Global dynamics of a dengue fever model incorporating transmission seasonality

Min Zhu, Tingting Feng, Yong Xu, Jinde CaoNonlinear 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a sophisticated mathematical model for dengue fever that accounts for both seasonal changes (time-periodicity) and geographical differences (spatial heterogeneity). By analyzing a reaction-diffusion system, the researchers define a basic reproduction number ($R_0$) that acts as a strict threshold: if $R_0 \le 1$, the disease eventually vanishes; if $R_0 > 1$, it persists in a predictable seasonal cycle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dengue fever is a major global health crisis, often cited as the fastest-spreading mosquito-borne disease. Its transmission is notoriously complex because it depends on the intersection of human activity and mosquito biology, both of which are heavily influenced by the environment.

Most traditional models simplify this by assuming either a uniform environment or a constant climate. However, in reality, temperature and rainfall vary by month (seasonality) and by location (spatial heterogeneity). Previous research often struggled to provide a complete picture of "global stability"—the mathematical certainty that a disease will either die out or persist regardless of the initial number of cases. This paper fills that gap by providing a rigorous proof for the threshold dynamics of a model that incorporates these real-world fluctuations.

Methods

The authors employ a reaction-diffusion system consisting of four partial differential equations (PDEs). These equations track the density of susceptible and infectious humans ($S_h, I_h$) and mosquitoes ($S_v, I_v$) across a spatial habitat over time.

Key methodological highlights include:

  • Next-Generation Operator Theory: To calculate $R_0$ for a system that changes over time and space, the authors use the spectral radius of a "next infection operator" rather than a simple matrix.
  • Monotone Dynamical Systems: They use the theory of monotone flows and the method of upper and lower solutions to prove that the system's behavior is globally predictable.
  • Periodic Parameterization: Unlike simpler models, they assume that almost all biological parameters—including human birth/death rates, mosquito recruitment, and biting rates—are time-periodic functions.
  • Numerical Simulation: They apply the model to Guangzhou, China, using 2020 temperature data to fit trigonometric (Fourier) series for temperature-dependent variables like biting rates.

Datasets

While this is primarily a theoretical modeling paper, the authors validated their work using real-world data points for Guangzhou, China (2020):

  • Population Data: Permanent resident density and human mortality rates were sourced from the Guangzhou Statistical Yearbook [32].
  • Climate Data: Monthly mean temperatures for Guangzhou in 2020 were used to drive the seasonal parameters [36].
  • Biological Parameters: Biting rates and transmission probabilities were derived from established entomological studies [13, 17].

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The $R_0 = 1$ Boundary: A significant contribution of this paper is the inclusion of the $R_0 = 1$ case. Many previous studies only looked at $R_0 < 1$ or $R_0 > 1$. The authors prove that even at the exact threshold of $R_0 = 1$, the disease-free state remains globally stable.
  • Succinct Conditions: The authors provide more streamlined mathematical conditions for stability than previous iterations of similar models, making the theory more accessible for future epidemiological applications.
  • Diffusion Sensitivity: The paper discusses how the movement (diffusion) of humans and mosquitoes affects the outbreak risk. They explore "limiting forms" of $R_0$, showing how the threshold changes as species become more or less mobile.
  • Seasonal "Aha": The numerical simulations clearly show that even when a disease persists ($R_0 > 1$), it doesn't stay at a flat level; it settles into a "positive periodic solution" that mirrors the seasonal temperature cycles.

Key Results

  • Mathematical Threshold: The researchers proved that $R_0$ is the unique decider of long-term disease dynamics.
  • Guangzhou Case Study:
    • Extinction Scenario: By setting mosquito recruitment ($A$) to a low value ($0.0008 \times$ human population), they calculated an $R_0 \approx 0.6325$. Simulations showed the infectious populations ($I_h, I_v$) decaying to zero.
  • Persistence Scenario: By increasing recruitment ($A$) to $2.40 \times$ human population, the $R_0$ jumped to $\approx 3.6858$. The simulation showed the disease stabilizing into a fluctuating seasonal pattern, confirming the existence of a "global attractor."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Constant Human Population: The model assumes the total human population ($N_h$) is constant over time. While reasonable for short-term outbreaks, it may not capture long-term demographic shifts.
  • Rainfall Omission: While temperature is a primary driver, mosquito breeding is also heavily dependent on rainfall and humidity, which are not explicitly modeled here.
  • Human Mobility: The model uses standard diffusion (random walk). In reality, human movement is often directed (commuting, travel), which might require more complex "patch" models or non-local diffusion terms.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that their framework could be extended to include vaccine injection strategies or large-scale mosquito eradication programs to see how these interventions shift the $R_0$ threshold in a seasonal environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

The changes of seasons cause that the transmission of dengue fever is characterized by periodicity. We develop a dengue fever transmission model incorporating seasonal periodicity and spatial heterogeneity. Based on the well-posedness of solution for this model, we propose its basic reproduction number R0, and we discuss the properties of this number including its limiting form when the diffusion coefficients change. Moreover, the dynamical behavior of this model infers that if R0 ⩽ 1, then the disease-free periodic solution is globally asymptotically stable, and if R0 &gt; 1, then the model possesses a positive periodic solution, which is globally asymptotically stable. These theoretical findings are further illustrated by the final numerical simulations. Additionally, we add that the similar problem has been investigated by M. Zhu and Y. Xu [A time-periodic dengue fever model in a heterogeneous environment, Math. Comput. Simul., 155:115–129, 2019] in which some dynamical results have been studied only on the cases R0 &lt; 1 and R0 &gt; 1. Our results not only include the scenario on the case R0 = 1, but also involve the more succinct conditions on the cases R0 &lt; 1 and R0 &gt; 1.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2023global,
  author = {Min Zhu and Tingting Feng and Yong Xu and Jinde Cao},
  title = {{Global dynamics of a dengue fever model incorporating transmission seasonality}},
  booktitle = {Nonlinear},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.15388/namc.2023.28.31958},
}
Figure