GIS-Based Visibility Network and Defensibility Model to Reconstruct Defensive System of the Han Dynasty in Central Xinjiang, China

Jianfeng Zhu, Yueping Nie, Huaguang Gao, Fang Liu, Lijun YuISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reconstructs the Han Dynasty's defensive system in Central Xinjiang by integrating GIS-based visibility networks and defensibility models. By analyzing spatial relationships and site importance, it sheds light on ancient military strategies and cultural communication along the Silk Road.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Han Dynasty's expansion into the Western Regions (modern Xinjiang) involved establishing a complex defensive system to protect the Silk Road. Understanding this system is crucial for comprehending ancient military organization, cultural propagation, and the strategic placement of settlements. Previous studies often focused on individual site characteristics or broad geographical factors, but lacked a comprehensive approach to model the interconnectedness of defensive sites and their spatial defensibility within the landscape. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method to reconstruct the entire defensive network, considering both visibility and inherent defensibility of the terrain and sites.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Visibility Network Analysis: Using GIS, the researchers created visibility lines between archaeological sites (city sites and beacon towers) based on Digital Elevation Models (DEM). This network visualizes lines of sight, crucial for surveillance and communication.
  • Complex Network Analysis (CNA): Standard graph theory metrics (density, inclusivity, degree, betweenness, closeness) were applied to the visibility network to quantify the importance and connectivity of individual sites within the network.
  • Defensibility Models:
    • Linear Regression: A model was built to predict the "relative importance" of a site based on factors like proximity to roads, distance to cities, slope, and density of visibility lines. This model assigns varying importance to sites.
  • Logistic Regression: This model predicts the probability of a site's occurrence based on similar defensibility factors, treating all sites as having equal initial importance.
  • Least-Cost Path Analysis: Using the defensibility models (linear and logistic) as cost surfaces, the researchers simulated optimal transportation corridors. These paths represent likely routes for military movement and cultural exchange, contrasting with simpler slope-based paths.

Datasets

  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM): SRTM DEM (90m resolution) was used for spatial analysis and visibility calculations.
  • Archaeological Site Data: Data from the third cultural relic census, including coordinates and descriptive attributes of 94 archaeological sites (city sites, beacon towers, tombs, general relics) in the study area.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interconnectedness is Key: The defensive system wasn't just about individual strongholds but a network of sites communicating and supporting each other. Visibility and connectivity were paramount.
  • Beacon Towers as Early Warning Systems: Beacon towers played a critical role in surveillance and rapid signal transmission, often having a stronger monitoring ability than city sites due to their placement and height.
  • Defensibility is Multifaceted: Simply being on a slope isn't enough. Factors like proximity to roads, distance to other defensive centers, and the density of the defensive network itself significantly contribute to a site's defensibility.
  • Han Dynasty's Strategic Planning: The reconstructed transportation corridors reveal deliberate planning, prioritizing routes that balanced defensive strength with efficient movement, indicating a sophisticated understanding of the landscape.
  • Cultural Fusion and Defense: The study highlights how defensive infrastructure also facilitated cultural exchange and the spread of Han influence into the Western Regions.

Key Results

  • Visibility Network Structure: The visibility network analysis revealed three main local parts, with two in the east identified as important defensive regions.
  • Site Importance: Sites like Agra and Kuhne Shahr were found to have significant controlling abilities within their local defensive regions. Kuyux Shahr and Kuhne Shahr were identified as crucial for the Western Region's Frontier Command.
  • Defensibility Models: The linear regression model explained approximately 42.7% of the defensive importance. Key variables influencing defensibility included proximity to roads (positive), distance to cities (positive), and slope (negative).
  • Transportation Corridors: Least-cost paths derived from defensibility models showed significant differences from slope-based paths, indicating that defense, not just terrain, dictated ancient routes. The paths generally aligned between the linear and logistic models, suggesting a consistent understanding of historical defensive corridors.
  • Shape Analysis: Square city sites were linked to Central Plain Culture, while rounder shapes were characteristic of the local Western Region, reflecting cultural fusion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Verification Needed: The authors acknowledge that the reconstructed paths and defensive system require further verification with more archaeological information and field investigations.
  • Missing Data: Some sites, like C8, are not currently visible, limiting shape analysis. The exact locations of the Western Region's Frontier Command and lost beacon towers are still subjects for future research.
  • Dynamic Landscape: The study notes that landscapes change over time, and while the current analysis uses DEM, historical terrain variations could influence interpretations.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest seeking out the Western Region's Frontier Command and lost beacon towers. They also propose further research into the correlation between path transition and environmental variation, and applying this framework to explore the spatial connotation of ancient sites and broader anthropological archaeology.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhu2017gis,
  author = {Jianfeng Zhu and Yueping Nie and Huaguang Gao and Fang Liu and Lijun Yu},
  title = {{GIS-Based Visibility Network and Defensibility Model to Reconstruct Defensive System of the Han Dynasty in Central Xinjiang, China}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi6080247},
}

Loading related content...

Figure