Geometric description of vakonomic and nonholonomic dynamics. Comparison of solutions

Jorge Cortés, Manuel de León, David Martı́n de Diego, Sonia Martı́nezarXiv 2000 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We treat vakonomic dynamics with general constraints within a new geometric framework appropriate for studying optimal control problems. We compare our formulation with the Vershik-Gershkovich model in the case of linear constraints. We demonstrate how nonholonomic mechanics also admits a new geometrical description, enabling the development of an algorithm to compare solutions between both dynamics. Several illustrative examples, including the rolling penny, are treated to validate the theory.

Introduction: The Conflict of Constrained Motion

In classical mechanics, modeling systems with constraints—such as a wheel rolling without slipping—presents a fundamental choice between two distinct mathematical frameworks. The first, nonholonomic mechanics, relies on the d'Alembert principle, where constraint forces do no work. This is widely accepted as the physically accurate model for mechanical systems. The second, vakonomic dynamics, utilizes a variational principle that minimizes an action functional subject to constraints. While less common in pure physics, vakonomic dynamics is the standard approach in optimal control theory.

Historically, these two methods often yield divergent equations of motion for the same physical system. This discrepancy poses a significant challenge for engineers and physicists designing complex systems like robotic vehicles or biomimetic locomotors. This paper provides a rigorous geometric language to bridge these two worlds, identifying the specific conditions under which their solutions coincide.

A Unified Geometric Framework

To move beyond coordinate-dependent limitations, this research adopts a sophisticated coordinate-independent approach based on presymplectic geometry.

The Skinner and Rusk Formalism

The authors utilize the Whitney sum of the tangent and cotangent bundles ($T^*Q \oplus TQ$) as the primary "ambient" phase space. By treating positions, velocities, and momenta (Lagrange multipliers) on equal footing, this formalism provides a comprehensive environment to analyze constrained motion.

Presymplectic Geometry and the Gotay-Nester Algorithm

Because constraints restrict a system's motion, the resulting geometric structure (the 2-form) is not perfectly invertible, or "symplectic"; instead, it is presymplectic. To find consistent solutions within such a system, motion must be restricted to specific submanifolds. The authors apply the Gotay-Nester algorithm to both vakonomic and nonholonomic models to systematically derive these consistent submanifolds.

The Comparison Algorithm

The core contribution of this work is a new algorithm designed to find the intersection of these two dynamical worlds. By taking the final submanifolds derived for both systems and applying a specific mapping ($\Upsilon$), the authors can identify the set of initial conditions where the physical nonholonomic motion is also a "vakonomic" optimal solution.

This approach reveals that the difference between the two models is deeply tied to the curvature of the constraints. If the constraints are "flat" (integrable or holonomic), the two theories collapse into one. Furthermore, the paper demonstrates that for vakonomic systems, the behavior of the Lagrangian outside the constraint manifold is irrelevant, whereas nonholonomic mechanics depends on the full ambient Lagrangian.

Key Results and Applications

Generalization of Theory

The authors prove that their geometric approach is a direct generalization of the Vershik-Gershkovich formulation, successfully extending it from simple linear constraints to complex nonlinear ones.

The Rolling Penny

To illustrate the theory, the authors apply their algorithm to the classic "vertical rolling penny" problem. They successfully identified specific submanifolds—such as motion along a straight line—where the nonholonomic and vakonomic solutions are identical.

Equivalence Conditions

The research re-obtains and weakens the hypotheses of previous studies (such as those by Favretti). It demonstrates that if a trajectory is a solution to the "free" (unconstrained) problem and happens to satisfy the constraints, it serves as a valid solution for both models.

Limitations and Future Research

While the framework is robust, it currently excludes abnormal solutions—pathological curves found in sub-Riemannian geometry that do not admit non-trivial variations. Additionally, the current study focuses on autonomous systems where physics does not change over time.

Future work will look toward extending this geometric description to non-autonomous (time-dependent) systems and integrating symmetry reduction techniques to better handle systems with inherent physical symmetries, such as those found in complex robotic locomotion.

Summary updated

Abstract

We treat the vakonomic dynamics with general constraints within a new geometric framework which will be appropriate to study optimal control problems. We compare our formulation with Vershik-Gershkovich one in the case of linear constraints. We show how nonholonomic mechanics also admits a new geometrical description wich enables us to develop an algorithm of comparison between the solutions of both dynamics. Some examples illustrating the theory are treated.
BibTeX
@misc{cortes2000geometric,
  author = {Jorge Cortés and Manuel de León and David Martı́n de Diego and Sonia Martı́nez},
  title = {{Geometric description of vakonomic and nonholonomic dynamics. Comparison of solutions}},
  year = {2000},
  eprint = {math/0006183},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0006183},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure