Genetic history of the population of Crete

Petros Drineas, Fotis Tsetsos, Anna Plantinga, Iosif Lazaridis, Evangelia Yannaki, Anna Razou, Katerina Kanaki, Manolis Michalodimitrakis, Francisco Pérez‐Jiménez, Giustina De Silvestro, Maria Concetta Renda, J Stamatoyannopoulos, Kenneth K. Kídd, Brian L. Browning, Peristera Paschou, George StamatoyannopoulosAnnals 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses genetic data from Cretan populations to investigate the impact of historical invasions and settlements, revealing surprisingly small genetic contributions from Arab and Venetian occupations. Instead, it uncovers a genetic relationship with Central, Northern, and Eastern European populations, suggesting a significant, yet historically under-documented, influx of people from these regions during the medieval period.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The historical record of Crete, particularly its medieval period, is marked by numerous invasions and occupations by various groups, including Arabs and Venetians. However, contemporary historical accounts are often scarce, contradictory, or subject to biased interpretations by historians. This makes it challenging to definitively assess the demographic impact of these historical events on the Cretan population. The paper aims to bridge this gap by employing population genetics to provide an objective, data-driven perspective on the genetic legacy of these historical interactions, specifically focusing on the period between the 9th and 17th centuries CE.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining several established population genetics techniques:

  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Used to visualize genetic relationships among individuals and populations, identifying clusters and gradients in genetic variation. This is a standard method for exploring population structure.
  • ADMIXTURE Analysis: A model-based approach to infer the ancestry proportions of individuals from a predefined number of ancestral populations. This helps quantify the genetic contributions from different source populations.
  • Identity by Descent (IBD) Analysis: This method detects segments of DNA shared between individuals that are likely inherited from a common ancestor. It's particularly useful for identifying recent or more distant shared ancestry and can reveal patterns of population admixture and relatedness. The paper utilized the Refined IBD algorithm for this.
  • ChromoPainter and FineSTRUCTURE: These tools are used for haplotype-based analysis, allowing for a more detailed examination of population structure and admixture by painting chromosomes with segments from ancestral donors.
  • ALDER: A method specifically used to estimate the timing and proportion of admixture events, particularly useful for dating historical population movements.

The novelty lies not in the individual methods, but in their combined application to a historically complex and under-studied population like Crete, aiming to reconcile genetic data with historical narratives.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets:

  • Cretan Samples: Genotypes from 129 individuals from 17 rural districts of Crete, collected using Illumina 1M or 2.5M arrays. These individuals were selected to represent the rural population of Crete in the mid-to-late 19th century, based on their grandparents' origins.
  • Published Datasets: Samples from various global populations, including those from the Human Genome Diversity Project (HGDP) and the 1000 Genomes Project.
  • Newly Collected Samples: Data from Greek subpopulations, and populations from the areas of Cordoba (Andalusia), Veneto, and Sicily, collected specifically for this study.
  • IBD Analysis Datasets: Two datasets were used for IBD analyses, one with 759 individuals from Crete and Southern Europe, and another with 1,882 individuals from various European and Near Eastern populations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Minimal Arab and Venetian Genetic Footprint: Despite significant historical occupations, the genetic data shows surprisingly little evidence of substantial admixture from the Arab (9th-10th centuries CE) and Venetian (13th-17th centuries CE) periods. This challenges some historical interpretations that suggested dramatic demographic shifts.
  • East-West Gradient: A pronounced genetic gradient exists across Crete, running from east to west. This pattern aligns with historical settlement patterns, with Minoan civilization concentrated in the east and Mycenaean influence in the west.
  • Unexpected European Connections: The most striking finding is the strong genetic relationship between Cretans and populations from Central, Northern, and Eastern Europe. This suggests a significant, historically under-documented influx of people from these regions during the medieval period.
  • Reconciling Genetics and History: The study highlights how population genetics can offer an unbiased lens to investigate historical events, complementing and sometimes challenging traditional historical interpretations.

Key Results

  • Arab Occupation: PCA and ADMIXTURE analyses showed a clear separation between Cretans and Andalusian, North African, and Near Eastern populations, indicating minimal genetic contribution from the Arab occupation.
  • Venetian Occupation: PCA and ADMIXTURE analyses revealed a gradient from Cretans towards Italian populations (Veneto, Tuscany), but the genetic contribution of Venetians was found to be low.
  • IBD Sharing: IBD analysis revealed that Cretans share higher levels of IBD with Central, Eastern, and Northern European populations than with Southern European populations. Specifically, east Crete showed higher IBD with Ukraine and Poland, and west Crete also showed high IBD with Poland and Ukraine.
  • ALDER Analysis: This method estimated admixture events from Central, Northern, and Eastern European sources dating to the medieval period, with proportions ranging from 17% to 28%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size and Representation: While the study sampled from 17 districts, the overall sample size of 129 individuals for the primary analysis might limit the resolution of fine-scale population structure. The focus on rural populations also means the urban centers, which may have experienced different demographic histories, are not fully represented.
  • Model Assumptions: The ALDER analysis relies on a pulse model of admixture, which may not fully capture complex or continuous migration histories.
  • Ancient DNA: The authors acknowledge that ancient DNA studies from Crete would be invaluable for directly tracing the origins and timing of population movements, especially for understanding early migrations.
  • Sophistication of Tools: The paper suggests that further analyses using more sophisticated statistical tools and larger sample sizes, including ancient DNA, could provide deeper insights into historical controversies.
  • Interpreting IBD: While IBD analysis revealed strong connections to Northern and Eastern Europe, the exact historical events responsible (e.g., Gothic or Slavic migrations, Byzantine resettlement) remain open to interpretation and require further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The medieval history of several populations often suffers from scarcity of contemporary records resulting in contradictory and sometimes biased interpretations by historians. This is the situation with the population of the island of Crete, which remained relatively undisturbed until the Middle Ages when multiple wars, invasions, and occupations by foreigners took place. Historians have considered the effects of the occupation of Crete by the Arabs (in the 9th and 10th centuries C.E.) and the Venetians (in the 13th to the 17th centuries C.E.) to the local population. To obtain insights on such effects from a genetic perspective, we studied representative samples from 17 Cretan districts using the Illumina 1 million or 2.5 million arrays and compared the Cretans to the populations of origin of the medieval conquerors and settlers. Highlights of our findings include (1) small genetic contributions from the Arab occupation to the extant Cretan population, (2) low genetic contribution of the Venetians to the extant Cretan population, and (3) evidence of a genetic relationship among the Cretans and Central, Northern, and Eastern Europeans, which could be explained by the settlement in the island of northern origin tribes during the medieval period. Our results show how the interaction between genetics and the historical record can help shed light on the historical record.
BibTeX
@article{drineas2019genetic,
  author = {Petros Drineas and Fotis Tsetsos and Anna Plantinga and Iosif Lazaridis and Evangelia Yannaki and Anna Razou and Katerina Kanaki and Manolis Michalodimitrakis and Francisco Pérez‐Jiménez and Giustina De Silvestro and Maria Concetta Renda and J Stamatoyannopoulos and Kenneth K. Kídd and Brian L. Browning and Peristera Paschou and George Stamatoyannopoulos},
  title = {{Genetic history of the population of Crete}},
  journal = {Annals},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1111/ahg.12328},
}
Figure