Genomic insights into host–Endozoicomonadaceae cophylogeny

Zhuang Shao, Jian Zhang, Jiaxin Li, Jie LiMicrobial 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a strong evolutionary congruence (cophylogeny) between marine bacteria of the family Endozoicomonadaceae and their animal hosts, suggesting co-evolutionary histories. Importantly, it demonstrates that the genomic features of these bacteria, such as genome size, phage/insertion element content, and specific gene functions, are linked to the intimacy and longevity of their symbiotic relationships.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Marine ecosystems rely heavily on symbiotic relationships between microbes and host organisms. The Endozoicomonadaceae family is a particularly abundant and functionally diverse group of bacterial symbionts found across a wide range of marine animals. While previous research using 16S rRNA gene sequences hinted at cophylogenetic patterns (meaning the evolutionary trees of hosts and symbionts mirror each other), this approach has limitations. It doesn't capture the full picture of how the symbiont's genome itself might shape these long-term associations. This paper aims to bridge that gap by using whole-genome data to investigate the cophylogeny between Endozoicomonadaceae and their hosts, and crucially, to explore how genomic features influence the nature and stability of these symbioses.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Genome Collection and Annotation: They gathered 42 high-quality Endozoicomonadaceae genomes from various sources (cultivated, single-cell amplified, and metagenomic assembled). These genomes were reannotated using Prokka for consistency and assessed for quality using CheckM.
  • Genomic Feature Identification: Standard bioinformatics tools were used to identify orthologous groups (OrthoFinder), calculate genome-wide average nucleotide identity (ANI), and annotate functional genes (eggNOG-mapper, EnrichM). Novelty lies in the comprehensive analysis of phage content (Phage Search Tool Enhanced Release, geNomad) and insertion elements (UGENE, ISfinder) across these genomes.
  • Phylogenetic Reconstruction: Both bacterial and host phylogenetic trees were constructed using Bayesian methods based on sets of single-copy orthologous genes (for bacteria) and 18S rRNA, cytochrome c oxidase subunit I, and cytochrome b genes (for hosts).
  • Cophylogenetic Analysis: The Procrustean Approach to Cophylogeny (PACo) was used to quantify the topological congruence between host and symbiont trees. This method assesses how well the two evolutionary trees align. Additionally, event-based cophylogenetic analysis (eMPRess) was used to infer evolutionary events like cospeciation, duplication, and transfer.
  • Correlation Analysis: Spearman correlation was used to investigate potential relationships between cophylogenetic residuals (a measure of how well symbionts track hosts) and genomic features like genome size, phage count, and insertion element count.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available genomes of Endozoicomonadaceae members from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) and Zenodo. Host species information was also gathered from public databases. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strong Cophylogeny: The evolutionary histories of Endozoicomonadaceae bacteria and their marine animal hosts are significantly intertwined, indicating a long-term co-evolutionary relationship. This is a more robust finding than previous studies based on single genes.
  • Genomic Erosion Matters: Phages and insertion elements are actively shaping the genomes of these bacteria, leading to varying degrees of genome erosion. This isn't just random damage; it seems to be linked to their symbiotic lifestyle.
  • Smaller Genomes, Closer Ties: Bacteria with smaller, more "eroded" genomes tend to show a stronger cophylogenetic signal with their hosts. This suggests that genome reduction might be a hallmark of highly specialized and long-term symbiotic relationships.
  • Functional Genes for Interaction: Bacteria that exhibit closer associations with their hosts (indicated by smaller cophylogenetic residuals) possess specific genes related to infection processes and host-symbiont interactions. This points to a molecular basis for intimate symbiosis.

Key Results

  • A significant cophylogenetic pattern was detected between Endozoicomonadaceae and their hosts (P-value < 0.01).
  • The number of insertion elements varied from 0 to 22 across the studied genomes.
  • A total of 2739 phage genes were annotated, with most belonging to the order Caudoviricetes.
  • A significant difference in the number of phages was observed between stony coral-associated and sponge-associated Endozoicomonadaceae genomes.
  • Event-based cophylogenetic analysis revealed 65 evolutionary events, including 8 cospeciations, suggesting that cospeciation is a significant driver of these associations.
  • While trends were observed, statistical significance was not reached for correlations between cophylogenetic residuals and genome size, phage number, or insertion element number. However, the direction of these trends (smaller genomes, more phages/IS elements associated with closer cophylogeny) is noteworthy.
  • Specific genes related to the two-component system, bacterial motility, and immune response were enriched in Endozoicomonadaceae groups showing stronger cophylogenetic associations with their hosts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Significance: The authors note that while trends were observed, the correlations between genomic features and cophylogenetic residuals did not reach statistical significance. This could be due to sample size or the complexity of the interactions.
  • Time Calibration: The current cophylogenetic analysis tools do not support time-calibrated phylogenies, which would provide more accurate insights into the timing of evolutionary events.
  • Data Availability: The limited availability of symbiont data can lead to incomplete phylogenetic branches, potentially affecting the accuracy of cophylogenetic event analysis.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future studies should incorporate more comprehensive genomic data and potentially time-calibrated phylogenies to further elucidate host-symbiont cophylogeny. They also emphasize the need to consider genomic features when studying these relationships. A more detailed analysis of a larger dataset is recommended for a more robust understanding.

Summary updated

Abstract

The congruence between host and symbiont phylogenies reflects the evolutionary links among ecologically important interactions. As potential key symbionts, the members affiliated to the family <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> have previously been investigated for the cophylogenetic relationship with their hosts using their 16S rRNA gene sequences. However, this approach neglects the genomic features of symbionts that may influence the long-term associations between <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> members and their hosts. Here, we collected available high-quality genomes of <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> from diverse hosts and investigated their genomic features, including genome size, phages, insertion elements and the composition of functional genes. We also tested the host<i>-Endozoicomonadaceae</i> cophylogeny and examined the correlation between the cophylogenetic squared residuals and the genomic features of <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> members. Our results revealed a cophylogenetic pattern between members of the <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> family and their various hosts. Moreover, we found that the investigated genomes of <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> members were differentially eroded by phages and insertion elements. Additionally, <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> members with smaller, more eroded genomes tended to exhibit lower cophylogenetic residuals with their hosts. Gene function analysis further revealed that <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> members with closer associations with their hosts carried specific genes related to infection processes and host-symbiont interactions. This study suggests that the genomic features of <i>Endozoicomonadaceae</i> members may influence long-term host<i>-Endozoicomonadaceae</i> intimate associations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shao2025genomic,
  author = {Zhuang Shao and Jian Zhang and Jiaxin Li and Jie Li},
  title = {{Genomic insights into host–Endozoicomonadaceae cophylogeny}},
  booktitle = {Microbial},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1099/mgen.0.001384},
}
Figure