Genomic and phenotypic characterization of Streptococcus mutans isolates suggests key gene clusters in regulating its interaction with Streptococcus gordonii

Shanshan Liu, Yu Sun, Yudong Liu, Fuyong Hu, Li Xu, Qingwei Zheng, Qinglong Wang, Guojin Zeng, Kai ZhangFrontiers in Microbiology 2022 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Microbiology, uses a multi-omics approach to identify the genetic "arsenal" that Streptococcus mutans—the primary culprit behind tooth decay—uses to outcompete its neighbor, the relatively "friendly" Streptococcus gordonii. By comparing 80 clinical isolates, researchers identified three specific gene clusters (SMU_137–140, SMU_1315c–1317c, and SMU_1908c–1909c) that appear to regulate this microbial warfare, offering new targets for preventing dental caries.

TL;DR

Researchers integrated genomic, transcriptomic, and phenotypic data from 80 clinical S. mutans isolates to identify novel gene clusters that regulate its ability to antagonize S. gordonii. The study reveals that beyond well-known bacteriocins, complex metabolic and transport-related gene clusters are critical for S. mutans to dominate the dental plaque environment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Our mouths are a microbial battlefield. Streptococcus mutans is a major pathogen that produces acid, leading to dental caries (cavities). However, it doesn't live alone. Early colonizers like Streptococcus gordonii actually help maintain health by producing hydrogen peroxide ($H_2O_2$) and alkaline ammonia to inhibit S. mutans.

For S. mutans to cause decay, it must successfully antagonize and displace S. gordonii. While scientists knew that S. mutans uses "mutacins" (antibiotic-like peptides) to fight back, not all clinical isolates behave the same way. This paper addresses the gap in our understanding of what other genetic factors, beyond mutacins, allow certain strains of S. mutans to be more aggressive competitors than others.

Methods

The authors employed a "funnel" approach to narrow down candidate genes:

  1. Phenotyping: They collected 80 clinical isolates of S. mutans from children and used a bacteriocin assay to group them into "antagonistic" (those that killed S. gordonii) and "non-antagonistic" groups.
  2. Comparative Genomics: They sequenced the genomes of all 80 isolates to find Differentially Distributed Genes (DDGs)—genes present in one group but absent in the other.
  3. Transcriptomics (RNA-seq): They compared the gene expression levels of representative strains from both groups to see which genes were actually "turned on" during competition.
  4. Bioinformatics (antiSMASH): They used specialized software to predict secondary metabolite biosynthetic gene clusters.
  5. Validation: Finally, they used qRT-PCR on 35 isolates to validate the expression of 16 top candidate genes.

Datasets

  • Clinical Isolates: 80 S. mutans isolates collected from children in Bengbu, China (62 from children with caries, 18 from caries-free children).
  • Reference Genomes: S. mutans UA159 served as the primary reference.
  • Comparative Species: 40 other bacterial species (mostly other Streptococci) were used for Average Nucleotide Identity (ANI) analysis to ensure the isolates were correctly identified.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Genetic Diversity Matters: Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA) showed that antagonistic and non-antagonistic strains cluster separately, meaning their overall genetic makeup is significantly different, not just a few isolated genes.
  • Beyond Mutacin IV: Interestingly, the expression of known mutacin IV genes didn't show a statistically significant difference between the two groups in the RNA-seq data. This suggests that while mutacins are important, they aren't the only factor determining competitive success in clinical strains.
  • Metabolic Warfare: The study highlighted the SMU_137–139 cluster, which is involved in malolactic fermentation (MLF). MLF helps bacteria survive acid stress. Surprisingly, these genes were downregulated in the antagonistic group, suggesting a complex trade-off between survival and aggression.
  • Synergistic Clusters: Adjacent genes in the identified clusters showed extremely high expression correlation (coefficients > 0.9), indicating they function together as single units (operons) to regulate interaction.

Key Results

  • Genomic Findings: Identified 33 genes positively correlated and 61 genes negatively correlated with antagonism.
  • Transcriptomic Findings: RNA-seq revealed 11 upregulated and 43 downregulated genes in the antagonistic group.
  • Validated Targets: qRT-PCR confirmed that:
  • SMU_137–140 (malate dehydrogenase, permease, etc.) and SMU_1315c–1317c (transport-related) were significantly downregulated in antagonistic strains.
  • SMU_1908c–1909c were significantly upregulated in antagonistic strains.
  • Caries Correlation: Interestingly, the ability to inhibit S. gordonii did not strictly correlate with whether the child had cavities ($p = 0.348$), suggesting that while antagonism is a prerequisite for virulence, other environmental factors also play a role.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study is primarily observational and correlative. While they identified these gene clusters, they haven't yet performed "knockout" experiments to prove that deleting these genes actually stops the antagonism.

Additionally, the isolates were all from a single geographic region (Bengbu, China). Because S. mutans shows high regional genetic variation, these findings need to be validated in global cohorts. Future work will likely focus on the functional mechanisms of the SMU_1315c transport-related gene and the specific metabolic pathways that give antagonistic strains their edge.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Streptococcus mutans</i> (<i>S. mutans</i>) is one of the primary pathogens responsible for dental caries. <i>Streptococcus gordonii</i> (<i>S. gordonii</i>) is one of the early colonizers of dental plaque and can compete with <i>S. mutans</i> for growth. In the present analysis, we explored key target genes against <i>S. gordonii</i> in <i>S. mutans</i> using 80 <i>S. mutans</i> clinical isolates with varying capabilities against <i>S. gordonii</i>. A principal coordinate analysis revealed significant genetic diversity differences between antagonistic and non-antagonistic groups. Genomic comparisons revealed 33 and 61 genes that were, respectively, positively and negatively correlated with <i>S. mutans</i> against <i>S. gordonii</i>, with RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq) highlighting 11 and 43 genes that were, respectively, upregulated and downregulated in the antagonistic group. Through a combination of these results and antiSMASH analysis, we selected 16 genes for qRT-PCR validation in which the expression levels of SMU_137 (malate dehydrogenase, mleS), SMU_138 (malate permease, mleP), SMU_139 (oxalate decarboxylase, oxdC), and SMU_140 (glutathione reductase) were consistent with RNA-seq results. SMU_1315c-1317c (SMU_1315c transport-related gene) and SMU_1908c-1909c were, respectively, downregulated and upregulated in the antagonistic group. The expression patterns of adjacent genes were closely related, with correlation coefficient values greater than 0.9. These data reveal new targets (SMU_137-140, SMU_1315c-1317c, and SMU_1908c-1909c) for investigating the critical gene clusters against <i>S. gordonii</i> in <i>S. mutans</i> clinical isolates.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022genomic,
  author = {Shanshan Liu and Yu Sun and Yudong Liu and Fuyong Hu and Li Xu and Qingwei Zheng and Qinglong Wang and Guojin Zeng and Kai Zhang},
  title = {{Genomic and phenotypic characterization of Streptococcus mutans isolates suggests key gene clusters in regulating its interaction with Streptococcus gordonii}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2022.945108},
}
Figure