Genetically encoded calcium indicators for multi-color neural activity imaging and combination with optogenetics

Jasper Akerboom, Nicole Carreras Calderón, Lin Tian, Sebastian Wabnig, Matthias Prigge, Johan Tolö, Andrew Gordus, Michael B. Orger, Kristen E. Severi, J. J. Macklin, Ronak Patel, Stefan R. Pulver, Trevor J. Wardill, Elisabeth Fischer, Christina Schüler, Tsai‐Wen Chen, Karen S. Sarkisyan, Jonathan S. Marvin, Cornelia I. Bargmann, Douglas S. Kim, Sebastian Kügler, Leon Lagnado, Peter Hegemann, Alexander Gottschalk, Eric R. Schreiter, Loren L. LoogerFrontiers in Molecular Neuroscience 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Genetically encoded calcium indicators (GECIs) are powerful tools for systems neuroscience. This paper describes the development of "RCaMPs," a family of red-shifted, single-wavelength GECIs engineered from the circular permutation of the thermostable red fluorescent protein mRuby. Through high-resolution crystallography and biophysical characterization, we demonstrate that RCaMPs overcome significant limitations of existing sensors, such as spectral crosstalk and photoactivation artifacts. We validated RCaMP performance across multiple model organisms, including Caenorhabditis elegans, Drosophila, and zebrafish. Furthermore, we introduce blue (BCaMP), cyan (CyCaMP), and yellow (YCaMP) variants, providing a comprehensive chromatic toolkit for multi-color functional imaging and integrated optogenetics.

Introduction

For over a decade, the green GCaMP series has been the "gold standard" for imaging neural activity. However, the reliance on a single spectral channel creates two major bottlenecks. First, it limits multiplexing; researchers cannot easily distinguish between distinct cell populations (e.g., neurons vs. astrocytes) or subcellular compartments (e.g., mitochondria vs. cytoplasm) when all signals are green. Second, green GECIs suffer from significant optogenetic crosstalk. Common actuators like Channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) are activated by blue light, which also excites green GECIs, leading to optical interference during simultaneous stimulation and imaging.

While red sensors like R-GECO1 were developed to address these issues, they are prone to "photoactivation"—a phenomenon where blue light induces reversible chemical changes in the chromophore, creating false-positive calcium signals. This study introduces RCaMPs as a robust alternative for multi-color and all-optical experiments.

Methods and Structural Engineering

The authors employed structure-guided rational design and directed evolution to create RCaMPs from mRuby, a thermostable red fluorescent protein. By performing "circular permutation," the protein's sequence was rearranged to place the new termini near the chromophore. A calcium-binding domain (Calmodulin and M13) was then fused to these termini, allowing calcium-induced conformational changes to modulate the sensor's brightness.

High-resolution crystal structures were solved for mRuby, RCaMP, and R-GECO1. These structures provided critical insights into the chromophore environments and the engineered protein domain interfaces. Screening was conducted in E. coli for brightness and maturation, followed by validation in cultured mammalian cells and intact model organisms.

Key Insights: The Photoactivation Artifact and Imine Hydrolysis

A pivotal discovery was the identification of the photoactivation artifact in R-GECO1. Under blue light, R-GECO1 produces signals that mimic calcium transients even in the absence of essential cofactors, making it incompatible with ChR2-based optogenetics. RCaMP, due to its unique chromophore environment and more "closed" beta-barrel structure, is immune to this effect.

Additionally, the researchers discovered that red GECIs undergo imine hydrolysis during maturation. This process leads to specific backbone cleavage, effectively turning the sensor into a "split protein" where the fragments remain associated and functional.

SDS-PAGE analysis demonstrating imine hydrolysis and protein cleavage across various red GECI variants.

Results: A Full Chromatic Palette

RCaMP1h is red-shifted by approximately 80 nm compared to GCaMP, enabling clean two-color imaging. In C. elegans, the authors successfully performed simultaneous ChR2 activation and RCaMP imaging, measuring calcium responses during muscle contractions. They also demonstrated sub-cellular resolution by imaging mitochondrial calcium (via RCaMP) and cytoplasmic calcium (via GCaMP) within a single neuron.

Beyond red sensors, the team applied the lessons learned from RCaMP and GCaMP to rationally design blue (BCaMP), cyan (CyCaMP), and yellow (YCaMP) variants. These indicators allow for even greater flexibility in multi-spectral imaging.

Biophysical characterization of chromatic GECI variants BCaMP1c, CyCaMP1a, and YCaMP1b, including absorbance, excitation/emission, and calcium affinity plots.

RCaMPs are approximately 3x brighter than R-GECO1 under 1-photon excitation and 2x brighter under 2-photon excitation. While R-GECO1 has a higher dynamic range and calcium affinity, RCaMP's photostability and lack of photoswitching make it a superior choice for many applications.

Discussion and Future Directions

RCaMP represents a significant step forward for all-optical physiology. By providing a sensor that is spectrally independent from blue-light actuators, it enables the precise study of neural circuits. However, limitations remain: RCaMPs currently have a lower dynamic range (ΔF/F) than the latest GCaMP6 variants and require longer maturation times. Future directed evolution aims to close this sensitivity gap, potentially making red GECIs the preferred choice for deep-tissue imaging due to the reduced scattering of longer-wavelength light.

Summary updated

Abstract

Genetically encoded calcium indicators (GECIs) are powerful tools for systems neuroscience. Here we describe red, single-wavelength GECIs, "RCaMPs," engineered from circular permutation of the thermostable red fluorescent protein mRuby. High-resolution crystal structures of mRuby, the red sensor RCaMP, and the recently published red GECI R-GECO1 give insight into the chromophore environments of the Ca(2+)-bound state of the sensors and the engineered protein domain interfaces of the different indicators. We characterized the biophysical properties and performance of RCaMP sensors in vitro and in vivo in Caenorhabditis elegans, Drosophila larvae, and larval zebrafish. Further, we demonstrate 2-color calcium imaging both within the same cell (registering mitochondrial and somatic [Ca(2+)]) and between two populations of cells: neurons and astrocytes. Finally, we perform integrated optogenetics experiments, wherein neural activation via channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) or a red-shifted variant, and activity imaging via RCaMP or GCaMP, are conducted simultaneously, with the ChR2/RCaMP pair providing independently addressable spectral channels. Using this paradigm, we measure calcium responses of naturalistic and ChR2-evoked muscle contractions in vivo in crawling C. elegans. We systematically compare the RCaMP sensors to R-GECO1, in terms of action potential-evoked fluorescence increases in neurons, photobleaching, and photoswitching. R-GECO1 displays higher Ca(2+) affinity and larger dynamic range than RCaMP, but exhibits significant photoactivation with blue and green light, suggesting that integrated channelrhodopsin-based optogenetics using R-GECO1 may be subject to artifact. Finally, we create and test blue, cyan, and yellow variants engineered from GCaMP by rational design. This engineered set of chromatic variants facilitates new experiments in functional imaging and optogenetics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{akerboom2013genetically,
  author = {Jasper Akerboom and Nicole Carreras Calderón and Lin Tian and Sebastian Wabnig and Matthias Prigge and Johan Tolö and Andrew Gordus and Michael B. Orger and Kristen E. Severi and J. J. Macklin and Ronak Patel and Stefan R. Pulver and Trevor J. Wardill and Elisabeth Fischer and Christina Schüler and Tsai‐Wen Chen and Karen S. Sarkisyan and Jonathan S. Marvin and Cornelia I. Bargmann and Douglas S. Kim and Sebastian Kügler and Leon Lagnado and Peter Hegemann and Alexander Gottschalk and Eric R. Schreiter and Loren L. Looger},
  title = {{Genetically encoded calcium indicators for multi-color neural activity imaging and combination with optogenetics}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Molecular Neuroscience},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3389/fnmol.2013.00002},
}
Figure