Genetic variants for head size share genes and pathways with cancer

Maria J. Knol, Raymond A. Poot, Tavia E. Evans, Claudia L. Satizábal, Aniket Mishra, Sandra Van der Auwera, Marie‐Gabrielle Duperron, Xueqiu Jian, Beng‐Choon Ho, Dianne H.k. van Dam-Nolen, Sander Lamballais, Mikołaj A. Pawlak, Cora E. Lewis, Amaia Carrión-Castillo, Theo G.m. van Erp, Céline S. Reinbold, Jean Shin, Markus Scholz, Asta K. Håberg, Anders Kämpe, Gloria Hoi‐Yee Li, Reut Avinun, Joshua Atkins, Fang‐Chi Hsu, Alyssa R. Amod, Max Lam, Ami Tsuchida, Mariël W.a. Teunissen, Alexa Beiser, Frauke Beyer, Joshua C. Bis, Daniël Bos, R. Nick Bryan, Robin Bülow, Svenja Caspers, Gwénaëlle Catheline, Charlotte A. M. Cecil, Shareefa Dalvie, Jean‐François Dartigues, Charles DeCarli, Maria Enlund-Cerullo, Judith M. Ford, Barbara Franke, Barry I. Freedman, Nele Friedrich, Melissa J. Green, Simon Haworth, Catherine Helmer, Per Hoffmann, Georg Homuth, M. Kamran Ikram, Clifford R. Jack, Neda Jahanshad, Christiane Jockwitz, Yoichiro Kamatani, Christopher Chen, Shuo Li, Keane Lim, W. T. Longstreth, Fabìo Macciardi, Outi Mäkitie, Bernard Mazoyer, Sarah E. Medland, Susumu Miyamoto, Susanne Moebus, Thomas H. Mosley, Ryan L. Muetzel, Thomas W. Mühleisen, Manabu Nagata, Soichiro Nakahara, Nicholette D. Palmer, Zdenka Pausová, Adrian Preda, Yann Quidé, William R. Reay, Gennady V. Roshchupkin, Reinhold Schmidt, Pamela J. Schreiner, Kazuya Setoh, Chin Yang Shapland, Stephen Sidney, Beaté St Pourcain, Jason L. Stein, Yasuharu Tabara, Alexander Teumer, Anne Uhlmann, Aad van der Lugt, Meike W. Vernooij, David J. Werring, B. Gwen Windham, A. Veronica Witte, Katharina Wittfeld, Qiong Yang, Kazumichi Yoshida, Han G. Brunner, Quentin Le Grand, Kang Sim, Dan J. Stein, Donald W. Bowden, Murray J. CairnsbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Human head size is determined by rapid growth in the first years of life, a developmental trajectory distinct from the rest of the body, which typically grows until early adulthood. While rare genetic syndromes have identified specific genes affecting head size, the genetic drivers of variation within the general population have remained largely unknown. To elucidate the biological pathways underlying human head growth, we performed the largest genome-wide association study (GWAS) to date (N = 79,107). We identified 67 genetic loci—50 of which are novel—and found that these loci are preferentially associated with head size and are mostly independent of height. Subsequent neuroimaging and pathway analyses revealed a strong overlap between head size variants and cancer pathways, including p53, Wnt, and ErbB signaling. Genes near lead variants, such as TP53, PTEN, and APC, were significantly enriched for genes involved in macrocephaly syndromes and high-fidelity cancer genes. These findings suggest that the genetic machinery regulating early brain and cranial growth is linked to a propensity for neoplasia later in life, independent of overall body height.

Introduction

The human head is a unique developmental marker. Unlike the long bones of the body, the cranium and the brain it houses reach near-adult dimensions within the first few years of life. This rapid proliferation is tightly regulated, yet the genetic architecture governing natural variation in head size among healthy individuals has been poorly understood. Historically, research has focused on rare syndromes like macrocephaly (abnormally large head) or microcephaly (abnormally small head). However, whether the same biological "software" driving these clinical conditions also dictates the spectrum of head sizes in the general population—and whether this growth is distinct from general body height—remained an open question.

Methods and Data

This study utilized a meta-analysis of GWAS data from the CHARGE and ENIGMA consortia, nearly doubling the sample size of previous research to a total of 79,107 individuals. The primary cohort was of European ancestry (N=75,309), with additional validation performed in smaller African and Asian samples.

To isolate the specific drivers of head growth, researchers employed several analytical layers:

  • Height-Adjusted Modeling: A secondary GWAS model was run adjusting for body height to determine if head size variants were merely markers for "general bigness."
  • Neuroimaging Mapping: Genetic variants were mapped against MRI and CT data from 22,145 individuals (including the UK Biobank) to observe effects on specific brain regions versus global brain volume.
  • Pathway Enrichment: The team used hypothesis-free screening against the KEGG pathway database and clinical databases such as OMIM (for rare syndromes) and COSMIC (for cancer genes) to identify biological overlaps.

Key Findings

Independence from Height

One of the study's primary insights is that head size is not simply a byproduct of overall stature. In height-adjusted models, the genetic correlation between head size and height effectively vanished. This confirms that head growth is governed by a specific, independent biological program.

The Cancer Connection

The most striking discovery was the massive enrichment of head-size variants in cancer-related pathways. The study identified 67 loci, with 50 being novel discoveries. Within these loci, genes such as TP53, PTEN, and APC—well-known tumor suppressors and oncogenes—were prominent.

Pathway analysis showed significant enrichment for:

  • p53 Signaling: Often called the "guardian of the genome," regulating cell cycle and apoptosis.
  • Wnt Signaling: Crucial for body patterning and cell fate specification.
  • ErbB Signaling: Involved in cell proliferation and differentiation.

Genes near the lead variants showed a 9-fold enrichment for high-fidelity cancer genes. This suggests that the same mechanisms facilitating rapid cellular proliferation during early brain development are also those that, when dysregulated, lead to uncontrolled tumor growth.

From Syndromes to General Variation

The study found that common variants in the general population were 37-fold enriched for genes involved in macrocephaly syndromes. Interestingly, this enrichment was not seen for microcephaly. This suggests that the genetic "knobs" that produce a larger head in healthy individuals are the same ones that, when severely mutated, cause pathological overgrowth. Furthermore, the same types of mutations (e.g., gain-of-function) that cause macrocephaly as germline mutations often appear as somatic mutations in various cancers.

Regional Brain Specificity

While most identified variants had widespread effects across the brain, 17 variants demonstrated regional specificity, affecting areas such as the nucleus accumbens. Polygenic scores derived from these variants were associated with skull area but did not correlate with the bone density or area of the limbs or spine, reinforcing the cranium-specific nature of these genetic drivers.

Discussion and Clinical Implications

These results indicate that the genes regulating early brain and cranial growth are fundamentally linked to a propensity for neoplasia later in life. However, the authors caution that this is an observational genetic link; a larger head size does not necessarily cause cancer, but rather suggests a shared biological vulnerability.

Future research is required to address the ancestry bias in current datasets, as the majority of participants were of European descent. Additionally, prospective studies are needed to determine if head size measurements in early life could eventually serve as a subtle clinical marker for long-term health risks or inform screening protocols for individuals with specific genetic profiles. Understanding this link between development and disease opens new avenues for exploring how the foundations of human growth influence health throughout the lifespan.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The size of the human head is determined by growth in the first years of life, while the rest of the body typically grows until early adulthood 1 . Such complex developmental processes are regulated by various genes and growth pathways 2 . Rare genetic syndromes have revealed genes that affect head size 3 , but the genetic drivers of variation in head size within the general population remain largely unknown. To elucidate biological pathways underlying the growth of the human head, we performed the largest genome-wide association study on human head size to date (N = 79,107). We identified 67 genetic loci, 50 of which are novel, and found that these loci are preferentially associated with head size and mostly independent from height. In subsequent neuroimaging analyses, the majority of genetic variants demonstrated widespread effects on the brain, whereas the effects of 17 variants could be localized to one or two specific brain regions. Through hypothesis-free approaches, we find a strong overlap of head size variants with both cancer pathways and cancer genes. Gene set analyses showed enrichment for different types of cancer and the p53, Wnt and ErbB signalling pathway. Genes overlapping or close to lead variants – such as TP53 , PTEN and APC – were enriched for genes involved in macrocephaly syndromes (up to 37-fold) and high-fidelity cancer genes (up to 9-fold), whereas this enrichment was not seen for human height variants. This indicates that genes regulating early brain and cranial growth are associated with a propensity to neoplasia later in life, irrespective of height. Our results warrant further investigations of the link between head size and cancer, as well as its clinical implications in the general population.
BibTeX
@misc{knol2020genetic,
  author = {Maria J. Knol and Raymond A. Poot and Tavia E. Evans and Claudia L. Satizábal and Aniket Mishra and Sandra Van der Auwera and Marie‐Gabrielle Duperron and Xueqiu Jian and Beng‐Choon Ho and Dianne H.K. van Dam-Nolen and Sander Lamballais and Mikołaj A. Pawlak and Cora E. Lewis and Amaia Carrión-Castillo and Theo G.M. van Erp and Céline S. Reinbold and Jean Shin and Markus Scholz and Asta K. Håberg and Anders Kämpe and Gloria Hoi‐Yee Li and Reut Avinun and Joshua Atkins and Fang‐Chi Hsu and Alyssa R. Amod and Max Lam and Ami Tsuchida and Mariël W.A. Teunissen and Alexa Beiser and Frauke Beyer and Joshua C. Bis and Daniël Bos and R. Nick Bryan and Robin Bülow and Svenja Caspers and Gwénaëlle Catheline and Charlotte A. M. Cecil and Shareefa Dalvie and Jean‐François Dartigues and Charles DeCarli and Maria Enlund-Cerullo and Judith M. Ford and Barbara Franke and Barry I. Freedman and Nele Friedrich and Melissa J. Green and Simon Haworth and Catherine Helmer and Per Hoffmann and Georg Homuth and M. Kamran Ikram and Clifford R. Jack and Neda Jahanshad and Christiane Jockwitz and Yoichiro Kamatani and Christopher Chen and Shuo Li and Keane Lim and W. T. Longstreth and Fabìo Macciardi and Outi Mäkitie and Bernard Mazoyer and Sarah E. Medland and Susumu Miyamoto and Susanne Moebus and Thomas H. Mosley and Ryan L. Muetzel and Thomas W. Mühleisen and Manabu Nagata and Soichiro Nakahara and Nicholette D. Palmer and Zdenka Pausová and Adrian Preda and Yann Quidé and William R. Reay and Gennady V. Roshchupkin and Reinhold Schmidt and Pamela J. Schreiner and Kazuya Setoh and Chin Yang Shapland and Stephen Sidney and Beaté St Pourcain and Jason L. Stein and Yasuharu Tabara and Alexander Teumer and Anne Uhlmann and Aad van der Lugt and Meike W. Vernooij and David J. Werring and B. Gwen Windham and A. Veronica Witte and Katharina Wittfeld and Qiong Yang and Kazumichi Yoshida and Han G. Brunner and Quentin Le Grand and Kang Sim and Dan J. Stein and Donald W. Bowden and Murray J. Cairns},
  title = {{Genetic variants for head size share genes and pathways with cancer}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.07.15.191114},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure