GINIplus and LISAplus. Design and selected results of two German birth cohorts about natural course of atopic diseases and its determinants

Joachim Heinrich, Irene Brüske, Claudia Cramer, Ute Hoffmann, Markus Schnappinger, Beate Schaaf, Andrea von Berg, Dietrich Berdel, Ursula Krämer, Irina Lehmann, Olf Herbarth, Michael Borte, A. Grübl, Carl Peter Bauer, C. Beckmann, Heidrun Behrendt, Johannes Ring, Sibylle KoletzkoAllergologie 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This review details the design and initial findings of two large German birth cohort studies, GINIplus and LISAplus, which investigated the development of atopic diseases in children. By tracking thousands of newborns over a decade, these studies highlight the significant influence of lifestyle and environmental factors, alongside genetics, in shaping immune system development and the onset of conditions like asthma and eczema.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the growing concern over the increasing prevalence of atopic diseases (such as asthma, hay fever, and eczema) in children, particularly the stark differences observed between East and West Germany following reunification. This geographical disparity strongly suggested that environmental and lifestyle factors, rather than purely genetic predispositions, played a crucial role. The challenge was to systematically investigate these complex interactions from the earliest stages of life to understand how the immune system develops and how various exposures influence the onset and course of these chronic conditions. Traditional cross-sectional studies couldn't capture the developmental trajectory, necessitating longitudinal birth cohort designs.

Methods

The core methodology employed is that of prospective, population-based birth cohort studies. Two major cohorts, GINIplus and LISAplus, were established.

  • GINIplus: This study had two arms: an interventional arm (a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial using hydrolyzed formula nutrition for infants with a family history of allergy) and a non-interventional arm for children without a family history of allergy or those whose families opted out of the intervention.
  • LISAplus: This was a non-interventional study.

Both studies involved extensive data collection through questionnaires, medical examinations, and biological sample analyses at multiple time points from birth up to 10 years of age (with ongoing follow-up). Data collected included:

  • Questionnaires: Covering diseases and symptoms (allergies), social factors, vaccinations, exposure to noxious substances (passive smoking, indoor/outdoor air), health-related behavior (physical activity, nutrition), and mental well-being (SDQ, depression, Kidscreen).
  • Medical Investigations: Skin examinations, lung function tests (FENO), anthropometry, blood pressure, and dental health.
  • Biological Analyses: Total and specific IgE, IgA, viral and vaccination antibodies, T-cell immunity, lipids, inflammation markers, Homeostasis Model Assessment (HOMA), and fatty acids.
  • Genetic Analyses: Investigating genetic predispositions.
  • Exposure Assessments: Air pollutants (using Land Use Regression models), noise, and use of health services.

The studies utilized a combination of observational data and, in the case of GINIplus's interventional arm, a randomized controlled trial design to disentangle causal relationships.

Datasets

The paper describes the recruitment and follow-up of participants for the GINIplus and LISAplus cohorts.

  • GINIplus: Recruited 5,991 healthy, term newborns from Munich and Wesel between September 1995 and June 1998. Approximately 55.4% were followed up to age 10.
  • LISAplus: Recruited 3,097 healthy, term newborns from Munich, Leipzig, Wesel, and Bad Honnef between November 1997 and January 1999. Approximately 56.8% were followed up to age 10.

These are newly established birth cohorts for the purpose of this research, not pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Western Lifestyle" Hypothesis: The significant differences in allergy prevalence between East and West Germany before reunification strongly pointed towards lifestyle and environmental factors as key drivers, a concept the studies aimed to explore in detail.
  • Perinatal Period is Crucial: The paper emphasizes that the perinatal period is a critical window for immune system priming, making pregnancy and birth cohorts essential for understanding disease determinants.
  • Early Allergic Sensitization as a Predictor: Experiencing allergic sensitization (detecting IgE against allergens) in the first year of life significantly increases the risk of developing atopic diseases later in childhood.
  • Complex Gene-Environment Interactions: While genetic factors are important (e.g., filaggrin gene mutations increasing eczema risk), their interaction with environmental factors (like older siblings) can modify outcomes.
  • Environmental Exposures Matter from In Utero: Exposure to endotoxins in utero might actually reduce the risk of allergic reactions, suggesting a complex dose-response relationship and the importance of early life exposures.
  • Traffic Pollution and Health: Exposure to traffic-related air pollution is linked to increased risks of asthmatic and allergic diseases, particularly sensitization to airborne allergens.
  • Indoor Environment Impact: Renovation work during pregnancy, leading to exposure to volatile organic compounds (VOCs), can alter the immune system development in newborns, potentially increasing the risk of atopic eczema.
  • Eczema and Mental Health Link: A notable finding is the association between eczema in early childhood and an increased risk of behavioral deviations and emotional problems later in childhood, suggesting potential psychoneuro-endocrine links.

Key Results

  • Natural Course of Atopic Diseases: Eczema and food allergies tend to decrease with age, while asthma and hay fever become more frequent in older children.
  • Allergic Sensitization: By age 10, nearly half of the children in the cohorts showed positive reactions to airborne allergens.
  • Regional Differences Diminishing: While initial differences in allergy prevalence between East and West Germany were pronounced, by the year 2000, these differences had diminished, suggesting a convergence in lifestyle and environmental factors.
  • Early Sensitization Risk: Children sensitized to allergens in their first year of life had a significantly higher risk of developing eczema (20.6% vs. 9.4%), hay fever (15.4% vs. 7.3%), and asthma (10.2% vs. 2.6%) by age 6.
  • Filaggrin Mutation and Siblings: Children with filaggrin gene mutations had a significantly higher risk of developing eczema if they lived with older siblings, indicating a complex interaction.
  • Endotoxin Exposure: High endotoxin exposure in the first 6 months of life reduced the risk of developing unspecific eczema.
  • Traffic Pollution: Living less than 50m from a busy street increased the risk of developing asthma, hay fever, eczema, or allergic sensitization by up to 50%.
  • Eczema and Behavior: Children with eczema in their first two years of life showed an approximately 50% increased risk for general behavioral deviations and emotional problems at age 10.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Methodological Challenges: The authors acknowledge the difficulty in definitively evaluating the exact role of factors like breast-feeding due to ethical constraints preventing randomized studies.
  • Causality: While associations are found, establishing definitive causal relationships for many factors (e.g., the link between eczema and unusual behavior patterns) remains challenging due to unknown biological mechanisms.
  • Ongoing Follow-up: The 15-year follow-up is ongoing and expected to provide further insights into preadolescence and adolescence, a period where phenomena like the inversion of male dominance in asthma frequency occur, and other health-related impairments become more prominent. Future work will continue to explore these complex interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The increasing prevalence of asthma, hay fever, and allergic sensitization in Western Germany after east-west division in 1949 and their rapid increase in East German children after re-unification in 1990 are strong indications for the role of life-style and/or environmental factors in the development of atopic diseases. Obviously, the perinatal period is crucial for priming the immune system. Therefore, explorations of determinants of atopic diseases need pregnancy or birth cohorts as the most appropriate epidemiological study designs. This review presents the design and selected results of the two German birth cohorts GINIplus and LISAplus. GINIplus and LISAplus recruited 5.991 and 3.097 healthy, term newborns, respectively, from Munich, Wesel, Leipzig, and Bad Honnef. Approximately 55% could be followed for the first 10 years. We analyzed the natural course of atopic diseases and the role of life-style, environmental, and genetic factors for disease onset, intermediate phenotypes, and genes involved in detoxification and oxidative stress. The results of these two large birth cohorts contributed substantially to the understanding of atopic diseases and their determinants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{heinrich2017giniplus,
  author = {Joachim Heinrich and Irene Brüske and Claudia Cramer and Ute Hoffmann and Markus Schnappinger and Beate Schaaf and Andrea von Berg and Dietrich Berdel and Ursula Krämer and Irina Lehmann and Olf Herbarth and Michael Borte and A. Grübl and Carl Peter Bauer and C. Beckmann and Heidrun Behrendt and Johannes Ring and Sibylle Koletzko},
  title = {{GINIplus and LISAplus. Design and selected results of two German birth cohorts about natural course of atopic diseases and its determinants}},
  booktitle = {Allergologie},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.5414/alx01455e},
}
Figure