TL;DR
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (pMSSM) to explain the mysterious gamma-ray excess observed from the Galactic Center by the Fermi telescope. The researchers found that two specific scenarios within the pMSSM can successfully account for this excess while remaining consistent with all other experimental data, and these scenarios predict observable signals at the upcoming LHC Run-II and next-generation dark matter detectors.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
For years, scientists have observed an unexplained excess of gamma-ray emissions originating from the center of our Milky Way galaxy, detected by the Fermi Large Area Telescope. While astrophysical explanations involving pulsars or other exotic sources have been proposed, a compelling alternative is the annihilation of dark matter particles. The challenge lies in finding a specific dark matter model that can both explain this gamma-ray signal and simultaneously satisfy a wide range of other experimental constraints, including those from direct and indirect dark matter detection experiments, as well as collider searches. This paper tackles this challenge by performing a global fit of the pMSSM, a well-motivated extension of the Standard Model that includes dark matter candidates, to see if it can provide a consistent explanation for the Fermi GeV excess and predict future detection prospects.
Methods
The authors employ a rigorous global fitting approach to explore the parameter space of the 19-dimensional phenomenological Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (pMSSM-19). This involves:
- Global Likelihood Analysis: They construct a joint likelihood function that combines numerous experimental constraints. This includes:
- The Fermi GeV excess data itself.
- Electroweak precision observables (e.g., Z-pole measurements).
- Flavor physics constraints (e.g., B and D meson decays).
- Cosmological dark matter relic density measurements from Planck.
- Direct detection limits from experiments like LUX.
- Indirect detection limits from experiments like IceCube.
- Constraints from Higgs boson searches and searches for supersymmetric particles (sparticles) at colliders.
- Parameter Scan: They use the MultiNest algorithm to efficiently scan the vast parameter space of the pMSSM, aiming to identify regions that are consistent with all the included data.
- Model Comparison: They evaluate the quality of the fit using a $\chi^2$ statistic and a p-value, which quantifies the probability of observing the data given the model.
Datasets
The study utilizes a comprehensive set of experimental datasets and theoretical predictions:
- Fermi Large Area Telescope (LAT) data: Specifically, the gamma-ray excess observed from the Galactic Center.
- Planck satellite data: For cosmological dark matter relic density measurements.
- LEP experiment data: For electroweak precision observables.
- Tevatron and LHC experiment data: For Higgs boson searches and sparticle searches.
- Direct detection experiments: Primarily LUX, with projections for Xenon1T.
- Indirect detection experiments: Primarily IceCube.
- Flavor physics experiments: Data related to B and D meson decays.
The paper does not introduce new datasets but rather integrates existing experimental results into a unified statistical framework.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Fermi GeV Excess as a Dark Matter Signal: The study strongly supports the interpretation of the Fermi GeV excess as a potential signal of dark matter annihilation, specifically from neutralinos within the pMSSM framework.
- Two Viable pMSSM Scenarios: The analysis reveals two distinct regions in the pMSSM parameter space that successfully explain the Fermi GeV excess while satisfying all other experimental constraints. This is a significant finding, as it narrows down the possibilities for dark matter models.
- Specific Annihilation Channels: The two viable scenarios are characterized by specific annihilation channels:
- Neutralinos with masses around 80-100 GeV annihilating primarily into W-boson pairs (95% branching ratio).
- Heavier neutralinos (180-200 GeV) annihilating predominantly into top-quark pairs (87% branching ratio).
- Implications for Future Experiments: The identified pMSSM scenarios predict specific signatures that will be within reach of upcoming experiments, offering clear targets for future searches.
Key Results
The global fit identified two main regions of viable pMSSM parameter space:
- WW Annihilation Scenario: Neutralinos with masses around 80-100 GeV, primarily bino-like, annihilating into W+W- with a 95% branching ratio. This scenario provides a good fit to the Fermi GeV excess and other data.
- tt Annihilation Scenario: Heavier neutralinos with masses around 180-200 GeV, also predominantly bino-like, annihilating into t$\bar{t}$ with an 87% branching ratio. This scenario also offers a good fit.
The overall best-fit point for the combined dataset achieved a $\chi^2$ of 122.0 with 104 degrees of freedom, corresponding to a p-value of 0.11. The $\chi^2$ for the $\bar{t}$ scenario was 127.6 with a p-value of 0.06. The paper highlights that theoretical uncertainties in the Galactic Center fit are crucial for achieving these reasonable p-values.
Limitations and Future Work
- Theoretical Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge that theoretical uncertainties, particularly in the modeling of the Galactic Center excess and DM signal spectra, play a significant role in achieving acceptable p-values. While they incorporate a 10% uncertainty, further refinement in these areas could improve the precision of the fits.
- Degrees of Freedom: The exact number of degrees of freedom in the fit is complex to determine precisely and relies on extensive Monte Carlo simulations. The authors use a simplified counting method.
- Future Detection Prospects: The paper emphasizes that the identified pMSSM scenarios predict signals that will be testable by:
- LHC Run-II: Through searches for charginos, neutralinos, squarks, and light smuons.
- Xenon1T: This experiment's unprecedented sensitivity to spin-dependent neutron scattering cross-sections is expected to probe the entirety of the favored parameter space in the WW annihilation scenario.
- Future Indirect Detection: While current indirect detection experiments are largely out of reach, future, more sensitive analyses of dwarf spheroidal galaxies might probe some of these models.
The authors suggest that dedicated searches for heavy Higgs bosons decaying into charginos and neutralinos could also provide strong constraints.
Summary updated