Genetic Testing for Cancer Risk and Perceived Importance of Genetic Information Among US Population by Race and Ethnicity: a Cross-sectional Study

Young‐Rock Hong, Sandhya Yadav, Ruixuan Wang, Susan T. Vadaparampil, Jiang Bian, Thomas J. George, Dejana BraithwaiteJournal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities 2023 · DOI

Introduction

Precision oncology holds the promise of personalized care, yet its benefits are not distributed equally across the population. A significant "perception-uptake paradox" exists within the US: while non-Hispanic Black and Hispanic individuals often value genetic information for cancer care more highly than non-Hispanic Whites, they face substantial barriers in awareness and access to actual genetic testing. This study investigates these disparities to understand whether the bottleneck in precision medicine is a lack of interest or systemic hurdles in information and access.

Methods

This cross-sectional study utilized data from the 2020 Health Information National Trends Survey (HINTS-5 Cycle 4), a nationally representative survey by the National Cancer Institute. The sample included 3,551 respondents, weighted to represent approximately 226 million US adults. Researchers employed multivariable logistic regression models, controlling for a wide array of covariates including sociodemographics (age, sex, education, income), health insurance status, and family cancer history. A key focus was the "HINTS Genetic Testing Module," which targets clinically actionable testing for conditions like BRCA1/2 and Lynch syndrome rather than ancestry-based tests.

Results

The study revealed a profound awareness gap: only 37.8% of the US population has even heard of genetic testing for cancer risk. Furthermore, actual uptake remains remarkably low, with only 3.9% of the total population reporting they had undergone such testing.

The Awareness and Uptake Gap

Significant disparities were observed across racial and ethnic lines. Non-Hispanic Black (OR=0.47) and Hispanic (OR=0.56) respondents had significantly lower odds of being aware of genetic testing compared to non-Hispanic Whites. This lack of knowledge translates directly into lower testing rates, even when controlling for factors like insurance and income.

Sociodemographic characteristics associated with awareness and uptake of genetic testing for cancer risk.

The Perception Paradox

Despite lower awareness and uptake, minority groups expressed a higher perceived value of genetic information. Hispanic and non-Hispanic Black respondents were significantly more likely to rate genetic information as "very important" for preventing and treating cancer than their White counterparts.

Perceived importance of genetic information for cancer prevention by race and ethnicity.

Among those who viewed genetic information as "very or somewhat important" for prevention, the predicted probability of actually receiving testing was notably lower for Hispanics (2.1%) and non-Hispanic Blacks (3.2%) compared to non-Hispanic Whites (5.5%).

Discussion

The findings suggest that the barrier to equitable precision medicine is not a lack of perceived value or interest among minority populations. Instead, the "perception-uptake paradox" points toward systemic issues in information dissemination and healthcare access. While insurance status is a critical factor—uninsured individuals had an adjusted odds ratio of 0.02 for testing—disparities persisted even after adjusting for socioeconomic variables. This indicates that provider bias, medical mistrust, and limited genetic literacy may also play significant roles.

To bridge this gap, the authors advocate for culturally tailored educational interventions and further research into patient-provider communication. Ensuring that the benefits of the genomic revolution are accessible to all requires addressing these fundamental inequities in awareness and clinical integration.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{hong2023genetic,
  author = {Young‐Rock Hong and Sandhya Yadav and Ruixuan Wang and Susan T. Vadaparampil and Jiang Bian and Thomas J. George and Dejana Braithwaite},
  title = {{Genetic Testing for Cancer Risk and Perceived Importance of Genetic Information Among US Population by Race and Ethnicity: a Cross-sectional Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/s40615-023-01526-4},
}
Figure