Genome-Wide Analyses of Exonic Copy Number Variants in a Family-Based Study Point to Novel Autism Susceptibility Genes

Maja Bućan, Brett S. Abrahams, Kai Wang, Joseph Glessner, Edward I. Herman, Lisa I. Sonnenblick, Ana I. Alvarez Retuerto, Marcin Imieliński, Dexter Hadley, Jonathan P. Bradfield, Cecilia Kim, Nicole B. Gidaya, Ingrid Lindquist, Ted Hutman, Marian Sigman, Vlad Kustanovich, Clara Lajonchere, Andrew Singleton, Junhyong Kim, Thomas H. Wassink, William M. McMahon, Thomas Owley, John A. Sweeney, Hilary Coon, John I. Nürnberger, Mingyao Li, Rita M. Cantor, Nancy J. Minshew, James S. Sutcliffe, Edwin H. Cook, Géraldine Dawson, Joseph D. Buxbaum, Struan F.a. Grant, Gerard D. Schellenberg, Daniel H. Geschwind, Håkon HåkonarsonPLoS 2009 · DOI

Abstract

The genetics underlying autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) is complex and remains poorly understood. While structural variation plays a role in a subset of cases, previous research often lacked the resolution to identify individual genes within large chromosomal regions. To address this, we performed high-density genotyping in 912 multiplex families from the Autism Genetics Resource Exchange (AGRE) and compared them to 1,488 healthy controls. By prioritizing exonic deletions (eDels), exonic duplications (eDups), and whole gene duplications (gDups), we identified over 150 loci with rare variants specific to cases. Twenty-seven of these were confirmed in an independent replication cohort of 859 cases and 1,051 controls. Our findings highlight known loci (e.g., NRXN1, 15q11-q13) and reveal novel candidates like BZRAP1 and MDGA2. The prevalence of unique rare variants underscores the genetic heterogeneity of ASD and the necessity for large-scale studies.

Introduction

Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is characterized by significant genetic complexity. Although twin studies indicate a high degree of heritability, identifying the specific genetic drivers has been a major challenge. Early genomic studies identified large chromosomal regions associated with ASD, but these "regions of interest" often encompass dozens of genes, making it difficult to pinpoint the exact causal variants.

This study seeks to bridge the resolution gap by focusing on exonic Copy Number Variants (CNVs)—small deletions or duplications that directly affect the protein-coding regions of the genome. By shifting the focus from large-scale chromosomal abnormalities to specific genic events, the researchers aimed to identify individual susceptibility genes and clarify the biological pathways involved in ASD etiology.

Methods

The study utilized a multi-stage discovery and replication framework to identify high-confidence ASD risk genes.

Genotyping and CNV Detection

The discovery cohort was analyzed using Illumina HumanHap550 arrays, providing over 560,000 markers across the genome. Structural variations were detected using the PennCNV algorithm, which integrates signal intensity (Log R Ratio) and allelic intensity ratios (B Allele Frequency) to ensure robust detection.

Prioritization Strategy

The researchers filtered for three specific types of "genic" events likely to have functional consequences:

  1. eDels: Deletions affecting one or more exons.
  2. eDups: Internal duplications within a gene, often leading to frameshifts.
  3. gDups: Duplications of the entire gene, potentially leading to increased protein dosage.

Validation and Cohorts

Findings were validated using TaqMan qPCR for selected de novo variants. The study involved three primary datasets:

  • Discovery: 912 multiplex families from the Autism Genetic Resource Exchange (AGRE).
  • Controls: 1,488 healthy individuals (CHOP and NINDS cohorts).
  • Replication: An independent Autism Case-Control (ACC) cohort of 859 cases and 1,051 controls.

Results

The analysis revealed a landscape of extreme genetic heterogeneity, characterized by a "long tail" of rare variants.

Novel Susceptibility Genes

Two primary novel candidates emerged with significant statistical support:

  • BZRAP1: An adaptor molecule involved in synaptic transmission. Exonic variants were found in 12 unrelated cases but zero controls ($p = 2.3 \times 10^{-5}$).
  • MDGA2: A gene involved in cell adhesion. Variants were found to be case-specific ($p = 1.3 \times 10^{-4}$). Interestingly, MDGA2 shares high structural similarity with Contactin 4 (CNTN4), a known ASD-linked gene, suggesting a potential shared mechanism of molecular mimicry.

Replication and Known Loci

Of the 150+ initial candidate loci, 27 were successfully confirmed in the independent replication cohort. The study also successfully recovered established ASD-associated regions, including deletions in NRXN1 and duplications in the 15q11–q13 region. Permutation testing (10,000 trials) confirmed that the observed number of case-specific loci was significantly higher than expected by chance ($p < 0.0001$).

Discussion

The findings support a model of ASD driven by numerous rare genetic events rather than a few common mutations. Many of the identified genes converge on pathways related to synaptic function and neuronal cell adhesion, reinforcing the "synaptopathy" hypothesis of autism.

Furthermore, the presence of risk variants in some unaffected family members supports a "multi-locus" or "threshold" model. In this view, a single rare variant might contribute to a "broader autism phenotype" (subclinical traits), but a clinical diagnosis may require multiple genetic "hits."

Limitations and Future Directions

While this study provides high-resolution mapping of ASD risk genes, the rarity of these variants makes achieving formal statistical significance for every individual gene difficult, even with large cohorts. Additionally, identifying a genetic disruption does not immediately reveal the underlying biological mechanism. Future research should focus on the functional characterization of BZRAP1 and MDGA2 to understand how these disruptions impact neural development and connectivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The genetics underlying the autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) is complex and remains poorly understood. Previous work has demonstrated an important role for structural variation in a subset of cases, but has lacked the resolution necessary to move beyond detection of large regions of potential interest to identification of individual genes. To pinpoint genes likely to contribute to ASD etiology, we performed high density genotyping in 912 multiplex families from the Autism Genetics Resource Exchange (AGRE) collection and contrasted results to those obtained for 1,488 healthy controls. Through prioritization of exonic deletions (eDels), exonic duplications (eDups), and whole gene duplication events (gDups), we identified more than 150 loci harboring rare variants in multiple unrelated probands, but no controls. Importantly, 27 of these were confirmed on examination of an independent replication cohort comprised of 859 cases and an additional 1,051 controls. Rare variants at known loci, including exonic deletions at NRXN1 and whole gene duplications encompassing UBE3A and several other genes in the 15q11-q13 region, were observed in the course of these analyses. Strong support was likewise observed for previously unreported genes such as BZRAP1, an adaptor molecule known to regulate synaptic transmission, with eDels or eDups observed in twelve unrelated cases but no controls (p = 2.3x10(-5)). Less is known about MDGA2, likewise observed to be case-specific (p = 1.3x10(-4)). But, it is notable that the encoded protein shows an unexpectedly high similarity to Contactin 4 (BLAST E-value = 3x10(-39)), which has also been linked to disease. That hundreds of distinct rare variants were each seen only once further highlights complexity in the ASDs and points to the continued need for larger cohorts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bucan2009genome,
  author = {Maja Bućan and Brett S. Abrahams and Kai Wang and Joseph Glessner and Edward I. Herman and Lisa I. Sonnenblick and Ana I. Alvarez Retuerto and Marcin Imieliński and Dexter Hadley and Jonathan P. Bradfield and Cecilia Kim and Nicole B. Gidaya and Ingrid Lindquist and Ted Hutman and Marian Sigman and Vlad Kustanovich and Clara Lajonchere and Andrew Singleton and Junhyong Kim and Thomas H. Wassink and William M. McMahon and Thomas Owley and John A. Sweeney and Hilary Coon and John I. Nürnberger and Mingyao Li and Rita M. Cantor and Nancy J. Minshew and James S. Sutcliffe and Edwin H. Cook and Géraldine Dawson and Joseph D. Buxbaum and Struan F.A. Grant and Gerard D. Schellenberg and Daniel H. Geschwind and Håkon Håkonarson},
  title = {{Genome-Wide Analyses of Exonic Copy Number Variants in a Family-Based Study Point to Novel Autism Susceptibility Genes}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pgen.1000536},
}
Figure