Global mining is diminishing the effectiveness of Protected Areas in forest conservation

Tingting He, He Ren, Yihua Hu, Yanling Zhao, Youpeng Lu, Fashuai Li, Maoxin Zhang, Jianyong Zhang, Hongtao Cao, Huicai Yang, Wu Jin, Zhipei Sun, Jianyu Wang, Yuwei ChenResearch Square 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

While Protected Areas (PAs) are the "gold standard" for conservation, global mining is increasingly breaching these boundaries. This study reveals that nearly 20% of mining-induced forest loss now occurs within PAs, with a massive "leakage" effect causing 2.5 times more deforestation in the immediate 10km buffer zones surrounding these protected sites.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Protected Areas are designed to be sanctuaries for biodiversity, yet they face mounting pressure from industrial activities. While agriculture and urbanization are frequently cited as primary drivers of deforestation, mining is often dismissed as a "secondary" factor.

The authors argue that this oversight is dangerous. Mining is uniquely destructive because it involves the total removal of soil and vegetation, leading to irreversible ecological loss. This paper provides the first comprehensive global spatiotemporal analysis to quantify exactly how much forest we are losing to mining both inside PAs and in their immediate vicinity, challenging the assumption that "protected" means "off-limits" to heavy industry.

Methods

The researchers conducted a multi-layered spatiotemporal analysis by integrating four major types of geospatial data. The core of their approach involved:

  • Spatial Overlay: Overlaying annual forest loss data with mining land-use polygons and PA boundaries to attribute specific deforestation events to mining.
  • Buffer Analysis: Establishing 1–10 km "buffer zones" around PAs to measure "neighborhood leakage"—the phenomenon where industrial activity is pushed just outside a protected boundary, still impacting the ecosystem.
  • Active Mining Assessment: A novel classification system to identify "active" mines. A mine was deemed active if:
  • Forest loss was detected for three consecutive years (2018–2020).
  • Recent forest loss (2018–2020) accounted for more than 20% of the total loss since 2000.
  • Biomass Analysis: Using Aboveground Biomass (AGB) density maps to determine not just how much forest was lost, but the quality (carbon density) of that forest.

Datasets

The study relied on several high-resolution global datasets:

  • Global Forest Change (GFC): 30-meter resolution data (Hansen et al.) to track annual forest loss.
  • World Database on Protected Areas (WDPA): The February 2022 version, categorized by IUCN strictness levels.
  • Global-scale Mining Land Use Dataset: Derived from visual interpretation of Sentinel-2 and Google Earth imagery.
  • Global Forest AGB Density Map: To assess the carbon and biomass implications of the loss.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Leakage" Effect: The most striking finding is that forest loss within a 10km buffer of a PA is ~2.5 times higher than inside the PA. This suggests that while PAs might stop some direct mining, they often just displace the environmental damage to the immediate doorstep of the protected zone.
  • Rising Incursion: The proportion of mining-induced forest loss occurring inside PAs is growing. It was ~11% over the last two decades but has surged to ~19% in the last five years.
  • Targeting High-Value Carbon Sinks: We aren't just losing "any" forest; we are losing high-biomass forests. In South America, the average biomass density of forests lost to mining outside PAs has actually surpassed the density of those inside PAs.
  • Strictness vs. Vulnerability: While "strict" PAs (IUCN categories Ia, Ib) generally perform better at reducing total forest loss area than "non-strict" ones, they appear more susceptible to the specific pressures of mining in certain regions, particularly in Asia.

Key Results

  • Total Impact: Between 2000 and 2020, global mining directly caused ~13,630 km² of forest loss.
  • Inside the Gates: Approximately 1,486 km² of that loss occurred within PA boundaries.
  • Active Threats: 586 mines (28% of those identified) remain active within PAs, posing a continuous threat.
  • Regional Hotspots: Brazil and Indonesia account for over one-third of global mining-induced forest loss. In South America, the proportion of loss occurring within PAs has averaged over 40% in the last three years.
  • The 10km Buffer: Forest loss in the 10km buffer reached ~3,848 km², highlighting the massive indirect footprint of mining infrastructure (roads, settlements).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several challenges and areas for further study:

  • Indirect Impacts: The study focuses primarily on the direct footprint of mining. However, indirect impacts—such as "ghost roads" and infrastructure that facilitate further encroachment—can extend up to 70km beyond a mining concession.
  • Governance Gaps: The paper notes that preventing mining is exceptionally difficult in resource-rich but economically underdeveloped countries with fragile governance.
  • Policy Integration: Future work needs to focus on how to integrate mining policy into broader conservation frameworks, rather than treating PAs as isolated islands. The authors urge for "30x30" goals to include not just the size of protected areas, but the quality of management regarding industrial extraction.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Protected areas (PAs) are fundamental cornerstone for global forest conservation, yet human activities have increasingly threatened them in recent years. While mining, a highly destructive but profitable economic activity, is often considered a secondary driver in forest loss compared to other human activities. Here, we conduct a spatiotemporal analysis to evaluate the effectiveness of PAs in mitigating forest loss associated with global mining. Our result reveals that from 2000 to 2020, ~11% (~1486 km<sup>2</sup>) of mining-induced forest loss occurred within PAs boundaries, a figure that has risen to ~19% over the past five years. Furthermore, ~28% (586 mines) still remain active, posing a continuous threat to forest integrity. We also find forests beyond boundaries are experiencing severe neighborhood leakage effects, with the forest loss within a ten-kilometer buffer being ~2.5 fold that of within PAs. Notably, temporal analysis further indicates that the loss is occurring in areas with higher average forest aboveground biomass (AGB) density. In South America, the average AGB density of forest loss beyond PAs boundaries has exceeded that within PAs over the past five years, far surpassing the global average. We urge the enhancement of protection quality and management strategies both within PAs and in surrounding buffer zones, ensuring their long-term contribution to global forest conservation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2025global,
  author = {Tingting He and He Ren and Yihua Hu and Yanling Zhao and Youpeng Lu and Fashuai Li and Maoxin Zhang and Jianyong Zhang and Hongtao Cao and Huicai Yang and Wu Jin and Zhipei Sun and Jianyu Wang and Yuwei Chen},
  title = {{Global mining is diminishing the effectiveness of Protected Areas in forest conservation}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-6318099/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure