Genomic divergence in allopatric Northern Cardinals of the North American warm deserts is associated with behavioral differentiation

Kaiya L. Provost, William M. Mauck, Brian Tilston SmithbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how behavioral differences, specifically song recognition, contribute to speciation in Northern Cardinals separated by the Cochise Filter Barrier. The research reveals that despite some historical gene flow, strong song discrimination between desert populations acts as a reproductive barrier, suggesting that behavioral isolation can initiate and maintain speciation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Speciation, the process by which new species arise, is often initiated by geographic isolation. However, it's not fully understood how barriers that don't completely halt gene flow can still lead to distinct species. This paper explores how behavioral traits, like song recognition in birds, can act as a "filter" across biogeographic barriers, preventing gene flow and promoting divergence even when genetic isolation isn't absolute. The authors focus on Northern Cardinals in the Sonoran and Chihuahuan deserts, separated by the Cochise Filter Barrier, a region of transitional habitat. They aim to disentangle the roles of geographic distance, dialect changes, and behavioral isolation in maintaining genetic differentiation between these populations.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Genomic Analysis: They used genome-wide markers (specifically ddRAD sequencing) to model the demographic history of the Northern Cardinal populations. This involved fitting data to isolation and isolation-with-migration models to infer divergence times and gene flow patterns.
  • Behavioral Experiments: They conducted reciprocal call-broadcast experiments with male Northern Cardinals. This involved playing songs from different geographic locations (local, distant within the same desert, and across the barrier) and observing the males' aggression levels. This allowed them to assess song recognition and discrimination.
  • Statistical Modeling: Generalized linear mixed models (GLMMs) were used to analyze the aggression data, accounting for site-specific variations and stimulus set effects. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to reduce multiple aggression measures into a single composite score.

Datasets

The study utilized genomic data from vouchered Northern Cardinal samples collected from the Sonoran Desert (N=54) and the Chihuahuan Desert (N=31). Additional samples from C. cardinalis carneus (Pacific Coast) and C. sinuatus were used as outgroups. Behavioral data was collected from 67 sites in the Sonoran Desert and 61 sites in the Chihuahuan Desert. Song recordings were sourced from Xeno-Canto and also recorded by the authors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Song as a Reproductive Filter: The study strongly suggests that song discrimination acts as a significant reproductive barrier, even in the presence of some historical gene flow. This highlights the power of behavioral traits in driving speciation.
  • Behavioral Isolation Precedes Complete Genetic Isolation: The findings indicate that strong song discrimination can evolve and maintain divergence before complete genetic isolation is achieved, challenging the notion that genetic divergence must precede behavioral divergence.
  • Geographic Distance vs. Behavioral Dialect: The research effectively disentangles the effects of geographic distance (and associated dialect changes) from true behavioral isolation across the barrier. While distant songs elicited less aggression than local songs, songs from across the barrier elicited minimal aggression, suggesting a specific response to allopatric populations.
  • Unidirectional Gene Flow: The demographic modeling revealed a best-fit model of unidirectional gene flow from the Chihuahuan to the Sonoran Desert, albeit at a very low rate. This suggests a historical asymmetry in dispersal or colonization.

Key Results

  • Demographic History: The best-fit demographic model indicated divergence between Sonoran and Chihuahuan populations around 606,181 years ago, with a much older divergence from the C. c. carneus outgroup (~1.4 million years ago).
  • Gene Flow: A model of unidirectional gene flow from the Chihuahuan to the Sonoran Desert was supported, with a very low estimated gene flow rate (mean 3.43 x 10⁻⁷). This suggests historical introgression rather than recent gene flow.
  • Aggression Responses: Male Northern Cardinals showed significantly higher aggression towards local songs compared to songs from other locations. Aggression towards "Across-Barrier" songs was minimal, similar to responses to control songs (Cactus Wren), indicating they were not recognized as conspecific.
  • Desert Differences: While both populations showed strong discrimination against across-barrier songs, Sonoran individuals were significantly more aggressive to local songs than Chihuahuan individuals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Female Choice Not Tested: The study focused on male aggression as a proxy for mate recognition. The authors acknowledge that they did not directly test female mate choice, which is a critical component of sexual selection and speciation. Future work should investigate female responses to different song dialects.
  • Anecdotal Female Responses: While not a primary focus, anecdotal observations suggested that female Northern Cardinals might also show preferences for local dialects, warranting further investigation.
  • Contemporary Contact Zone: The study focused on allopatric populations, meaning there is no current contact zone. This allowed for the examination of isolation-driven divergence but doesn't directly address processes occurring during secondary contact.
  • Broader Community Context: The authors suggest that future studies could investigate other bird species codistributed across the Cochise Filter Barrier to see if similar patterns of song discrimination and genetic divergence are observed, providing a broader understanding of how such barriers shape biodiversity.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Biogeographic barriers are thought to be important in initiating speciation through geographic isolation, but they rarely indiscriminately and completely reduce gene flow across the entire community. Understanding which species’ attributes regulate a barrier could help elucidate how speciation is initiated. Here, we investigated the association of behavioral isolation on population differentiation in Northern Cardinals ( Cardinalis cardinalis ) distributed across the Cochise Filter Barrier, a region of transitional habitat which separates the Sonoran and Chihuahuan deserts. Using genome-wide markers, we modeled demographic history by fitting the data to isolation and isolation-with-migration models. The best-fit model indicated that desert populations diverged in the mid-Pleistocene and there has been historically low, unidirectional gene flow into the Sonoran Desert. We then tested song recognition using reciprocal call-broadcast experiments to compare song recognition between deserts, controlling for song dialect changes within deserts. We found that male Northern Cardinals in both deserts were most aggressive to local songs and failed to recognize across-barrier songs. A correlation of genomic differentiation despite historic introgression and strong song discrimination is consistent with a model where speciation is initiated across a barrier and maintained by behavioral isolation.
BibTeX
@misc{provost2018genomic,
  author = {Kaiya L. Provost and William M. Mauck and Brian Tilston Smith},
  title = {{Genomic divergence in allopatric Northern Cardinals of the North American warm deserts is associated with behavioral differentiation}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/347492},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure