Genotypic clustering does not imply recent tuberculosis transmission in a high prevalence setting: A genomic epidemiology study in Lima, Peru

Avika Dixit, Luca Freschi, Roger Vargas, Róger Calderón, James C. Sacchettini, Francis Drobniewski, Jerome T. Galea, Carmen Contreras, Rosa Yataco, Zibiao Zhang, Leonid Lecca, Sergios‐Orestis Kolokotronis, Barun Mathema, Maha FarhatbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that traditional methods for tracking tuberculosis (TB) transmission can overestimate recent outbreaks in high-burden settings. By using whole-genome sequencing (WGS), researchers found that a cluster identified by older methods had actually been circulating for decades, highlighting the need for WGS to accurately understand TB epidemiology and inform control strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tracking the spread of infectious diseases like tuberculosis is crucial for effective public health interventions. Traditional methods, such as MIRU-VNTR typing, are often used to group similar bacterial strains and infer transmission events, forming "clusters." However, the utility and interpretation of these clusters in high-burden settings, where TB is endemic and transmission is continuous, remain unclear. Specifically, it's uncertain whether these clusters represent recent outbreaks or long-standing endemic strains. This paper aims to clarify this by applying whole-genome sequencing (WGS) to a large TB cluster in Lima, Peru, a high-prevalence setting, and comparing its findings to traditional methods.

Methods

The researchers performed whole-genome sequencing on 61 isolates from a larger cluster of 148 strains identified by MIRU-VNTR typing. They then compared transmission link inference using both epidemiological data and genomic data, including controversial variants. A time-calibrated phylogenetic tree was generated to estimate the emergence dates of the cluster and drug resistance acquisition events. To validate their findings, they analyzed genomic data from a TB outbreak in London and a larger dataset of public Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) genomes. They also investigated bacterial factors potentially contributing to transmission fitness.

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • 61 Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates from a large MIRU-VNTR cluster in Lima, Peru.
  • Genomic data from 148 strains initially identified by MIRU-VNTR typing.
  • Genomic data from 325 TB cases from an outbreak in London for validation.
  • A dataset of 12,032 public Mtb genomes to identify bacterial factors under positive selection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MIRU-VNTR clusters can mask long-term endemicity: What appears as a recent outbreak via MIRU-VNTR typing can, with WGS, be revealed as a lineage that has been circulating for many decades. This challenges the assumption that clusters directly equate to recent transmission events.
  • Genomic regions matter: Excluding certain genomic regions (like PE/PPE genes) from WGS analysis can lead to an underestimation of genetic diversity and potentially misinterpret transmission links. Including these regions, along with indels, provides a more granular and accurate picture.
  • Drug resistance evolution is complex: Resistance to drugs like rifampicin and pyrazinamide can emerge multiple times independently within a single cluster, suggesting different evolutionary pathways and acquisition events.
  • Host and bacterial factors intertwine: Transmission success is not solely due to bacterial evolution; host factors (like age and substance use) also play a significant role, interacting with bacterial traits to influence spread.

Key Results

  • The 57 most genetically homogeneous isolates within the cluster diverged around 1968 (95% HPD: 1945-1985), indicating decades of circulation rather than a recent outbreak.
  • Rifampicin resistance emerged at least three times independently within the cluster.
  • The study identified five cluster-defining single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), including one in the esxV gene, that may contribute to transmissibility.
  • In a London outbreak dataset, including PE/PPE variants and indels reduced the number of inferred transmission links by 11%, suggesting these regions are important for accurate inference.
  • Five patients were identified as having a particularly high "propensity to propagate" (PTP), linked to being younger, male, smear-positive, and having a history of substance use.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample size: While the study analyzed 61 isolates, the authors acknowledge that sequencing a subset of isolates might have led to missed links and an underestimation of diversity.
  • Contact tracing limitations: Contact tracing was primarily limited to households, potentially missing community-based transmission events.
  • Dating estimates: The dating estimates rely on previously reported molecular clock rates, which can have inherent uncertainties.

The authors suggest that WGS, especially when incorporating PE/PPE regions and indels, offers significantly higher resolution for understanding TB transmission in high-burden settings. Future work could focus on integrating WGS data more seamlessly with epidemiological investigations and exploring the identified bacterial factors for potential intervention targets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Whole genome sequencing (WGS) can elucidate Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) transmission patterns but more data is needed to guide its use in high-burden settings. In a household-based transmissibility study of 4,000 TB patients in Lima, Peru, we identified a large MIRU-VNTR Mtb cluster with a range of resistance phenotypes and studied host and bacterial factors contributing to its spread. Methods WGS was performed on 61 of 148 isolates in the cluster. We compared transmission link inference using epidemiological or genomic data with and without the inclusion of controversial variants, and estimated the dates of emergence of the cluster and antimicrobial drug resistance acquisition events by generating a time-calibrated phylogeny. We validated our findings in genomic data from an outbreak of 325 TB cases in London. Using a larger set of 12,032 public Mtb genomes, we determined bacterial factors characterizing this cluster and under positive selection in other Mtb lineages. Findings Four isolates were distantly related and the remaining 57 isolates diverged ca. 1968 (95% HPD: 1945-1985). Isoniazid resistance arose once, whereas rifampicin resistance emerged subsequently at least three times. Amplification of other drug resistance occurred as recently as within the last year of sampling. High quality PE/PPE variants and indels added information for transmission inference. We identified five cluster-defining SNPs, including esxV S23L to be potentially contributing to transmissibility. Interpretation Clusters defined by MIRU-VNTR typing, could be circulating for decades in a high-burden setting. WGS allows for an improved understanding of transmission, as well as bacterial resistance and fitness factors. Funding The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health (Peru Epi study U19-AI076217 and K01-ES026835 to MRF). The funding sources had no role in any aspect of the study, manuscript or decision to submit it for publication. Research in context Evidence before this study Use of whole genome sequencing (WGS) to study tuberculosis (TB) transmission has proven to have higher resolution that traditional typing methods in low-burden settings. The implications of its use in high-burden settings are not well understood. Added value of this study Using WGS, we found that TB clusters defined by traditional typing methods may be circulating for several decades. Genomic regions typically excluded from WGS analysis contain large amount of genetic variation that may affect interpretation of transmission events. We also identified five bacterial mutations that may contribute to transmission fitness. Implications of all the available evidence Added value of WGS for understanding TB transmission may be even higher in high-burden vs. low-burden settings. Methods integrating variants found in polymorphic sites and insertions and deletions are likely to have higher resolution. Several host and bacterial factors may be responsible for higher transmissibility that can be targets of intervention to interrupt TB transmission in communities.
BibTeX
@misc{dixit2018genotypic,
  author = {Avika Dixit and Luca Freschi and Roger Vargas and Róger Calderón and James C. Sacchettini and Francis Drobniewski and Jerome T. Galea and Carmen Contreras and Rosa Yataco and Zibiao Zhang and Leonid Lecca and Sergios‐Orestis Kolokotronis and Barun Mathema and Maha Farhat},
  title = {{Genotypic clustering does not imply recent tuberculosis transmission in a high prevalence setting: A genomic epidemiology study in Lima, Peru}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/418202},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure