Genetic and environmental contributions to food use patterns of young adult twins

Kaisu Keskitalo, Karri Silventoinen, Hely Tuorila, Markus Perola, Kirsi H. Pietiläinen, Aila Rissanen, Jaakko KaprioPhysiology 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the genetic and environmental factors influencing food choices in young adults using a large twin cohort. It found that while genetics plays a significant role (around 40-45% of the variation), shared family environment has no discernible impact on adult food habits, suggesting that nutritional education should target young adults directly.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding what drives our food choices is crucial, as diet profoundly impacts health. While children's food preferences are heavily shaped by taste and familiarity, adult choices are influenced by a complex interplay of factors including nutrition knowledge, culture, and economics. Previous twin studies have suggested a genetic component to food use, but the relative contributions of genetics and environment, particularly the role of shared family environment, remain unclear, especially as individuals transition into adulthood and gain independence. This paper aims to disentangle these influences in young adults (22-27 years old) to better inform public health strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative genetic modeling approach using data from a large Finnish twin cohort. They utilized a food-frequency questionnaire to assess the consumption patterns of 24 food items. Factor analysis was used to group these items into four broader categories: "healthy" foods, high-fat foods, sweet foods, and meats. The core of their analysis involved applying classical twin modeling, specifically the ACE model (Additive genetic, Common environmental, and unique Environmental effects), to estimate the proportions of variance attributable to each factor. They also explored the possibility of sex-specific genetic effects, meaning different genes might influence food choices in males and females. Statistical analyses were performed using the SPSS statistical package and the Mx statistical package for genetic modeling.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a large population-based Finnish twin cohort, comprising 4388 twin individuals from five consecutive birth cohorts (1975-1979). The data was collected through a postal questionnaire during the fourth wave of a longitudinal study, when participants were aged 22-27 years. The sample included 2009 complete twin pairs with known zygosity (monozygotic and dizygotic, both same-sex and opposite-sex).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Family Environment Doesn't Shape Adult Food Habits: Perhaps the most striking finding is that shared environmental factors, like growing up in the same household, do not significantly influence food use patterns in young adulthood. This suggests that once individuals leave home, the family's influence on their dietary choices diminishes considerably.
  • Genetics is a Major Player: A substantial portion of the variation in how often people consume different foods is inherited, with additive genetic effects accounting for approximately 40% of the variance in individual food item use and 45% in food categories.
  • Sex-Specific Genetic Influences Exist: The study identified that for certain food items and categories (like fresh vegetables, fruits, cheeses, and meat), the genetic underpinnings of food use can differ between males and females. This highlights the nuanced nature of genetic influence on complex behaviors.
  • No "One-Size-Fits-All" Genetic Factor: While genetics is important, the heritability estimates for different food items and categories were quite similar, suggesting that there isn't a single "food preference gene" but rather a complex interplay of genes influencing various aspects of food choice.

Key Results

  • Overall Genetic Influence: Approximately 40% of the variance in individual food item use and 45% of the variance in food category use was attributed to additive genetic factors.
  • Unshared Environment Dominates: The remaining variance (around 55-60%) was explained by unshared environmental factors, which include individual experiences and measurement error.
  • No Shared Environment Effect: Shared environmental factors did not contribute to the variance in food use in young adults.
  • Highest Heritability: Items like hamburgers, other sweets (excluding chocolate), and fruits showed the highest heritability estimates.
  • Sex Differences: Significant sex differences in genetic influences were observed for meat, fried foods, chocolate, and other sweets, as well as for fresh vegetables, fruits, and cheeses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations. The study relied on self-reported food use frequencies, which may be subject to misreporting (conscious or unconscious) and does not capture actual consumed quantities. The food items were also limited to 24 common foods in the Finnish diet, and some items were grouped, which might obscure finer distinctions. Furthermore, the study design did not allow for the separation of common environmental effects from dominant genetic effects.

Future work could involve using more objective measures of food intake (e.g., dietary diaries, biomarkers) and exploring gene-environment interactions more deeply. The findings also strongly suggest that nutritional education should be tailored to young adults, as this is a critical period for establishing lifelong healthy eating habits, and interventions should acknowledge the significant genetic predispositions involved. Further research could also investigate the specific genes contributing to these food preferences.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{keskitalo2007genetic,
  author = {Kaisu Keskitalo and Karri Silventoinen and Hely Tuorila and Markus Perola and Kirsi H. Pietiläinen and Aila Rissanen and Jaakko Kaprio},
  title = {{Genetic and environmental contributions to food use patterns of young adult twins}},
  booktitle = {Physiology},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physbeh.2007.08.025},
}
Figure