Global budget of methanol: Constraints from atmospheric observations

Daniel J. Jacob, Brendan D. Field, Qinbin Li, D. R. Blake, J. A. de Gouw, C. Warneke, Armin Hansel, Armin Wisthaler, H. B. Singh, Alex GuentherJournal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a global chemical transport model (GEOS-CHEM) to reconcile atmospheric methanol observations with current understanding of its sources and sinks. By incorporating a more nuanced plant emission model and atmospheric production pathways, the researchers refine the global methanol budget, estimating a total source of 240 Tg yr⁻¹, and highlight areas where our understanding remains incomplete, particularly in the remote troposphere.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The atmospheric budget of methanol, a significant organic gas, has been poorly understood, with previous estimates showing large discrepancies. This lack of clarity hinders its use as a tracer for other atmospheric processes and its role in the broader atmospheric chemistry. Specifically, previous models struggled to accurately reproduce observed seasonal variations and regional concentrations, suggesting missing or misrepresented sources and sinks. This paper aims to constrain the global methanol budget by comparing a detailed chemical transport model simulation with a comprehensive set of atmospheric observations.

Methods

The researchers employed the GEOS-CHEM global 3-D chemical transport model, driven by assimilated meteorological data. They incorporated detailed representations of methanol sources, including plant growth (with a new parameterization accounting for leaf age), plant decay, biomass burning, biofuels, urban emissions, and atmospheric production via CH₃O₂ radical reactions. For sinks, they included gas-phase oxidation by OH, dry and wet deposition, and ocean uptake. The model was run for a full year (2001) and its output was compared against a wide range of atmospheric observations from surface stations, aircraft, and ships. Tagged tracers were used to track the contributions of individual methanol sources.

Datasets

The study utilized the GEOS-3 assimilated meteorological observations from the NASA Global Modeling and Assimilation Office to drive the GEOS-CHEM model. For evaluation, the paper draws upon a comprehensive collection of atmospheric methanol measurements from various sources:

  • Surface air measurements: Including records reviewed by Heikes et al. [2002], and specific measurements from Innsbruck, Austria [Holzinger et al., 2001].
  • Aircraft missions: TRACE-P (North Pacific), TOPSE (North American Arctic), SONEX (North Atlantic), MINOS (Eastern Mediterranean), ITCT-2K2 (Northeast Pacific), and PEM-Tropics B (South Pacific).
  • Ship cruises: INDOEX (Indian Ocean) and AOE-2001 (Arctic Ocean).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leaf age matters: Accounting for the difference in methanol emission between young and mature leaves is crucial for accurately simulating seasonal variations, especially at mid-latitudes. Without this, models tend to overestimate concentrations in late summer and fall.
  • Atmospheric production is key in remote regions: In areas like the South Pacific, where biogenic sources are limited, atmospheric production of methanol (primarily from CH₃O₂ radical reactions) becomes the dominant source, and current model estimates for this source may be too low.
  • A refined global budget: By integrating these insights, the study provides a more constrained global methanol budget, with a best estimate of 240 Tg yr⁻¹.
  • Ocean uptake is a minor sink: Contrary to some previous assumptions, the study suggests ocean uptake is a relatively weak sink for methanol.
  • Evidence for VOCs beyond methane: Discrepancies in the remote troposphere, particularly concerning CH₃OOH and HCHO, suggest that VOCs other than methane likely contribute to CH₃O₂ production in these regions, indicating a more active organic photochemistry than currently modeled.

Key Results

  • Global Source Estimate: The best estimate for the global source of methanol is 240 Tg yr⁻¹.
  • Source Contributions: Plant growth is the largest source (128 Tg yr⁻¹), followed by atmospheric production (38 Tg yr⁻¹), plant decay (23 Tg yr⁻¹), biomass burning/biofuels (13 Tg yr⁻¹), and urban/industrial activities (4 Tg yr⁻¹).
  • Atmospheric Lifetime: The model simulates an atmospheric lifetime of methanol of 7 days, with gas-phase oxidation by OH being the dominant sink (63%).
  • Regional Discrepancy: A significant model underestimate was found over the South Pacific, where simulated concentrations were a factor of two too low. This suggests the atmospheric production source in this region may need to be doubled (to 50-100 Tg yr⁻¹).
  • Plant Growth Source Range: Atmospheric constraints imply a likely range of 100-160 Tg yr⁻¹ for the plant growth source.
  • Methanol Lifetime Range: The study suggests a likely range of 5-10 days for the methanol lifetime.

Limitations and Future Work

  • South Pacific Discrepancy: The model underestimates methanol concentrations over the South Pacific, suggesting that the atmospheric production source (from CH₃O₂ reactions) might be too low by a factor of two. This highlights the need for better understanding of CH₃O₂ concentrations and organic chemistry in the remote troposphere.
  • Zugspitze Discrepancy: Observations at Zugspitze suggest a potentially missing non-photochemical sink for methanol, which is not fully captured by the current model.
  • Acetone Correlation: The stronger observed correlation between methanol and acetone suggests that their sources might be governed by more similar processes than currently modeled, indicating potential improvements needed in the representation of biogenic acetone sources.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for more observations of methanol concentrations and fluxes over tropical continents. Better understanding of CH₃O₂ concentrations in the remote troposphere and the underlying organic chemistry is also crucial for improving model accuracy and utilizing methanol as a tracer for terrestrial biogenic emissions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We use a global three‐dimensional model simulation of atmospheric methanol to examine the consistency between observed atmospheric concentrations and current understanding of sources and sinks. Global sources in the model include 128 Tg yr −1 from plant growth, 38 Tg yr −1 from atmospheric reactions of CH 3 O 2 with itself and other organic peroxy radicals, 23 Tg yr −1 from plant decay, 13 Tg yr −1 from biomass burning and biofuels, and 4 Tg yr −1 from vehicles and industry. The plant growth source is a factor of 3 higher for young than from mature leaves. The atmospheric lifetime of methanol in the model is 7 days; gas‐phase oxidation by OH accounts for 63% of the global sink, dry deposition to land 26%, wet deposition 6%, uptake by the ocean 5%, and aqueous‐phase oxidation in clouds less than 1%. The resulting simulation of atmospheric concentrations is generally unbiased in the Northern Hemisphere and reproduces the observed correlations of methanol with acetone, HCN, and CO in Asian outflow. Accounting for decreasing emission from leaves as they age is necessary to reproduce the observed seasonal variation of methanol concentrations at northern midlatitudes. The main model discrepancy is over the South Pacific, where simulated concentrations are a factor of 2 too low. Atmospheric production from the CH 3 O 2 self‐reaction is the dominant model source in this region. A factor of 2 increase in this source (to 50–100 Tg yr −1 ) would largely correct the discrepancy and appears consistent with independent constraints on CH 3 O 2 concentrations. Our resulting best estimate of the global source of methanol is 240 Tg yr −1 . More observations of methanol concentrations and fluxes are needed over tropical continents. Better knowledge is needed of CH 3 O 2 concentrations in the remote troposphere and of the underlying organic chemistry.
BibTeX
@article{jacob2005global,
  author = {Daniel J. Jacob and Brendan D. Field and Qinbin Li and D. R. Blake and J. A. de Gouw and C. Warneke and Armin Hansel and Armin Wisthaler and H. B. Singh and Alex Guenther},
  title = {{Global budget of methanol: Constraints from atmospheric observations}},
  journal = {Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1029/2004jd005172},
}
Figure