Genomic analysis reveals a functional role for myocardial trabeculae in adults

Hannah V. Meyer, Timothy J. W. Dawes, Marta Serrani, Wenjia Bai, Paweł Tokarczuk, Jiashen Cai, Antonio de Marvao, Daniel Rueckert, Paul M. Matthews, Maria Laura Costantino, Ewan Birney, Stuart A. Cook, Declan P. O’ReganbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a multi-pronged approach combining genomics, advanced imaging analysis, and computational modeling to reveal that the intricate network of muscular structures lining the adult heart's ventricles (trabeculae) plays a crucial, previously unrecognized role in cardiovascular function. The findings suggest that increased trabecular complexity causally enhances ventricular performance and influences electrical activity, challenging the long-held notion of trabeculae as mere embryonic remnants.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For centuries, the presence of complex muscular ridges (trabeculae) on the inner surface of adult heart ventricles has been a puzzle. While their formation is understood during embryonic development, their persistence and functional significance in mature hearts have remained largely enigmatic. It was widely assumed they were evolutionary leftovers from fetal development, with no active role in adult cardiac physiology. This paper aims to resolve this enigma by investigating whether these trabeculae have a functional impact on the adult heart's performance and electrical activity, and to identify the genetic underpinnings of this trait.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated, multi-disciplinary strategy:

  • Deep Learning-based Image Analysis: A fully convolutional neural network was used for automated segmentation of cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) images to precisely quantify trabecular complexity. This allowed for the calculation of a "fractal dimension" (FD) as a measure of this complexity.
  • Population Genomics (GWAS): Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) were conducted on a large cohort (UK Biobank) to identify genetic variants associated with trabecular complexity (FD). These findings were then replicated in an independent cohort.
  • Mendelian Randomization (MR): This statistical technique was used to infer causal relationships. By using genetic variants as instrumental variables, the researchers could assess whether variations in trabecular complexity cause changes in cardiac function (like stroke volume and QRS duration), rather than just being correlated.
  • In Silico Biomechanical Simulations: A finite-element model of the left ventricle was created to simulate cardiac mechanics. This allowed researchers to experimentally vary trabecular complexity while keeping other factors constant, and observe the direct impact on ventricular performance and hemodynamics.
  • Functional and Molecular Annotations: Discovered genetic loci were cross-referenced with existing databases (e.g., GTEx for gene expression) to understand their potential molecular roles and associations with other physiological traits.

Datasets

  • UK Biobank: A large prospective cohort study with approximately 500,000 individuals, providing deep genetic and phenotypic data. For this study, 18,097 participants with cardiac MRI data were used for discovery.
  • UK Digital Heart Project: An independent validation cohort of 1,129 healthy adults from London, UK, with both genotype and CMR imaging data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Trabeculae are Functionally Relevant in Adults: The most significant insight is that trabeculae are not just vestigial structures but actively contribute to adult cardiac function. This challenges a long-standing assumption in cardiology.
  • Complexity Drives Performance: Increased trabecular complexity is causally linked to improved ventricular performance, specifically higher stroke volume and stroke work. This suggests a direct mechanical advantage conferred by the intricate structure.
  • Genetic Basis for Trabecular Structure: The study identified 16 distinct genetic loci associated with trabecular complexity, many of which are linked to known cardiac function genes or developmental pathways, providing a genetic foundation for this trait.
  • Link to Electrical Activity: Trabecular complexity also shows a correlation with electrical phenotypes, specifically QRS duration, suggesting a role in the heart's conduction system.
  • Developmental Echoes: Genes associated with trabecular complexity are often expressed in the fetal heart or vasculature, hinting at a continued, albeit subtle, developmental influence in adulthood.

Key Results

  • 16 Genetic Loci Identified: The study identified 16 independent genetic loci associated with left ventricular trabecular complexity.
  • Causal Link to Stroke Volume: Mendelian randomization and biomechanical simulations strongly supported a causal relationship between increased trabecular complexity and higher stroke volume. For example, the finite element model showed that increasing FD from 1.11 to 1.8 led to an increase in stroke volume from 60 ml to 80.3 ml.
  • Association with QRS Duration: A positive correlation was observed between trabecular complexity and QRS duration, and Mendelian randomization confirmed a causal link, suggesting trabeculae influence cardiac electrical conduction.
  • Replication: The genetic associations were successfully replicated in an independent cohort, strengthening the findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Observational Nature: While Mendelian randomization strengthens causal inference, it is still based on observational data. The authors acknowledge the potential for pleiotropy (genes affecting multiple traits) and the need for robust statistical methods to address it.
  • Model Simplifications: The finite element model, while sophisticated, involves simplifications of the complex in vivo cardiac environment.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring the precise molecular mechanisms by which the identified genes influence trabecular formation and function. Further research could also investigate how trabecular complexity might be altered in various cardiovascular diseases and whether it represents a therapeutic target. The study lays the groundwork for understanding how this intricate cardiac structure contributes to overall cardiovascular health and disease.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Since being first described by Leonardo da Vinci in 1513 it has remained an enigma why the endocardial surfaces of the adult heart retain a complex network of muscular trabeculae – with their persistence thought to be a vestige of embryonic development. For causative physiological inference we harness population genomics, image-based intermediate phenotyping and in silico modelling to determine the effect of this complex cardiovascular trait on function. Using deep learning-based image analysis we identified genetic associations with trabecular complexity in 18,097 UK Biobank participants which were replicated in an independently measured cohort of 1,129 healthy adults. Genes in these associated regions are enriched for expression in the fetal heart or vasculature and implicate loci associated with haemodynamic phenotypes and developmental pathways. A causal relationship between increasing trabecular complexity and both ventricular performance and electrical activity are supported by complementary biomechanical simulations and Mendelian randomisation studies. These findings show that myocardial trabeculae are a previously-unrecognised determinant of cardiovascular physiology in adult humans.
BibTeX
@misc{meyer2019genomic,
  author = {Hannah V. Meyer and Timothy J. W. Dawes and Marta Serrani and Wenjia Bai and Paweł Tokarczuk and Jiashen Cai and Antonio de Marvao and Daniel Rueckert and Paul M. Matthews and Maria Laura Costantino and Ewan Birney and Stuart A. Cook and Declan P. O’Regan},
  title = {{Genomic analysis reveals a functional role for myocardial trabeculae in adults}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/553651},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure