Genetic basis of negative heterosis for growth traits in chickens revealed by genome-wide gene expression pattern analysis

Chunning Mai, Chaoliang Wen, Zhiyuan Xu, Guiyun Xu, Sirui Chen, Jiangxia Zheng, Congjiao Sun, Ning YangJournal of Animal Science and Biotechnology/Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

While heterosis, or hybrid vigor, is a cornerstone of agricultural success, crossing specialized breeds can sometimes result in offspring that perform worse than their parents—a phenomenon known as negative heterosis. This study investigates the molecular mechanisms behind this "hybrid slump" in chickens. By crossing meat-type Cornish (broilers) with egg-type Rhode Island White (layers), researchers identified that nonadditive gene expression disrupts oxidative phosphorylation. This leads to a metabolic paradox in muscle tissues—low ATP levels despite high ATPase activity—resulting in significantly reduced growth and muscle mass in hybrid offspring. These findings reveal that nonadditive genes and their related oxidative phosphorylation are major genetic and molecular factors in negative heterosis, offering critical insights for future poultry breeding strategies.

Introduction

Heterosis is the tendency of a crossbred individual to show qualities superior to those of both parents. While positive heterosis is extensively utilized in breeding, negative heterosis is frequently observed in the poultry industry, particularly when crossing meat-type "broilers" with egg-type "layers." Despite its economic impact, the molecular basis of this underperformance has remained poorly understood. This research seeks to bridge the gap between phenotypic observation and genetic mechanism: Why does the genetic shuffling of two specialized lines result in a metabolic breakdown in the F1 generation?

Methodology

The researchers performed reciprocal crossing experiments using two distinct lines: the Cornish (C), a meat-type breed selected for rapid growth, and the Rhode Island White (R), a layer breed selected for egg production.

Key techniques included:

  • Phenotypic Tracking: Measuring body weight weekly for 8 weeks and performing detailed carcass analysis (slaughter weight, breast muscle mass, etc.) at 6 weeks.
  • Transcriptome Analysis (RNA-seq): Sequencing the mRNA of breast muscle tissues from purebred (CC, RR) and crossbred (CR, RC) chickens to identify Differentially Expressed Genes (DEGs).
  • Inheritance Pattern Classification: Categorizing genes into additivity (expression is the average of parents), dominance (expression mimics one parent), or overdominance (expression is outside the parental range).
  • Metabolic Validation: Measuring actual ATP content and ATPase activity in muscle tissues to confirm if the gene expression patterns translated to functional metabolic differences.

Results and Discussion

The Magnitude of the Growth Slump

Negative heterosis was not merely a minor statistical dip; it was a substantial phenotypic decline. Body weight measurements showed widespread negative heterosis across both sexes, reaching its peak slump between weeks 5 and 6, with heterosis percentages (H%) dropping as low as -21.63%.

Growth curves and heterosis percentages for female (a, c) and male (b, d) chickens over 8 weeks, illustrating the significant growth deficit in crossbreds (CR, RC) compared to the mid-parent value.

Carcass Traits and Muscle Development

The most extreme negative heterosis was observed in carcass traits, particularly breast muscle mass. In females, breast muscle weight showed negative heterosis values of -42.35% (CR) and -49.93% (RC). This indicates that the genetic combination of broiler and layer lines specifically impairs the development of high-value muscle tissues.

Carcass trait weights and heterosis percentages for females (a, b) and males (c, d) at 6 weeks, highlighting the extreme negative heterosis in breast muscle mass.

Molecular Drivers: The Metabolic Paradox

Transcriptomic analysis revealed that over 68% of the differentially expressed genes in the crosses followed nonadditive inheritance patterns (dominance or overdominance). Most of these genes "sided" with the slower-growing layer parent. Functional enrichment showed these nonadditive genes were heavily concentrated in the oxidative phosphorylation pathway—the cell's primary engine for generating energy (ATP).

Biochemical confirmation revealed a "metabolic paradox": crossbred chickens exhibited significantly lower ATP concentrations but higher ATPase activity. Essentially, their muscles were burning through energy faster than they could produce it, leaving insufficient energy available for protein synthesis and growth. The meat-type parent (CC) maintained the most efficient profile, with the highest ATP levels and lowest ATPase activity.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that negative heterosis in chicken growth is driven by nonadditive gene expression that disrupts energy metabolism. By identifying oxidative phosphorylation as a key pathway, this research provides a molecular framework for understanding hybrid underperformance. These insights are vital for refining breeding programs to avoid detrimental genetic combinations and optimize growth traits in poultry.

Summary updated

Abstract

These findings revealed that nonadditive genes and their related oxidative phosphorylation were the major genetic and molecular factors in the negative heterosis of growth in chickens, which would be beneficial to future breeding strategies.
BibTeX
@article{mai2021genetic,
  author = {Chunning Mai and Chaoliang Wen and Zhiyuan Xu and Guiyun Xu and Sirui Chen and Jiangxia Zheng and Congjiao Sun and Ning Yang},
  title = {{Genetic basis of negative heterosis for growth traits in chickens revealed by genome-wide gene expression pattern analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology/Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s40104-021-00574-2},
}
Figure