Genotype × Environment Interaction for Appraisal of Iron and Zinc Rich Stable Genotypes in Lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.)

Sudip Bhattacharya, Sanjukta Roy, Mousumi Murmu, Sanjoy Gorai, Arpita Das, Jayeeta Banerjee, Santosh Kumar GuptaLegume 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Micronutrient malnutrition is a severe peril for the wellbeing of humankind, which can be holistically addressed through genetic biofortification. Lentil, proclaimed as "poor man’s meat," holds great promise in global biofortification programs. This study appraised genetic variability for iron (Fe) and zinc (Zn) content and elucidated the role of Genotype × Environment (G × E) interaction to identify stable, micronutrient-enriched lentil genotypes. By integrating Heritability-Adjusted Genotype plus Genotype-by-Environment (HA-GGE) biplots with Restricted Maximum Likelihood/Best Linear Unbiased Prediction (REML/BLUP), the study identified ILL-10123 and VL-156 as "ideal" genotypes for Fe and Zn content, respectively.

Introduction

Micronutrient malnutrition, often referred to as "hidden hunger," affects billions of people globally, with iron and zinc deficiencies being the most prevalent. Lentils (Lens culinaris) are a critical source of protein and minerals in many developing nations. However, breeding for higher nutrient density is complicated by Genotype × Environment (G × E) interactions. A variety that excels in one environment may underperform in another due to soil chemistry, climate, or management practices. To ensure the success of biofortification, it is essential to identify genotypes that are both nutrient-rich and stable across diverse growing conditions.

Methodology

The researchers evaluated 44 lentil genotypes (43 advanced breeding lines and one released variety) across six distinct environments in West Bengal, India, spanning three locations over two consecutive years. The study employed a robust mixed-model approach to untangle genetic potential from environmental noise:

  • REML/BLUP: Used to estimate true genetic values by accounting for environmental variance.
  • HA-GGE Biplot: A visualization tool that accounts for trait heritability to identify stable genotypes and ideal testing locations.
  • Summation Rank Index (SRI): A ranking system combining both Fe and Zn performance to identify superior all-around lines.

Results and Discussion

The analysis revealed substantial genetic diversity among the 44 genotypes. Iron content ranged from 48.07 to 107.45 mg/kg, and zinc content ranged from 38.72 to 60.07 mg/kg.

Distribution of Fe and Zn content across genotypes and environments.

The Impact of Environment

Statistical analysis showed that the environment accounted for the majority of variation in nutrient content—60.68% for Fe and 73.96% for Zn. This high environmental influence highlights the necessity of multi-location testing for biofortification programs.

Stability and Performance

The HA-GGE biplots allowed for the visualization of the trade-off between high nutrient concentration and stability. Genotypes positioned closest to the Average Environment Coordination (AEC) abscissa represent the ideal balance of high performance and consistency across all six environments.

Mean vs. Stability HA-GGE biplots for Fe and Zn.

Key findings include:

  • ILL-10123 (G9): Identified as the "ideal" genotype for iron content.
  • VL-156 (G41): Identified as the "ideal" genotype for zinc and the top-ranked genotype overall according to the Summation Rank Index.
  • Testing Locations: Kalyani (L1 and L2) was identified as an ideal testing ground due to its high discriminativeness (ability to highlight differences between genotypes) and representativeness of the target region.

Conclusion

This study provides a powerful statistical framework for identifying stable, nutrient-dense lentil genotypes. High broad-sense heritability for both Fe (0.81) and Zn (0.79) suggests that these traits can be effectively targeted in breeding programs. While the current scope is regional, the identified lines (ILL-10123 and VL-156) serve as vital parental material for future biofortified varieties. Future research should focus on validating these results across broader international agro-climatic zones and ensuring that nutrient enrichment does not come at the cost of total crop yield.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Micronutrient malnutrition is a severe peril for wellbeing of humankind, which can be holistically addressed through genetic biofortification. Lentil, proclaim as poor man’s meat can hold a great promise in global biofortification programme. The present study was designed to appraise genetic variability for Fe and Zn content and elucidate the role of Genotype × Environment interaction for delimitation of micronutrient enriched stable lentil genotypes integrating HA-GGE biplot with REML/BLUP. Methods: Grain Fe and Zn content of 44 lentil genotypes grown at three different locations of West Bengal during two consecutive years were estimated for deciphering the G × E interaction combining HA-GGE and REML/BLUP. Result: Results revealed substantial genetic variability for Fe (48.07 to 107.45 mg kg-1) and Zn (38.72 to 60.07 mg kg-1) in 44 lentil genotypes with significant influence of environment and GE interaction. The present study precisely detected ILL-10123 and VL-156 as the ‘ideal’ genotypes for Fe and Zn content, respectively in addition to non-redundant testing location. Identified genotypes and testing location aid in global biofortification programme for upscaling micronutrient concentration in lentil.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bhattacharya2024genotype,
  author = {Sudip Bhattacharya and Sanjukta Roy and Mousumi Murmu and Sanjoy Gorai and Arpita Das and Jayeeta Banerjee and Santosh Kumar Gupta},
  title = {{Genotype × Environment Interaction for Appraisal of Iron and Zinc Rich Stable Genotypes in Lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.)}},
  booktitle = {Legume},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18805/lr-5205},
}
Figure