Genome-wide association analysis provides molecular insights into natural variation in watermelon seed size

Chengsheng Gong, Shengjie Zhao, Dongdong Yang, Xuqiang Lü, Muhammad Anees, Nan He, Hongju Zhu, Yong Zhao, Wenge LiuHorticulture 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses genome-wide association analysis (GWAS) to identify key genetic regions and candidate genes associated with watermelon seed size variation. The findings reveal significant correlations between different seed traits and highlight the role of domestication in seed enlargement, providing valuable molecular markers for breeding efforts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Watermelon seed size is a crucial trait for both consumers and breeders, with different types of watermelons selected for either seed consumption (larger seeds) or flesh consumption (smaller seeds). Despite its importance, the genetic mechanisms underlying the natural variation in watermelon seed size remain poorly understood. This lack of knowledge hinders targeted breeding for desired seed characteristics. This paper aims to bridge this gap by dissecting the genetic basis of seed size variation in a diverse collection of watermelon accessions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Phenotypic Characterization: Five seed size traits (100-seed weight, seed hilum length, seed length, seed width, and seed thickness) were meticulously measured across 197 watermelon accessions over two years. Statistical analyses, including descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, and coefficient of variation, were used to understand the natural variation and relationships between these traits.
  • Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS): High-quality SNP data from the 197 accessions were analyzed using two association algorithms, EMMAX and Fast-LMM. This allowed for the identification of significant single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) loci associated with seed size traits. QQ and Manhattan plots were used to visualize the results and control for false positives.
  • Candidate Gene Prediction: Regions of the genome (100 kb upstream and downstream) surrounding significant SNPs were investigated for potential candidate genes involved in seed size regulation.
  • Quantitative Real-Time PCR (qRT-PCR): The expression levels of selected candidate genes were analyzed in watermelon seeds from different accessions to validate their potential roles in seed size determination.
  • Abscisic Acid (ABA) Content Measurement: ABA levels were determined in watermelon seeds to explore the potential link between ABA metabolism and seed size.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 197 watermelon accessions. These accessions were sourced from a national genebank and represented diverse geographical origins (North America, Africa, Europe, and Asia) and species classifications (CC, CA, CM, CL_ES, and CL). SNP data was obtained from a combination of previously published resequencing data (163 accessions) and newly generated data for the remaining accessions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seed Size is Highly Correlated: The five measured seed traits are strongly interconnected, suggesting that they are largely governed by a common set of genetic factors.
  • Domestication Drives Seed Enlargement: The study provides evidence that seed enlargement has been a significant evolutionary feature during watermelon domestication, particularly in species selected for seed consumption.
  • Species-Specific Differences: Distinct differences in seed size were observed among different watermelon species, with Citrullus mucosospermus (CM) and Citrullus lanatus edible-seeded (CL_ES) types exhibiting significantly larger seeds, aligning with their use for seed consumption.
  • Key Genetic Loci Identified: The GWAS successfully pinpointed eleven significant SNP loci, with four on chromosome 5 showing particularly strong associations with multiple seed size traits. These SNPs represent promising molecular markers for future breeding.
  • ABA Metabolism as a Regulator: Two candidate genes, Cla97C05G104360 and Cla97C05G104380, were identified as potentially playing a crucial role in regulating watermelon seed size through their involvement in abscisic acid (ABA) metabolism. Higher ABA content was correlated with larger seeds.

Key Results

  • Significant SNPs: Eleven non-repeating significant SNPs were identified through GWAS, with four on chromosome 5 (S5:32250307, S5:32250454, S5:32256177, and S5:32260870) being strongly associated with 100-seed weight, seed length, and seed width.
  • Candidate Genes: Five candidate genes were identified in the vicinity of the significant SNPs. qRT-PCR analysis revealed that Cla97C05G104360 and Cla97C05G104380 showed differential expression patterns correlated with seed size and ABA content.
  • Phenotypic Variation: 100-seed weight exhibited the highest variability among the measured traits (CV > 53%).
  • Species Seed Size: CL_ES had the largest average 100-seed weight (15.28 g), while CC had the smallest (3.52 g).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that seed size is a complex quantitative trait and that further experimental validation is necessary. Future work should focus on:

  • Functional Validation: Conducting more experiments to verify the functions of the identified candidate genes.
  • Population Development: Constructing isolated population validation experiments to confirm the key roles of these genes in watermelon seed size regulation.
  • Retrograde Validation: Further exploring the mechanisms by which these genes regulate ABA content and, consequently, seed size.
  • Marker-Assisted Breeding: Utilizing the identified SNP markers for efficient marker-assisted breeding programs to develop watermelon cultivars with desired seed sizes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Seed-consumption watermelon tend to have larger-sized seeds, while flesh-consumed watermelon often require relatively smaller seed. Therefore, the seed size of watermelon has received extensive attention from consumers and breeders. However, the study on the natural variation and genetic mechanism of watermelon seed size is not clear enough. In the present study, 100 seed weight, seed hilum length, seed length, seed width, and seed thickness in 197 watermelon accessions were examined. Furthermore, association analysis was conducted between seed size traits and high-quality SNP data. The results revealed that there was a strong correlation between the five seed traits. And seed enlargement was an important feature during watermelon seed size domestication. Meanwhile, the seed consumption biological species C. mucosospermu and C. lanatus edible seed watermelon had a significantly bigger seed size than other species's. Eleven non-repeating significant SNPs above the threshold line were obtained by GWAS analysis. Four of them on chromosome 5 were considered to be closely associated with seed size traits, i.e. S5: 32250307, S5: 32250454, S5: 32256177, S5: 32260870, which could be used as potential molecular markers for the breeding of watermelon cultivars with target seed size. In addition, combined with gene annotation information and previous reports, five genes near the four significant SNPs may regulate seed size. And qRT-PCR analysis showed that two genes Cla97C05G104360 and Cla97C05G104380, which may be involved in abscisic acid metabolism, may play an important role in regulating the seed size of watermelon. Our findings provide molecular insights into natural variation in watermelon seed size, and gives valuable information of molecular marker-assisted breeding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2022genome,
  author = {Chengsheng Gong and Shengjie Zhao and Dongdong Yang and Xuqiang Lü and Muhammad Anees and Nan He and Hongju Zhu and Yong Zhao and Wenge Liu},
  title = {{Genome-wide association analysis provides molecular insights into natural variation in watermelon seed size}},
  booktitle = {Horticulture},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1093/hr/uhab074},
}
Figure