Genome-wide association study meta-analysis of suicide attempt identifies twelve genome-wide significant loci and implicates genetic risks for specific health factors

Anna R. Docherty, Niamh Mullins, Allison E. Ashley‐Koch, Xuejun Qin, Jonathan R. I. Coleman, Andrey A. Shabalin, Jooeun Kang, Balasz Murnyak, Frank R. Wendt, Mark J. Adams, Adrián I. Campos, Emily DiBlasi, Janice M. Fullerton, Henry R. Kranzler, Amanda V. Bakian, Eric T. Monson, Miguel E. Rentería, Consuelo Walss‐Bass, Ole A. Andreassen, Cynthia M. Bulik, Howard J. Edenberg, Ronald C. Kessler, J. John Mann, John I. Nürnberger, Giorgio Pistis, Fabian Streit, Robert J. Ursano, Renato Polimonti, Michelle F. Dennis, Melanie E. Garrett, Lauren P. Hair, Philip D. Harvey, Elizabeth R. Hauser, Michael A. Hauser, Jennifer E. Huffman, Daniel Jacobson, Jennifer H. Lindquist, Ravi Madduri, Benjamin H. McMahon, David W. Oslin, Jodie Trafton, Swapnil Awasthi, Andrew W. Bergen, Wade H. Berrettini, Martin Bohus, Harry Brandt, Xiao Chang, Hsi‐Chung Chen, Wei J. Chen, Erik D. Christensen, Steven Crawford, Scott J. Crow, Philibert Duriez, Alexis C. Edwards, Fernando Fernández‐Aranda, Manfred M. Fichter, Hanga Galfalvy, Steven Gallinger, Michael J. Gandal, Philip Gorwood, Yiran Guo, Jonathan D. Hafferty, Håkon Håkonarson, Katherine A. Halmi, Akitoyo Hishimoto, Sonia Jain, Stéphane Jamain, Susana Jiménez‐Múrcia, Craig Johnson, Allan S. Kaplan, Walter H. Kaye, Pamela K. Keel, James L. Kennedy, Minsoo Kim, Kelly L. Klump, Daniel Levey, Dong Li, Shih‐Cheng Liao, Klaus Lieb, Lisa Lilenfeld, Adriana Lori, Pierre J. Magistretti, Christian R. Marshall, James E. Mitchell, R Myers, Satoshi Okazaki, Ikuo Otsuka, Dalila Pinto, Abigail Powers, Nicolás Ramoz, Stephan Ripke, Stefan Roepke, Vsevolod Rozanov, Stephen W. Scherer, Christian Schmahl, Marcus Sokolowski, Anna Starnawska, Michael Strober, Mei‐Hsin Su, Laura M. ThorntonmedRxiv 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Objective: Suicidal behavior is heritable and a major cause of death worldwide. This study leveraged genetic cohorts from two large-scale genome-wide association studies (GWAS) to conduct the largest GWAS meta-analysis of suicide attempt (SA) to date. Methods: The study comprised 22 cohorts, including 43,871 SA cases and 915,025 ancestry-matched controls. Analytical methods included multi-ancestry inverse variance-weighted fixed effects meta-analyses, gene/gene-set enrichment, Mendelian Randomization, and genetic correlation analyses. Results: Multi-ancestry and European ancestry meta-analyses identified 12 risk loci (p < 5×10⁻⁸) implicating genes such as DRD2, SLC6A9, and NLGN1. The multi-ancestry SNP-based heritability was 5.7%. Significant shared genetic variation was found with ADHD, smoking, and risk tolerance, even after conditioning on major depressive disorder (MDD) and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Conclusions: This analysis identifies several risk loci and establishes significant shared genetic covariation with clinical phenotypes, providing insights into the genetic architecture of suicide attempt across major ancestry groups.

Introduction

Suicide is a leading cause of death globally, yet its biological underpinnings remain poorly understood. While suicidal behavior is known to be heritable—with estimates ranging from 30% to 55%—identifying specific genetic markers has been historically difficult. This difficulty stems from small sample sizes in previous studies and the high degree of comorbidity between suicide attempt (SA) and other psychiatric conditions. A central question in psychiatric genetics is whether the genetic risk for suicide is merely a byproduct of risks for conditions like MDD or PTSD, or if a "suicide-specific" genetic architecture exists. This study leverages massive datasets and advanced statistical conditioning to untangle these risks.

Methods

The researchers conducted a meta-analysis of 22 cohorts, combining data from the International Suicide Genetics Consortium (ISGC) and the Million Veteran Program (MVP). The primary analytical framework involved multi-ancestry meta-analyses using inverse variance-weighted fixed-effects models across European (EUR), African/African-American (AA), and East Asian (EAS) ancestry admixtures.

To isolate suicide-specific signals, the team employed Multi-Trait-Based Conditional & Joint Analysis (mtCOJO) to condition SA results on the genetic risk for MDD and PTSD. Biological insights were further explored using Summary-based Mendelian Randomization (SMR) to integrate GWAS data with brain eQTL data, and MAGMA for tissue-set and drug-target enrichment analyses.

Datasets and Cohort Composition

The study analyzed a total of 43,871 suicide attempt cases and 915,025 ancestry-matched controls. The ISGC contributed 18 cohorts, primarily civilian, while the MVP provided a large sample of U.S. military veterans. The ancestry breakdown was approximately 81% European, 11% African/African-American, 5% East Asian, and 3% Latin American.

Table 1: Breakdown of cohorts, ancestries, and sample sizes for suicide attempt cases and controls.

Results

The meta-analysis identified 12 genome-wide significant risk loci (p < 5 × 10⁻⁸). Eight loci were identified in the multi-ancestry analysis, with four additional loci found in the European-only analysis. These loci implicated several key genes, including DRD2 (Dopamine Receptor D2), SLC6A9, FURIN, NLGN1, SOX5, PDE4B, and CACNG2. The multi-ancestry SNP-based heritability of SA was estimated at 5.7% on the liability scale.

A significant finding was the "suicide diathesis." Genetic correlations with ADHD ($r_G = 0.55$), smoking ($r_G = 0.46$), and risk tolerance remained significant even after conditioning on MDD and PTSD. This suggests that the genetic risk for suicide is tied to a model involving altered decision-making and impulsivity rather than just mood symptoms. Furthermore, tissue enrichment analysis highlighted the pituitary gland and brain tissues, aligning with theories regarding the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis response to stress.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study represents the largest GWAS meta-analysis of suicide attempt to date. The identification of 12 loci and the persistence of genetic correlations with impulsivity-related traits after conditioning for major psychiatric comorbidities provide strong evidence for a unique genetic signature for suicide.

However, limitations remain. Despite the multi-ancestry design, the majority of the sample was of European descent, and no genome-wide significant loci were found in the smaller African or East Asian sub-groups, highlighting the need for greater global diversity in future research. Additionally, while SA and suicide death are genetically similar, future studies with even larger samples may be able to distinguish the nuances between these phenotypes and between suicidal ideation versus action. These findings provide critical insights into the genetic factors associated with suicide attempt across diverse populations and clinical settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Objective Suicidal behavior is heritable and a major cause of death worldwide. Two large-scale genome-wide association studies (GWAS) recently discovered and cross-validated genome-wide significant (GWS) loci for suicide attempt (SA). The current study leveraged the genetic cohorts from both studies to conduct the largest GWAS meta-analysis of SA to date. Multi-ancestry and admixture-specific meta-analyses were conducted within groups of significant African, East Asian, and European ancestry admixtures. Methods This study was comprised of 22 cohorts, including 43,871 SA cases and 915,025 ancestry-matched controls. Analytical methods across multi-ancestry and individual ancestry admixtures included inverse variance-weighted fixed effects meta-analyses, followed by gene, gene-set, tissue-set, and drug-target enrichment, as well as summary-data-based Mendelian Randomization with brain eQTL data, phenome-wide genetic correlation, and genetic causal proportion analyses. Results Multi-ancestry and European ancestry admixture GWAS meta-analyses identified 12 risk loci at p&lt;5×10 −8 . These loci were mostly intergenic and implicated DRD2, SLC6A9, FURIN, NLGN1, SOX5, PDE4B , and CACNG2 . The multi-ancestry SNP-based heritability estimate of SA was 5.7% on the liability scale (SE=0.003, p = 5.7×10 −80 ). Significant brain tissue gene expression and drug set enrichment was observed. There was shared genetic variation of SA with ADHD, smoking, and risk tolerance after conditioning SA on both major depressive disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder. Genetic causal proportion analyses implicated shared genetic risk for specific health factors. Conclusions This multi-ancestry analysis of suicide attempt identified several loci contributing to risk, and establishes significant shared genetic covariation with clinical phenotypes. These findings provide insight into genetic factors associated with suicide attempt across major ancestry admixtures, in veteran and civilian populations, and in attempt versus death.
BibTeX
@misc{docherty2022genome,
  author = {Anna R. Docherty and Niamh Mullins and Allison E. Ashley‐Koch and Xuejun Qin and Jonathan R. I. Coleman and Andrey A. Shabalin and Jooeun Kang and Balasz Murnyak and Frank R. Wendt and Mark J. Adams and Adrián I. Campos and Emily DiBlasi and Janice M. Fullerton and Henry R. Kranzler and Amanda V. Bakian and Eric T. Monson and Miguel E. Rentería and Consuelo Walss‐Bass and Ole A. Andreassen and Cynthia M. Bulik and Howard J. Edenberg and Ronald C. Kessler and J. John Mann and John I. Nürnberger and Giorgio Pistis and Fabian Streit and Robert J. Ursano and Renato Polimonti and Michelle F. Dennis and Melanie E. Garrett and Lauren P. Hair and Philip D. Harvey and Elizabeth R. Hauser and Michael A. Hauser and Jennifer E. Huffman and Daniel Jacobson and Jennifer H. Lindquist and Ravi Madduri and Benjamin H. McMahon and David W. Oslin and Jodie Trafton and Swapnil Awasthi and Andrew W. Bergen and Wade H. Berrettini and Martin Bohus and Harry Brandt and Xiao Chang and Hsi‐Chung Chen and Wei J. Chen and Erik D. Christensen and Steven Crawford and Scott J. Crow and Philibert Duriez and Alexis C. Edwards and Fernando Fernández‐Aranda and Manfred M. Fichter and Hanga Galfalvy and Steven Gallinger and Michael J. Gandal and Philip Gorwood and Yiran Guo and Jonathan D. Hafferty and Håkon Håkonarson and Katherine A. Halmi and Akitoyo Hishimoto and Sonia Jain and Stéphane Jamain and Susana Jiménez‐Múrcia and Craig Johnson and Allan S. Kaplan and Walter H. Kaye and Pamela K. Keel and James L. Kennedy and Minsoo Kim and Kelly L. Klump and Daniel Levey and Dong Li and Shih‐Cheng Liao and Klaus Lieb and Lisa Lilenfeld and Adriana Lori and Pierre J. Magistretti and Christian R. Marshall and James E. Mitchell and R Myers and Satoshi Okazaki and Ikuo Otsuka and Dalila Pinto and Abigail Powers and Nicolás Ramoz and Stephan Ripke and Stefan Roepke and Vsevolod Rozanov and Stephen W. Scherer and Christian Schmahl and Marcus Sokolowski and Anna Starnawska and Michael Strober and Mei‐Hsin Su and Laura M. Thornton},
  title = {{Genome-wide association study meta-analysis of suicide attempt identifies twelve genome-wide significant loci and implicates genetic risks for specific health factors}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.07.03.22277199},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure