Geuine tripartite entanglement in three-flavor neutrino oscillations

Yuwen Li, Lijuan Li, Xue‐Ke Song, Dong Wang, Ye LiuThe European Physical Journal C 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The violation of Leggett–Garg inequalities tested the quantumness of neutrino oscillations (NOs) across macroscopic distances. The quantumness can be quantified by using the tools of the quantum resource theories. Recently, a new genuine tripartite entanglement measure, concurrence fill, is defined as the square root of the area of the concurrence triangle satisfying all genuine multipartite entanglement conditions. It has several advantages compared to other existing tripartite measures. Here, we focus on using concurrence fill to quantify the tripartite entanglement in three-flavor NOs. Concurrence fill can reach its maximum 0.89 for the experimentally-observed electron antineutrino oscillations, but it cannot for the muon antineutrino oscillations. In both cases, we compare its performance with other three tripartite entanglement measures, including the generalized geometric measure (GGM), the three-$\pi$ entanglement, and the genuinely multipartite concurrence (GMC), in the neutrino propagation, and accordingly show that concurrence fill contains the most quantum resource. Furthermore, concurrence fill and the three-$\pi$ entanglement are always smooth, while GGM and GMC measures have several sharp peaks. The genuine tripartite quantification of the quantumness of three-flavor NOs represents the first step towards the further potential application of neutrinos on quantum information processing.

Introduction

Neutrino oscillations—the phenomenon where a neutrino changes its "flavor" as it travels—are a quintessentially quantum process. While experiments have proven that neutrinos violate classical limits (like the Leggett–Garg inequalities), quantifying exactly how much entanglement exists between the three flavors has been difficult. This paper explores the quantum "weirdness" of neutrinos, specifically focusing on how the three flavors—electron, muon, and tau—become entangled as they travel through space.

Quantifying Entanglement: The Concurrence Fill

Most existing measures of "tripartite" (three-way) entanglement suffer from mathematical artifacts, such as "sharp peaks" or non-analytical behavior, because they rely on finding the minimum value among different bipartite (two-way) pairings. This paper seeks to provide a more robust, global quantification of neutrino entanglement using a geometric approach called concurrence fill ($F_{123}$).

By treating the three possible bipartite entanglements as the sides of a triangle, the "concurrence fill" (the area of that triangle) provides a more holistic view of the system than measures that only look at the weakest link.

Geometric representation of the concurrence triangle at various L/E ratios showing the evolution of entanglement.

Comparative Analysis of Measures

The researchers compared four different entanglement measures: Generalized Geometric Measure (GGM), Three-$\pi$ Entanglement, Genuinely Multipartite Concurrence (GMC), and Concurrence Fill ($F_{123}$). The study found that concurrence fill is consistently larger than the three-$\pi$ entanglement measure across the entire propagation range, indicating it captures more "quantum resource" information.

Comparison of entanglement measures (Concurrence fill, GMC, Three-π, GGM) as a function of L/E, highlighting the smoothness and magnitude of the concurrence fill.

Key Results and Insights

  • Maximum Entanglement: For electron antineutrinos, the concurrence fill reaches a maximum of 0.89 at a specific $L/E$ ratio (approx. 10.83 km/MeV).
  • Smoothness Matters: Unlike GGM and GMC, which produce "sharp peaks" in their graphs due to their reliance on minimization functions, concurrence fill is always smooth. This makes it a more "natural" physical measure for a continuously evolving system.
  • Flavor Dependence: The potential for entanglement is not equal across all neutrino types. Electron antineutrinos show significantly higher maximum tripartite entanglement than muon antineutrinos under the studied conditions.

Conclusion

The high values of concurrence fill suggest that neutrinos are a rich source of genuine multipartite entanglement. This work represents a "first step" toward using neutrinos in quantum information processing (QIP). While the study primarily considers vacuum oscillations, future work must address the MSW effect in matter and the technical challenges of direct experimental verification.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The violation of Leggett–Garg inequalities tested the quantumness of neutrino oscillations (NOs) across macroscopic distances. The quantumness can be quantified by using the tools of the quantum resource theories. Recently, a new genuine tripartite entanglement measure (Xie et al. in Phys Rev Lett 127:040403, 2021), concurrence fill, is defined as the square root of the area of the concurrence triangle satisfying all genuine multipartite entanglement conditions. It has several advantages compared to other existing tripartite measures. Here, we focus on using concurrence fill to quantify the tripartite entanglement in three-flavor NOs. Concurrence fill can reach its maximum 0.89 for the experimentally-observed electron antineutrino oscillations, but it cannot for the muon antineutrino oscillations. In both cases, we compare its performance with other three tripartite entanglement measures, including the generalized geometric measure (GGM), the three- $$\pi $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mi>π</mml:mi></mml:math> entanglement, and the genuinely multipartite concurrence (GMC), in the neutrino propagation, and accordingly show that concurrence fill contains the most quantum resource. Furthermore, concurrence fill and the three- $$\pi $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mi>π</mml:mi></mml:math> entanglement are always smooth, while GGM and GMC measures have several sharp peaks. The genuine tripartite quantification of the quantumness of three-flavor NOs represents the first step towards the further potential application of neutrinos on quantum information processing.
BibTeX
@article{li2022geuine,
  author = {Yuwen Li and Lijuan Li and Xue‐Ke Song and Dong Wang and Ye Liu},
  title = {{Geuine tripartite entanglement in three-flavor neutrino oscillations}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-022-10759-2},
}
Figure