Genome-wide Comparative Analysis Reveals Possible Common Ancestors of NBS Domain Containing Genes in Hybrid Citrus sinensis Genome and Original Citrus clementina Genome

Yunsheng Wang, Lijuan Zhou, Dazhi Li, Amy Lawton‐Rauh, Pradip K. Srimani, Liangying Dai, Yongping Duan, Feng LuobioRxiv 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive analysis of NBS-encoding genes across three citrus genomes, revealing their evolutionary origins and structural diversity. The findings suggest that these crucial disease resistance genes in citrus likely share common ancestors and have undergone significant expansion and diversification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Plant immune systems rely on a diverse array of disease resistance (R) genes to detect and respond to pathogens. Among these, nucleotide-binding site (NBS)-encoding genes are a major class, playing a critical role in plant defense. Understanding the evolution and organization of these genes is key to improving crop resilience. While whole-genome sequences for some citrus species have become available, a comparative analysis of NBS genes across different citrus genomes, particularly between hybrid and original species, was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by investigating the features, evolutionary history, and potential common ancestry of NBS genes in Citrus clementina and two Citrus sinensis (hybrid) genomes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Genome-wide identification and annotation: They used HMMsearch and BLASTP to identify NBS-containing proteins across the three citrus genomes.
  • Phylogenetic analysis: NBS domain sequences were used to construct a Maximum Likelihood phylogenetic tree, revealing three main groups (TIR, CC1, and CC2) based on domain structure.
  • Motif analysis: MEME was used to identify conserved motifs within different NBS gene groups, providing insights into their functional domains and evolutionary origins.
  • Sequence variation analysis: They examined positively selected sites to understand evolutionary dynamics and mutation accumulation events.
  • Re-sequencing data mapping: Reads from pomelo and mandarin orange genomes were mapped to the C. sinensis genome to assess the conservation of NBS genes.
  • Gene cluster and synteny analysis: They investigated the physical clustering of NBS genes on chromosomes and identified syntenic blocks between genomes.
  • Gene conversion and duplication detection: Tools like GENECONV and MCScanX were used to identify these evolutionary events.
  • Pseudogene identification: PseudoPipe was employed to identify non-functional NBS genes.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Genome sequences and annotations:
    • Citrus clementina (from Citrus Genome Database)
    • Citrus sinensis USA (sweet orange, from Citrus Genome Database)
    • Citrus sinensis China (Chinese sweet orange, from Citrus sinensis annotation project)
  • Resequencing data:
    • Three Citrus maxima (pomelo) genomes
    • Three Citrus reticulata (Mandarin orange) genomes

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shared Ancestry: The phylogenetic analysis showed that NBS genes from the three citrus genomes are largely mixed within clades, strongly suggesting a common ancestral origin for these genes across citrus species.
  • Structural Diversity: NBS genes were classified into three main groups (TIR, CC1, CC2) based on their N-terminal domains, with CC-containing genes further divided into two distinct evolutionary origins.
  • Hybrid Genome Complexity: The NBS genes in the hybrid C. sinensis genome show significant homology to genes found in its parent species (C. maxima and C. reticulata), explaining their similarity to C. clementina.
  • Evolutionary Dynamics: NBS genes are highly dynamic, shaped by birth-and-death processes, gene duplications, conversions, recombination, and transposable element insertions, leading to both expansion and loss of genes.
  • Citrus Specificity: Citrus NBS genes appear to have a higher proportion of genes lacking LRR domains compared to other plant species like Arabidopsis and Populus.

Key Results

  • Gene Numbers: The study identified a substantial number of NBS genes: 618 in C. clementina, 650 in C. sinensis China, and 508 in C. sinensis USA.
  • Phylogenetic Groups: The phylogenetic tree clearly separated NBS genes into three main groups: TIR, CC1, and CC2.
  • Motif Conservation: Motifs identified in TIR domains of citrus NBS genes showed similarity to those in Arabidopsis and Populus, while CC domain motifs suggested different evolutionary origins for CC1 and CC2 groups.
  • Gene Clustering: A high percentage of NBS genes (84.9% in C. clementina, 76.9% in C. sinensis China) were found to be physically clustered on chromosomes.
  • Tandem Duplication: Tandem duplication was identified as a primary mechanism for the expansion of NBS genes in the Citrus genus.
  • Gene Conversion: Gene conversion events were prevalent, particularly within clusters and between genes of the same group.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Genome Assembly: The study acknowledges that the assembly of the C. sinensis USA genome is more fragmentary, which might affect the completeness of the NBS gene identification and analysis in that species.
  • Further Comparative Studies: The authors suggest that comparing NBS genes across more diverse citrus genomes could further elucidate their evolution and adaptation mechanisms.
  • Functional Characterization: While structural and evolutionary aspects are covered, future work could focus on the functional characterization of these NBS genes to understand their specific roles in disease resistance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Recently available whole genome sequences of three citrus species: one Citrus clementina and two Citrus sinensis genomes have made it possible to understand the features of candidate disease resistance genes with nucleotide-binding sites (NBS) domain in Citrus and how NBS genes differ between hybrid and original Citrus species. Result We identified and re-annotated NBS genes from three citrus genomes and found similar numbers of NBS genes in those citrus genomes. Phylogenetic analysis of all citrus NBS genes across three genomes showed that there are three approximately evenly numbered groups: one group contains the Toll-Interleukin receptor (TIR) domain and two different groups that contain the Coiled Coil (CC) domain. Motif analysis confirmed that the two groups of CC-containing NBS genes are from different evolutionary origins. We partitioned NBS genes into clades using NBS domain sequence distances and found most clades include NBS genes from all three citrus genomes. This suggests that NBS genes in three citrus genomes may come from shared ancestral origins. We also mapped the re-sequenced reads of three pomelo and three Mandarin orange genomes onto the Citrus sinensis genome. We found that most NBS genes of the hybrid C. sinensis genome have corresponding homologous genes in both pomelo and mandarin genome. The homologous NBS genes in pomelo and mandarin may explain why the NBS genes in their hybrid Citrus sinensis are similar to those in Citrus clementina in this study. Furthermore, sequence variation amongst citrus NBS genes were shaped by multiple independent and shared accelerated mutation accumulation events among different groups of NBS genes and in different citrus genomes. Conclusion Our comparative analyses yield valuable insight into the understanding of the structure, evolution and organization of NBS genes in Citrus genomes. There are significantly more NBS genes in Citrus genomes compared to other plant species. NBS genes in hybrid C. sinensis genomes are very similar to those in progenitor C. clementina genome and they may be derived from possible common ancestral gene copies. Furthermore, our comprehensive analysis showed that there are three groups of plant NBS genes while CC-containing NBS genes can be divided into two groups.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2014genome,
  author = {Yunsheng Wang and Lijuan Zhou and Dazhi Li and Amy Lawton‐Rauh and Pradip K. Srimani and Liangying Dai and Yongping Duan and Feng Luo},
  title = {{Genome-wide Comparative Analysis Reveals Possible Common Ancestors of NBS Domain Containing Genes in Hybrid <i>Citrus sinensis</i> Genome and Original <i>Citrus clementina</i> Genome}},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1101/008219},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure