Geological Conditions and Reservoir Formation Models of Low- to Middle-Rank Coalbed Methane in the Northern Part of the Ningxia Autonomous Region

Dongsheng Wang, Qiang Xu, Shuai Wang, Quanyun Miao, Zhengguang Zhang, Xiaotao Xu, Hongyu GuoProcesses 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the geological conditions and reservoir formation models for low- to middle-rank coalbed methane (CBM) in the Shizuishan area of Ningxia, China. By integrating diverse geological data, the research identifies key controlling factors and proposes a novel three-type CBM accumulation model, offering crucial guidance for future exploration in complex structural regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While CBM exploration in China has seen significant progress, particularly in the eastern Ordos Basin, the western edge, specifically the Shizuishan area, remains less understood. This region presents unique challenges due to its complex geological settings, including basin-marginal structural belts and low- to middle-rank coals. Existing models for CBM enrichment and accumulation are not fully applicable here, creating a knowledge gap that hinders precise exploration and development efforts. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically analyzing the geological conditions and developing new reservoir formation models tailored to the Shizuishan area.

Methods

The study employs a multi-disciplinary approach, integrating a variety of geological datasets. Key methods include:

  • Drilling and Logging Data: Used to understand coal seam thickness, burial depth, and lithological characteristics of the surrounding rocks.
  • Seismic Data: Utilized to delineate structural features, fault networks, and tectonic morphology.
  • Coalbed Methane (CBM) Test Data: Essential for assessing gas content and understanding gas-bearing properties.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Applied to analyze the microscopic characteristics of coal rock types, including organic matter pores and fractures.
  • Low-Temperature Liquid Nitrogen Adsorption: Used to determine pore structure and distribution (micropores and mesopores).
  • High-Pressure Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry: Employed to assess pore size distribution and fractal dimension, quantifying pore heterogeneity.
  • In-Situ Stress Testing: Conducted to understand the stress field and its influence on coal seam behavior and fracturing.
  • Tectonic Evolution Analysis: Reconstructed to understand the historical development of structural features.

A novel aspect of this research is the integration of these multi-source datasets to reveal the "tectonic-sedimentary-fluid" trinity coupling mechanism governing CBM enrichment in low-gentle slope structural belts.

Datasets

The study utilizes a comprehensive suite of geological data from the Shizuishan area in the northern part of the Ningxia Autonomous Region, China. This includes:

  • Drilling logs: Providing detailed information on subsurface stratigraphy and coal seam properties.
  • Well logging data: Offering geophysical measurements to infer rock properties and identify geological structures.
  • Seismic profiles: Used for structural mapping and understanding the tectonic framework.
  • Coalbed Methane (CBM) test data: Crucial for quantifying gas content and evaluating reservoir potential.
  • Coal samples: Collected for detailed petrographic and pore structure analysis (SEM, N2 adsorption, Hg intrusion).
  • In-situ stress test data: Obtained from well tests to characterize the stress regime.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing data types were integrated in a novel analytical framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Tectonic-Sedimentary-Fluid" Trinity: The research highlights that CBM enrichment in complex structural areas is not governed by a single factor but by the synergistic interplay of tectonic activity, sedimentary environment, and hydrodynamic conditions. This integrated approach provides a new paradigm for exploration.
  • Novel Three-Type CBM Accumulation Model: Moving beyond traditional binary classifications, the study proposes three distinct models:
  • Steep Flank Tectonic Fault Escape Type: Dominated by tectonic activity, where faults act as escape pathways, leading to lower gas content.
  • Axial Tectonic Hydrodynamic Sealing Type: A composite model where structural and hydrodynamic factors work together in syncline axial zones to trap gas.
  • Gentle Flank Lithology-Hydrodynamic Sealing Type: A synergy of lithology and water, where favorable cap rocks and stagnant water in gentle slopes promote enrichment.
  • "Slope Control Storage, Low-Structure Gas Reservoir" Model: This innovative concept for gentle slope areas emphasizes how structural characteristics and storage capacity interact to form CBM reservoirs.
  • Importance of Roof Lithology: The study underscores the role of dense sandstone roofs in central and southern areas as effective seals, crucial for gas preservation.
  • Coal Rank and Burial Depth Correlation: Coal rank increases with burial depth, influencing CBM adsorption capacity, with more uniform thermal evolution observed in the southeast.

Key Results

  • Principal Coal Seams Identified: Coal seams No. 2 and No. 3 (Shanxi Formation) and No. 5 and No. 6 (Taiyuan Formation) are identified as the primary coal-bearing seams with favorable thicknesses (exceeding 10m in the southwest).
  • Burial Depth Variations: Burial depth is generally stable in the east and south but fluctuates near fault F1 in the west and north, correlating with coal rank.
  • Gas Content Distribution: Gas content in coal seams 2 and 3 ranges from 5.90–12.61 m³/t (average 8.50 m³/t), with higher content in the southeast. Coal seams 5 and 6 show a range of 4.39–13.88 m³/t (average 8.11 m³/t), with high gas areas in the south.
  • Sealing Capacity: Dense sandstone roofs in the central and southern areas of coal seam No. 6 indicate strong sealing capacity.
  • Hydrodynamic Influence: Groundwater flow from the central area to the limbs, with higher water levels in the central and southern sectors, influences CBM migration and preservation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited to Shizuishan Area: The proposed accumulation models are specific to the geological conditions of the Shizuishan area. Further validation and adaptation may be needed for other regions with similar but not identical geological characteristics.
  • Complexity of "Trinity" Coupling: While the "tectonic-sedimentary-fluid" trinity is identified, further quantitative analysis of the precise interplay and weighting of each factor in different structural positions could enhance predictive capabilities.
  • Future Exploration Guidance: The authors explicitly state that their findings provide critical guidance for future exploration in the Ningxia Autonomous Region, suggesting that future work could involve applying these models to identify and prioritize new exploration targets. Further research could also focus on refining the quantitative criteria for target area selection within the proposed classification system.

Summary updated

Abstract

The mechanism of low- to middle-rank coal seam gas accumulation in the Baode block on the eastern edge of the Ordos Basin is well understood. However, exploration efforts in the Shizuishan area on the western edge started later, and the current understanding of enrichment and accumulation rules is unclear. It is important to systematically study enrichment and accumulation, which guide the precise exploration and development of coal seam gas resources in the western wing of the basin. The coal seam collected from the Shizuishan area of Ningxia was taken as the target. Based on drilling, logging, seismic, and CBM (coalbed methane) test data, geological conditions were studied, and factors and reservoir formation modes of CBM enrichment were summarized. The results are as follows. The principal coal-bearing seams in the study area are coal seams No. 2 and No. 3 of the Shanxi Formation and No. 5 and No. 6 of the Taiyuan Formation, with thicknesses exceeding 10 m in the southwest and generally stable thickness across the region, providing favorable conditions for CBM enrichment. Spatial variations in burial depth show stability in the east and south, but notable fluctuations are observed near fault F1 in the west and north. These burial depth patterns are closely linked to coal rank, which increases with depth. Although the southeastern region exhibits a lower coal rank than the northwest, its variation is minimal, reflecting a more uniform thermal evolution. Lithologically, the roof of coal seam No. 6 is mainly composed of dense sandstone in the central and southern areas, indicating a strong sealing capacity conducive to gas preservation. This study employs a system that fuses multi-source geological data for analysis, integrating multi-dimensional data such as drilling, logging, seismic, and CBM testing data. It systematically reveals the gas control mechanism of “tectonic–sedimentary–fluid” trinity coupling in low-gentle slope structural belts, providing a new research paradigm for coalbed methane exploration in complex structural areas. It creatively proposes a three-type CBM accumulation model that includes the following: ① a steep flank tectonic fault escape type (tectonics-dominated); ② an axial tectonic hydrodynamic sealing type (water–tectonics composite); and ③ a gentle flank lithology–hydrodynamic sealing type (lithology–water synergy). This classification system breaks through the traditional binary framework, systematically explaining the spatiotemporal matching relationships of the accumulated elements in different structural positions and establishing quantitative criteria for target area selection. It systematically reveals the key controlling roles of low-gentle slope structural belts and slope belts in coalbed methane enrichment, innovatively proposing a new gentle slope accumulation model defined as “slope control storage, low-structure gas reservoir”. These integrated results highlight the mutual control of structural, thermal, and lithological factors on CBM enrichment and provide critical guidance for future exploration in the Ningxia Autonomous Region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025geological,
  author = {Dongsheng Wang and Qiang Xu and Shuai Wang and Quanyun Miao and Zhengguang Zhang and Xiaotao Xu and Hongyu Guo},
  title = {{Geological Conditions and Reservoir Formation Models of Low- to Middle-Rank Coalbed Methane in the Northern Part of the Ningxia Autonomous Region}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/pr13072079},
}
Figure