Genetics of the peloponnesean populations and the theory of extinction of the medieval peloponnesean Greeks

George Stamatoyannopoulos, Aritra Bose, Athanasios Teodosiadis, Fotis Tsetsos, Anna Plantinga, Nikoletta Psatha, Nikos Zogas, Evangelia Yannaki, Pierre Zalloua, Kenneth K. Kídd, Brian L. Browning, J Stamatoyannopoulos, Peristera Paschou, Petros DrineasEuropean 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The Peloponnese has long been a subject of controversy regarding the ancestry of its population. In the 19th century, historian Jacob Philipp Fallmerayer proposed that medieval Peloponnesians were totally extinguished by Slavic and Avar invaders in the 6th century CE. This study uses 2.5 million single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) to investigate the genetic structure of 241 individuals from across the peninsula. Our findings reject the theory of total replacement, showing that Slavic ancestry in the region ranges from only 0.2% to 14.4%. Instead, Peloponnesians exhibit significant genetic continuity with Southern European populations, particularly Sicilians and Italians.

The Fallmerayer Controversy

For over 170 years, scholars have debated the "extinction theory" proposed by Jacob Philipp Fallmerayer. He argued that the "Hellenic" race was wiped out during medieval invasions, leaving modern Peloponnesians as essentially Hellenized Slavs. Historically, this debate relied on ambiguous medieval texts. This research moves the discussion into the realm of population genetics to quantify exactly how much Slavic versus Mediterranean ancestry exists in the modern population.

Methods and Datasets

The research team genotyped 241 individuals from all districts of the Peloponnese, focusing on rural populations to minimize the noise of recent migrations. This included culturally distinct subgroups like the Maniots (from the Tayetos mountains) and Tsakones (speakers of a unique Doric-derived dialect).

Geographic distribution of sampling locations across the Peloponnese districts.

Analyses included:

  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): To visualize population clusters.
  • ADMIXTURE: To estimate ancestral components.
  • Identity by Descent (IBD): To identify shared DNA segments indicating common ancestry.
  • Novel Quantitative ADMIXTURE Analysis: A new method using vector space calculus and the Frobenius norm to precisely project target populations onto reference groups (Slavs vs. Italians) to calculate shared ancestry percentages.

Key Results: Debunking the Extinction Theory

The genomic data reveals a clear genetic gap between Peloponnesians and the Slavic homeland. While Slavic migration did occur, it resulted in a "dilution" of the local gene pool rather than a total replacement.

ADMIXTURE plots (K=2 to K=8) illustrating the ancestral components of various Peloponnesian subpopulations.

Major Findings:

  • Low Slavic Ancestry: Quantified at 0.2% to 14.4% across different subpopulations—far too low to support a total population replacement.
  • Mediterranean Continuity: Peloponnesians share 85% to 96% of their ancestry with Italians and Sicilians, suggesting a shared Mediterranean genetic substrate that predates medieval migrations.
  • The Maniot Paradox: Fallmerayer specifically claimed the Maniots were of Slavic origin. However, genetic data shows they have the lowest Slavic ancestry (~1%), likely due to their historical isolation in rugged terrain.
  • Substructure and Isolation: The Peloponnese is not a genetic monolith. Groups like the Tsakones and Maniots are distinct outliers due to "isolation by distance," which preserved their unique genetic and linguistic heritage.

Conclusion

This study definitively rejects the theory of extinction of medieval Peloponnesians. While the current findings provide a powerful window into the past, future work using Ancient DNA (aDNA) from Bronze Age Mycenaeans and Classical Greeks would provide a direct chronological map of gene flow to further refine these historical insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

Peloponnese has been one of the cradles of the Classical European civilization and an important contributor to the ancient European history. It has also been the subject of a controversy about the ancestry of its population. In a theory hotly debated by scholars for over 170 years, the German historian Jacob Philipp Fallmerayer proposed that the medieval Peloponneseans were totally extinguished by Slavic and Avar invaders and replaced by Slavic settlers during the 6th century CE. Here we use 2.5 million single-nucleotide polymorphisms to investigate the genetic structure of Peloponnesean populations in a sample of 241 individuals originating from all districts of the peninsula and to examine predictions of the theory of replacement of the medieval Peloponneseans by Slavs. We find considerable heterogeneity of Peloponnesean populations exemplified by genetically distinct subpopulations and by gene flow gradients within Peloponnese. By principal component analysis (PCA) and ADMIXTURE analysis the Peloponneseans are clearly distinguishable from the populations of the Slavic homeland and are very similar to Sicilians and Italians. Using a novel method of quantitative analysis of ADMIXTURE output we find that the Slavic ancestry of Peloponnesean subpopulations ranges from 0.2 to 14.4%. Subpopulations considered by Fallmerayer to be Slavic tribes or to have Near Eastern origin, have no significant ancestry of either. This study rejects the theory of extinction of medieval Peloponneseans and illustrates how genetics can clarify important aspects of the history of a human population.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{stamatoyannopoulos2017genetics,
  author = {George Stamatoyannopoulos and Aritra Bose and Athanasios Teodosiadis and Fotis Tsetsos and Anna Plantinga and Nikoletta Psatha and Nikos Zogas and Evangelia Yannaki and Pierre Zalloua and Kenneth K. Kídd and Brian L. Browning and J Stamatoyannopoulos and Peristera Paschou and Petros Drineas},
  title = {{Genetics of the peloponnesean populations and the theory of extinction of the medieval peloponnesean Greeks}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/ejhg.2017.18},
}
Figure