Getting Rid of Male Gaze Gradually: Exploring the Development of Feminism from ELLE Magazine

Ying HeBCP 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Founded in 1945 by Helene Lazareff, ELLE magazine was established to center women’s fashion and lifestyle. Over the past 75 years, it has evolved from a local publication into a global brand that increasingly integrates gender equality as a core theme. This paper explores the transition from the "male gaze" to the "female gaze" through a comparative analysis of ELLE covers from the 20th and 21st centuries. By examining shifts in model gender, attire, and posture, the study finds that fashion media has moved away from objectifying women for male pleasure toward fostering female agency and self-expression. While significant progress has been made, the paper also acknowledges persistent obstacles, including the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and incomplete representation for marginalized communities.

Introduction: The Male Gaze in Fashion

The concept of the "male gaze," a term rooted in feminist film theory, describes the tendency of visual culture to depict the world and women from a masculine, heterosexual point of view. In this framework, women are presented as passive objects of pleasure for a male viewer. Historically, fashion magazines were primary drivers of this perspective, dictating how women should look and behave to satisfy social norms.

This study analyzes how ELLE has mirrored the development of feminism by dismantling these gender limitations. The research focuses on how the visual elements of a magazine cover—specifically the choice of models, their clothing, and their physical presence—reflect a gradual rise in female agency.

Methodology

The study employs a comparative qualitative analysis of ELLE magazine covers spanning from 1945 to 2022, including French, UK, and US editions. The analysis integrates visual semiotics with theoretical frameworks regarding self-objectification and the gaze. Three primary dimensions are evaluated:

  1. Model Demographics: The introduction and frequency of male models.
  2. Dressing Styles: The shift from conservative, submissive aesthetics to rebellious, autonomous styles.
  3. Models' Poses: The transition from stiff, product-focused postures to expressive, personality-driven movements.

Key Insights: From Object to Subject

The Rise of the Female Gaze

A pivotal shift in ELLE’s history occurred in November 1989, when the magazine began featuring male models alongside or instead of women. By introducing figures like David Beckham or Joseph Gordon-Levitt, the magazine repositioned women as the "seers" rather than just the "seen." This shift breaks the cycle of constant female self-criticism by allowing women to occupy the position of the observer, thereby asserting their own desires and perspectives.

Clothing as Autonomy

In the 1950s, ELLE covers typically featured "sober and conventional" attire—gloves, hats, and structured suits—designed to satisfy rigid social expectations of femininity. In contrast, modern covers use fashion as a tool for rebellion. For example, a 2020s cover featuring Kaia Gerber in a red velvet suit without a shirt exemplifies an "unrestrained" character expression. Here, clothing is no longer a uniform of submission but a medium for individual identity.

From "Clothes Racks" to "Souls"

Early fashion photography often treated models as mere "clothes racks," requiring them to stand straight and still to highlight the garment’s fabric and cut. This form of objectification prioritized the product over the person. Modern ELLE covers, however, emphasize "soul transmission." Whether it is Doja Cat captured in a candid moment or models in mid-leap, the focus has shifted to the model’s attitude and energy. The human element now takes precedence over the commercial object.

The qualitative shifts are supported by broader industry data. Statistics from 2010 to 2019 show that male model representation in the US fashion industry increased from 19.98% to 30.09%, while female representation adjusted accordingly. This suggests a diversifying market that no longer caters exclusively to a singular demographic gaze.

Furthermore, ELLE has increasingly aligned itself with social advocacy. Recent covers have moved beyond aesthetics to address legal rights and social respect. The November 2020 British ELLE cover featuring a lesbian couple serves as a prominent example of the magazine’s commitment to representing marginalized communities and challenging heteronormative standards.

Challenges and Future Outlook

Despite the rapid development of feminism as reflected in ELLE, the path forward remains fraught with obstacles. The author identifies several "additional risks" in the modern era:

  • Pandemic Setbacks: Research from UN Women suggests that the COVID-19 pandemic could delay gender equality by up to 25 years due to the disproportionate burden of unpaid labor and job losses placed on women.
  • Representation Gaps: While progress is visible, the legal rights and media representation of Black women and the LGBTQ+ community remain incompletely developed.
  • Persistent Bias: Deep-seated conservative biases continue to challenge feminist progress in the media and beyond.

Conclusion

The evolution of ELLE magazine covers provides a visual record of the gradual dismantling of the male gaze. As women transition from objects of display to subjects of their own narratives, fashion media has become a site of empowerment rather than just consumption. However, the journey toward true equality requires continued effort to overcome modern socio-economic setbacks and ensure that the "female gaze" is inclusive of all women.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to focus on women's fashion and lifestyle, a Frenchwoman named Helene Lazareff started ELLE magazine in 1945. After 50 years, ELLE has evolved from a fashion publication to a global fashion brand. Most notably, the ELLE brand process incorporates gender equality as a major theme. In this publication, women from varied backgrounds continue to express how they have defined men and their own social standing throughout history, as well as how they see femininity and masculinity now. Through a comparative analysis of images on magazine covers from the 20th and 21st centuries and theoretical knowledge of the male gaze, this paper finds that the development of the female gaze contributed to the rise in male models, that changes in clothing styles and brands reflected the emergence of women's sense of self, and that a variety of poses allowed women to present themselves bravely. Combined with such arguments, the paper concludes that feminism is developing rapidly, reflected on the covers of ELLE magazines, as women are gradually getting rid of the male gaze. Besides, based on the additional risks that come with advancing times, there are still many obstacles in the path of feminism challenging current feminists and females, which need them to make more efforts to overcome.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2023getting,
  author = {Ying He},
  title = {{Getting Rid of Male Gaze Gradually: Exploring the Development of Feminism from ELLE Magazine}},
  booktitle = {BCP},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.54691/bcpep.v9i.4684},
}
Figure