, understanding the global adoption patterns and the factors influencing mask-wearing behavior was crucial for effective public health messaging and policy. Previous studies were often limited by small sample sizes, narrow geographical scope, or short timeframes, making it difficult to draw broad conclusions. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a large-scale, longitudinal analysis of mask usage across diverse countries.

Methods

The researchers employed a survey-weighted multivariable logistic regression model to analyze the data. This statistical approach is standard for examining associations between various factors and a binary outcome (in this case, mask usage). The novelty lies in the scale and scope of the data:

  • Large-scale survey data: They utilized responses from the COVID-19 Symptom Survey, a daily cross-sectional online survey.
  • Country-level data integration: They incorporated country-level mask policy stringency data and COVID-19 case data.
  • Longitudinal analysis: The study tracked trends over a significant period (April to October 2020).
  • Two-stage weighting: Facebook's methodology for weighting the survey data was used to ensure representativeness.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was the COVID-19 Symptom Survey, a daily online survey conducted by the University of Maryland and Carnegie Mellon University in partnership with Facebook. This survey collected data from over 13.7 million respondents across 38 countries between April 23, 2020, and October 31, 2020.

Additional data sources included:

  • University of Oxford's Our World in Data: For country-level mask policy stringency.
  • Johns Hopkins University's COVID-19 data repository: For country-day-level COVID-19 cases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Global Mask Adoption is Heterogeneous: It's not a one-size-fits-all story. Mask usage evolved very differently across countries, highlighting the influence of local contexts, policies, and potentially cultural factors.
  • "Risky" Behaviors Correlate with Lower Mask Use: Engaging in activities like attending large public events, socializing outside the home, or dining out was associated with less mask-wearing. This suggests that people who are more inclined to engage in these activities might be less concerned about transmission or less compliant with mask recommendations.
  • Policy Stringency Matters: Stricter government policies mandating or recommending mask use were strongly associated with higher mask usage. This underscores the impact of public health directives on individual behavior.
  • Demographics Play a Role: Older individuals, females, and those living in urban areas were more likely to wear masks. This points to potential differences in risk perception, social norms, or access to information across demographic groups.

Key Results

  • Prevalence: Mask-wearing varied significantly across the 38 countries. Some countries maintained high prevalence (>70%) throughout the study period, while others remained consistently low (<15%).
  • Temporal Trends: Mask usage generally increased over time from April to October 2020, but the pace and extent of this increase differed greatly by country.
  • Predictors of Higher Mask Usage:
    • Older age (e.g., 65+ years: OR 1.47)
    • Female gender (OR 1.70)
    • Living in an urban area (OR 1.40)
    • Stricter mask policies (per 1 standard deviation increase: OR 1.58)
    • Having been tested for COVID-19 (OR 1.59)
  • Predictors of Lower Mask Usage:
    • Attending large public events (OR 0.45)
    • Socializing outside the household (OR 0.72)
    • Going to a restaurant/cafe/shopping center (OR 0.77)
    • Working outside the home (OR 0.98)
  • Lagged COVID-19 Cases: Interestingly, higher lagged COVID-19 cases were associated with less mask-wearing (OR 0.93), which is counterintuitive and warrants further investigation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Self-reported data: Mask usage was self-reported, which can be subject to recall bias or social desirability bias.
  • Non-experimental design: The study cannot establish causation, only associations.
  • Missing data for socioeconomic factors: Years of education, financial worry, and employment status were not collected for the entire study period, although a secondary model was used to address this.
  • Facebook user base: The data is drawn from Facebook users, which may not perfectly represent the entire population of each country.

Future work could explore the unobserved cultural phenomena that contribute to cross-country differences in mask adoption. Further research could also investigate the counterintuitive finding that higher COVID-19 cases were associated with lower mask usage. The findings also suggest a need for more targeted policy and messaging design to address specific populations and behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Guidelines and recommendations from public health authorities related to face masks have been essential in containing the COVID-19 pandemic. We assessed the prevalence and correlates of mask usage during the pandemic. Methods: We examined a total of 13,723,810 responses to a daily cross-sectional representative online survey in 38 countries who completed from April 23, 2020 to October 31, 2020 and reported having been in public at least once during the last seven days. The outcome was individual face mask usage in public settings, and the predictors were country fixed effects, country-level mask policy stringency, calendar time, individual sociodemographic factors, and health prevention behaviors. Associations were modelled using survey-weighted multivariable logistic regression. Findings: Mask-wearing varied over time and across the 38 countries. While some countries consistently showed high prevalence throughout, in other countries mask usage increased gradually, and a few other countries remained at low prevalence. Controlling for time and country fixed effects, sociodemographic factors (older age, female gender, education, urbanicity) and stricter mask-related policies were significantly associated with higher mask usage in public settings, while social behaviors considered risky in the context of the pandemic (going out to large events, restaurants, shopping centers, and socializing outside of the household) were associated with lower mask use. Interpretation: The decision to wear a face mask in public settings is significantly associated with sociodemographic factors, risky social behaviors, and mask policies. This has important implications for health prevention policies and messaging, including the potential need for more targeted policy and messaging design.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{elena2022global,
  author = {Badillo-Goicoechea Elena and Chang Ting-Hsuan and Kim Esther and LaRocca Sarah and Morris Katherine and Deng Xiaoyi and Chiu Samantha and Bradford Adrianne and Garcia Andres and Kern Christoph and Cobb Curtiss and Kreuter Frauke and Stuart Elizabeth A.},
  title = {{Global trends and predictors of face mask usage during the COVID-19 pandemic}},
  booktitle = {BMC Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=CjGCHo8O70},
}
Figure