Abstract: We present updated global fits of the constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (cMSSM), including the most recent constraints from the ATLAS and CMS detectors at the LHC, as well as the most recent results of the XENON100 experiment. Our robust analysis takes into account both astrophysical and hadronic uncertainties that enter in the calculation of the rate of WIMP-induced recoils in direct detection experiment. We study the consequences for neutralino Dark Matter, and show that current direct detection data already allow to robustly rule out the so-called Focus Point region, therefore demonstrating the importance of particle astrophysics experiments in constraining extensions of the Standard Model of Particle Physics. We also observe an increased compatibility between results obtained from a Bayesian and a Frequentist statistical perspective. We find that upcoming ton-scale direct detection experiments will probe essentially the entire currently favoured region (at the 99% level), almost independently of the statistical approach used. Prospects for indirect detection of the cMSSM are further reduced.
Introduction
This study, conducted shortly after the initial results from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and the XENON100 dark matter experiment, provides a comprehensive "health check" for the constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (cMSSM). By combining early LHC data with direct detection results, the authors demonstrate that the "Focus Point" region of the cMSSM is now robustly excluded, signaling that astrophysical searches for Dark Matter (DM) are becoming as powerful as collider experiments in narrowing the search for new physics.
Methodology
The authors employ a "Global Fit" approach, scanning the multi-dimensional parameter space of the cMSSM to identify regions consistent with all known experimental data. This involves comparing two major statistical philosophies: Bayesian inference (producing posterior probability distributions) and Frequentist profiling (identifying best-fit points). The study utilizes the MultiNest algorithm to efficiently explore high-dimensional spaces.
A key innovation in this work is the treatment of "nuisance parameters." These represent uncertainties in the local density of dark matter, the velocity of the Earth through the DM halo, and the internal quark structure of the proton. By treating these as variables rather than constants, the conclusions remain robust against astrophysical and nuclear physics uncertainties.
Experimental Datasets and Constraints
The study integrates a wide array of experimental data to constrain the cMSSM parameter space:
- LHC Data: Early 7 TeV proton-proton collision data from ATLAS and CMS (approx. 35 $pb^{-1}$ of luminosity).
- Direct Detection: Results from the XENON100 experiment (100.9 live days).
- Cosmology: DM relic density measurements from the WMAP 7-year dataset.
- Precision Physics: LEP limits on the Higgs boson mass, the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon $(g-2)_\mu$, and various rare B-physics decays.
Key Insights and Results
The End of the Focus Point
Historically, the cMSSM had several favored regions, including the "Focus Point" (FP) region where the neutralino has a significant Higgsino component. While attractive for explaining observed dark matter levels, the FP region predicts a high scattering cross-section that XENON100 should have detected. This analysis shows the FP region is now ruled out at the 95% confidence level, even when accounting for conservative astrophysical and hadronic uncertainties.
Statistical Convergence and Best-Fits
As experimental constraints tighten, Bayesian and Frequentist methods are beginning to converge on the same favored regions of parameter space. The most likely mass for the lightest neutralino (the DM candidate) is found to be in the 150–250 GeV range. Furthermore, the exclusion of the FP region significantly diminishes the prospects for indirect detection via high-energy neutrinos from the Sun, as the remaining regions have much lower scattering rates.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The study predicts that upcoming ton-scale experiments, such as XENON1T, will probe nearly 99% of the remaining favored cMSSM parameter space. While these conclusions are specific to the constrained MSSM, they highlight a shift where underground detectors are actively excluding theoretical models ahead of collider reach. Future work will benefit from higher LHC energies and improved lattice QCD calculations to reduce the dominant hadronic uncertainties in direct detection predictions.
Summary updated