Genetic design automation for autonomous formation of multicellular shapes from a single cell progenitor

Evan Appleton, Noushin Mehdipour, Tristan Daifuku, Demarcus Briers, Iman Haghighi, Michaël Moret, George Chao, Timothy M. Wannier, Anush Chiappino-Pepe, Jeremy Huang, Călin Belta, George M. ChurchbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces CellArchitect, a computer-aided design (CAD) software that automates the creation of genetic circuits to control the self-assembly of single cells into complex 3D multicellular shapes. This work bridges the gap between controlling cell identity and controlling multicellular morphology, offering a purely genetic approach to shape formation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The formation of complex multicellular organisms from a single cell is a fundamental process in biology. While significant progress has been made in differentiating cells into various types (e.g., using induced pluripotent stem cells or transcription factors), controlling the morphology of these growing cell masses has remained a major challenge. Existing methods like 3D bioprinting or artificial scaffolds are often labor-intensive, lack fine-grained genetic control, and struggle with repeatability. This paper tackles the problem of achieving autonomous, genetically programmed formation of arbitrary multicellular shapes starting from a single cell, without relying on external scaffolds or complex media.

Methods

The authors developed a computational framework, CellArchitect, that breaks down the problem into several key sub-problems:

  • Meshing: Input shapes (from STL files) are decomposed into discrete geometric blocks (tetrahedrons and cubes) that represent potential cellular units.
  • Connection Optimization: Algorithms like Maximum Leaf Spanning Tree (MLST) and Minimum Spanning Tree (MST) are used to minimize the number of orthogonal cell-surface binding proteins required to hold the meshed shape together, aiming for efficient and robust connections.
  • Developmental Tree Creation: A 'developmental tree' is generated, mapping the final cellular blocks back to a single progenitor cell. This tree outlines the sequence of cell divisions (standard, asymmetrical, or arrest) and the expression of specific proteins (surface binders, fluorescent proteins) needed at each step.
  • Genetic Circuit Design: Recombinase-based genetic circuits are designed to execute the developmental program. This involves genetic counters to track cell divisions and genetic registers to control the expression of specific genes (like surface binders) at precise developmental stages. They employ cell-cycle dependent promoters, degradation tags, and recombinase components for precise control.
  • State Machine Simulation: A finite state machine model simulates the behavior of the genetic circuits within individual cells, accounting for probabilities of recombination events, cell division, and potential off-target effects. This allows for predicting the dynamics of cell populations.
  • 4D Simulation: A physics-based simulation models multicellular self-assembly in 4D space (3D space + time). It incorporates cell division, Brownian motion, and physical forces (repulsion, attraction based on binding proteins) to mimic cell behavior in a simulated environment.
  • Verification: A graph-matching algorithm, specifically using Laplacian matrix eigenvalues, is employed to quantitatively compare the desired shape (represented as a graph) with the simulated outcomes, providing a similarity score to assess the success of a genetic circuit.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors use simulated data generated by their own framework and reference existing biological data for model parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Morphology and Genetics: The core innovation is the integration of genetic circuit design with computational modeling to achieve morphological control of multicellular structures, moving beyond just controlling cell identity.
  • Decomposition for Complexity: Breaking down the complex problem of shape formation into manageable sub-problems (meshing, developmental trees, circuit design, simulation, verification) is crucial for tackling such intricate biological engineering challenges.
  • Genetic Control of Self-Assembly: The paper demonstrates that genetic circuits can be designed to autonomously guide single cells to self-assemble into predefined 3D shapes, mimicking natural developmental processes.
  • Binary Counters for Scalability: The use of binary genetic counters is highlighted as a more scalable solution for tracking cell divisions compared to linear counters, especially for complex organisms with vast numbers of cells.
  • Quantitative Verification: Developing a quantitative metric (graph similarity score) for evaluating the success of simulated shape formation is essential for iterating and improving genetic designs.

Key Results

The paper presents a computational framework (CellArchitect) that can design genetic circuits for autonomous multicellular shape formation. As a proof of principle, they demonstrate the design and simulation of circuits for simple shapes (e.g., 2-tet and 3-tet structures). The verification algorithm shows promising results in comparing simulated outcomes to desired shapes, with scores indicating varying degrees of success. The simulation framework successfully models cell division, Brownian motion, and the effects of genetic circuits on cell behavior.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability of State Machines and Simulations: The authors acknowledge that the state machine and simulation frameworks become computationally expensive with increasingly complex genetic circuits and larger cell populations due to the exponential growth of possible states and interactions. This needs to be addressed for larger-scale applications.
  • Component Imperfection: The current models assume perfect functionality of genetic components. Future work should incorporate more realistic probabilities of off-target events and component failures.
  • Simplifications in Simulation: The simulation models K562 cells as incompressible spheres and uses simplified physical models. Future versions could incorporate more complex cell behaviors and interactions.
  • Broader Applications: The developmental tree concept and the genetic counter constructs could be extended beyond shape formation to applications like controlling cell differentiation or signaling in heterogeneous cell populations.
  • Experimental Validation: While the framework is designed for synthesis and testing, the paper focuses on the computational design and simulation aspects. Future work will involve experimental validation of the designed genetic circuits.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract Multi-cellular organisms originate from a single cell, ultimately giving rise to mature organisms of heterogeneous cell type composition in complex structures. Recent work in the areas of stem cell biology and tissue engineering have laid major groundwork in the ability to convert certain types of cells into other types, but there has been limited progress in the ability to control the morphology of cellular masses as they grow. Contemporary approaches to this problem have included the use of artificial scaffolds, 3D bioprinting, and complex media formulations, however, there are no existing approaches to controlling this process purely through genetics and from a single-cell starting point. Here we describe a computer-aided design approach for designing recombinase-based genetic circuits for controlling the formation of multi-cellular masses into arbitrary shapes in human cells.
BibTeX
@misc{appleton2019genetic,
  author = {Evan Appleton and Noushin Mehdipour and Tristan Daifuku and Demarcus Briers and Iman Haghighi and Michaël Moret and George Chao and Timothy M. Wannier and Anush Chiappino-Pepe and Jeremy Huang and Călin Belta and George M. Church},
  title = {{Genetic design automation for autonomous formation of multicellular shapes from a single cell progenitor}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/807107},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure