Genetic and Environmental Influences on Motor Function: A Magnetoencephalographic Study of Twins

Toshihiko Araki, Masayuki Hirata, Hisato Sugata, Takufumi Yanagisawa, Mai Onishi, Yoshiyuki Watanabe, K Omura, Chika Honda, Kazuo Hayakawa, Shiro YorifujiFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2014 · DOI

Abstract

To investigate the effect of genetic and environmental influences on cerebral motor function, we determined similarities and differences of movement-related cortical fields (MRCFs) in middle-aged and elderly monozygotic (MZ) twins. MRCFs were measured using a 160-channel magnetoencephalogram system when MZ twins were instructed to repeat lifting of the right index finger. We compared latency, amplitude, dipole location, and dipole intensity of movement-evoked field 1 (MEF1) between 16 MZ twins and 16 pairs of genetically unrelated pairs. Differences in latency and dipole location between MZ twins were significantly less than those between unrelated age-matched pairs. However, amplitude and dipole intensity were not significantly different. These results suggest that the latency and dipole location of MEF1 are determined early in life by genetic and early common environmental factors, whereas amplitude and dipole intensity are influenced by long-term environmental factors.

Introduction

Human motor function is a complex interplay between innate genetic blueprints and skills acquired through environmental interaction. While genetic markers like ACTN3 are known to correlate with physical performance, the specific neurophysiological components of brain activity that are "hard-coded" versus those that remain plastic are not fully understood.

To isolate these influences, researchers study monozygotic (MZ) twins, who share 100% of their genetic material. By examining older MZ twins who have lived apart for decades, it is possible to identify which brain characteristics remain synchronized (suggesting genetic or early-life stability) and which have diverged (suggesting the influence of long-term environmental factors).

Methods

The study, published in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, involved 16 pairs of healthy MZ twins (average age ~62) and 16 pairs of age-matched unrelated controls. Zygosity was strictly verified using short tandem repeat (STR) typing.

Participants performed a self-paced right index finger lifting task while their brain activity was recorded using a 160-channel Magnetoencephalography (MEG) system. The analysis focused on the Movement-Evoked Field 1 (MEF1), a robust signal occurring approximately 80–120 ms after muscle contraction, originating in the primary somatosensory or motor cortex.

Measurement of MEF1 latency and amplitude from MEG waveforms.

Four primary metrics were extracted from the MEF1 signal:

  1. Latency: The timing of the peak signal.
  2. Amplitude: The peak strength of the magnetic field.
  3. Dipole Location: The precise 3D coordinates of the signal source.
  4. Dipole Intensity: The estimated current strength at the source.

Key Results

The researchers found a distinct split in how genetic and environmental factors influence motor signals. Differences in latency and dipole location were significantly smaller in MZ twins compared to unrelated pairs ($p < 0.05$). This indicates that the anatomical "wiring" and the timing of the motor system are remarkably stable over time, likely anchored by genetics or early common environmental factors.

Topographic map showing the spatial distribution of MEG amplitude during the finger-lifting task.

In contrast, amplitude and dipole intensity showed no significant similarity between twins compared to unrelated individuals. This suggests that the "volume" or strength of the neural motor output is not fixed but is instead shaped by a lifetime of unique experiences, physical habits, and environmental interactions.

Discussion: Hardware vs. Software

These findings suggest a "hardware vs. software" model of the motor cortex. The similarity in latency may be linked to genetically determined rates of myelination, which dictates signal transmission speed and is largely established early in life. This serves as a stable neural "fingerprint."

Conversely, the lack of similarity in signal strength (amplitude and intensity) highlights the brain's functional plasticity. These metrics appear to be the "software" of the motor system, constantly updated by the individual's environment and motor demands over decades of life.

Limitations and Future Work

While the study provides strong evidence for the stability of motor timing and location, it cannot perfectly distinguish between genetics and the shared early environment (e.g., womb, childhood nutrition). Future research incorporating dizygotic (DZ) twins—who share 50% of their DNA but the same early environment—is necessary to further isolate the genetic component. Additionally, exploring more complex motor tasks may reveal different patterns of influence beyond the simple finger-lift model used here.

Summary updated

Abstract

To investigate the effect of genetic and environmental influences on cerebral motor function, we determined similarities and differences of movement-related cortical fields (MRCFs) in middle-aged and elderly monozygotic (MZ) twins. MRCFs were measured using a 160-channel magnetoencephalogram system when MZ twins were instructed to repeat lifting of the right index finger. We compared latency, amplitude, dipole location, and dipole intensity of movement-evoked field 1 (MEF1) between 16 MZ twins and 16 pairs of genetically unrelated pairs. Differences in latency and dipole location between MZ twins were significantly less than those between unrelated age-matched pairs. However, amplitude and dipole intensity were not significantly different. These results suggest that the latency and dipole location of MEF1 are determined early in life by genetic and early common environmental factors, whereas amplitude and dipole intensity are influenced by long-term environmental factors. Improved understanding of genetic and environmental factors that influence cerebral motor function may contribute to evaluation and improvement for individual motor function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{araki2014genetic,
  author = {Toshihiko Araki and Masayuki Hirata and Hisato Sugata and Takufumi Yanagisawa and Mai Onishi and Yoshiyuki Watanabe and K Omura and Chika Honda and Kazuo Hayakawa and Shiro Yorifuji},
  title = {{Genetic and Environmental Influences on Motor Function: A Magnetoencephalographic Study of Twins}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2014.00455},
}
Figure