Geothermal Retrofit of Illinois National Guard's State headquarters Building

Mark Lee2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details a project to retrofit the Illinois National Guard's State Headquarters building with a geothermal system, initially exploring the novel use of abandoned mine water as a heat sink. While the mine water concept proved unfeasible due to insufficient water levels, the project successfully implemented a conventional vertical closed-loop geothermal system, demonstrating a viable path for energy efficiency upgrades in existing buildings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The primary challenge addressed is the high cost and long payback periods associated with traditional geothermal retrofits for existing buildings, making them prohibitive for many organizations, including the National Guard. The paper explores an innovative solution: utilizing abandoned subsurface mine water as a heat sink. This approach was hypothesized to significantly reduce the required well field size, thereby lowering installation costs and shortening payback periods. The project also aimed to overcome technical hurdles related to mine water quality, legal issues, and identifying suitable energy recovery systems. Ultimately, the project pivoted to a conventional geothermal system due to the specific site's limitations, but still sought to demonstrate cost-effective retrofitting strategies.

Methods

The project involved several key methodological phases:

  • Mine Water Feasibility Study (Phase I): This involved developing methodologies to assess mine water quality and quantity, investigating legal and permitting requirements, and identifying suitable energy recovery systems. A crucial part of this phase was developing and testing a drilling methodology to accurately locate mine voids.
  • Mine Void Location: Multiple technologies were evaluated for detecting mine voids, with reflection seismology initially considered but deemed unsuitable for the site due to environmental factors. A drilling-based methodology was developed and tested, proving successful in locating mine voids in two out of three attempts.
  • Conventional Geothermal System Design and Installation (Phases II & III): Due to insufficient mine water, the project transitioned to a conventional geothermal system. This involved designing and installing a vertical closed-loop ground heat exchanger. The HVAC system was retrofitted to integrate with the geothermal system, with a focus on maximizing the use of available funds.
  • Hybrid System Design: A hybrid system was designed, combining the vertical closed-loop ground heat exchanger with a dry cooler for supplemental cooling, to meet budget and funding requirements.
  • Energy Modeling and Analysis: While a full energy model was outside the scope, existing energy audit data was used to project savings. The project also involved monitoring the performance of the new system.

Datasets

  • Energy Data: Energy data for the Illinois National Guard State Headquarters building was collected from May 2007 to April 2010 by the Illinois National Guard. This data was used to calculate average annual electricity and natural gas usage.
  • Commercial Buildings Energy Consumption Survey (2003): Data from this survey was used for comparison to evaluate the energy intensity of the AGO Building against similar-sized buildings.
  • ILDCEO Energy Audit (2009): This audit provided recommended energy conservation measures, including a geothermal system for the entire building, and projected energy savings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mine Water Potential and Limitations: The concept of using abandoned mine water as a heat sink is technically viable and potentially cost-effective, but highly dependent on the mine being sufficiently flooded. The lack of adequate water in the Panther Creek Mine #2 rendered this approach unfeasible for this specific project.
  • Drilling Methodology for Mine Void Location: Developing a reliable and cost-effective method to locate mine voids prior to drilling is critical for such projects. The developed drilling methodology proved successful, highlighting the importance of site-specific adaptation.
  • Hybrid Geothermal Systems: The project successfully implemented a hybrid geothermal system, combining a vertical closed-loop with a dry cooler, demonstrating a flexible approach to meet varying energy needs and budget constraints.
  • Retrofitting Challenges: Retrofitting existing buildings with advanced HVAC systems presents significant challenges, including limited space, integration with older systems, and budget limitations. The project highlights the need for phased implementation and careful planning.
  • VRF Systems for Retrofits: Variable Refrigerant Flow (VRF) systems are identified as a suitable technology for retrofits due to their modularity, lower space requirements, and potential for individual zone control, making them ideal for future expansions.

Key Results

  • Mine Water Test: Two out of three test wells successfully hit the mine void, validating the developed drilling methodology. However, insufficient water levels (18-24 inches) prevented the use of mine water as a heat sink.
  • Conventional Geothermal System: A conventional vertical closed-loop geothermal system was installed, connecting 113 wells drilled to a depth of 156 feet. This system was designed to accommodate future expansion to the entire building.
  • HVAC Retrofit: The project focused on retrofitting the south portion of the building with a geothermal VRF system, replacing older multizone units. This portion of the building was conditioned by two 30-ton water-to-water heat pumps and a 7-ton VRF system for the Joint Operations Center.
  • Energy Consumption Impact: While the geothermal system itself is energy efficient, the report notes that the savings were "virtually non-existent" when combined with the existing, older HVAC components in the un-retrofitted portions of the building. Electrical consumption increased by 13-135% and natural gas consumption by 13-135% in 2014 compared to 2013, with the dramatic increase in natural gas being unclear and requiring further investigation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mine Water Unsuitability: The primary limitation was the lack of sufficient water in the abandoned mine, preventing the initial, more cost-effective mine water heat sink concept from being realized.
  • Budget Constraints: The project budget limited the scope of the retrofit to only a portion of the building, necessitating a phased approach for full building coverage.
  • Integration with Existing Systems: The report acknowledges that the savings from the geothermal system were diminished by the continued reliance on older, less efficient HVAC components in other parts of the building.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future funding should be directed towards replacing the remaining HVAC systems with compatible geothermal technology to realize the full energy efficiency potential. Further monitoring and investigation are also recommended to understand the dramatic increase in natural gas consumption. The project also leaves open the possibility of future expansion of the geothermal system to the entire building.

Summary updated

Abstract

The goal of this project was to assess the feasibility of utilizing mine water as a heat sink for a geothermal heat pump system to heat and cool the 74,000 sq. ft. Illinois National Guard State Headquarters’ building in Springfield Illinois. If successful, this type of system would be less expensive to install than a traditional closed loop geothermal (ground source) heat pump system by significantly reducing the size of the well field, thus shortening or eliminate the payback period compared to a conventional system. In the end, a conventional ground loop was used for the project.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2015geothermal,
  author = {Mark Lee},
  title = {{Geothermal Retrofit of Illinois National Guard's State headquarters Building}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2172/1179248},
}
Figure