Genes Influence Young Children’s Human Figure Drawings and Their Association With Intelligence a Decade Later

Rosalind Arden, Maciej Trzaskowski, Victoria Garfield, Robert PlominPsychological 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that individual differences in young children's human figure drawings are significantly influenced by genetics, to a similar extent as general intelligence (g). Furthermore, drawing ability at age 4 is genetically linked to intelligence measured a decade later, suggesting a shared genetic basis for these seemingly distinct cognitive and expressive skills.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the Goodenough Draw-a-Man Test has been a popular, albeit sometimes controversial, method for assessing children's cognitive abilities. While its utility has been recognized, the underlying etiology of individual differences in children's figure drawing has remained largely unexplored. Specifically, the extent to which genetic factors versus environmental influences shape these drawings, and whether drawing ability at a young age predicts later intelligence, has been unclear. This paper aims to fill this gap by using a genetically informative twin study design to disentangle the genetic and environmental contributions to figure drawing and its relationship with intelligence over time.

Methods

The researchers employed a behavioral genetic design, specifically a twin study, utilizing data from the Twins Early Development Study (TEDS). This design leverages the fact that identical twins (monozygotic, MZ) share 100% of their genes, while fraternal twins (dizygotic, DZ) share approximately 50%. By comparing the similarity of traits between MZ and DZ twin pairs, researchers can estimate the heritability of those traits and the extent to which shared and non-shared environmental factors contribute.

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Intraclass Correlations (ICCs): Used to initially assess the degree of similarity between twin pairs for drawing and intelligence scores, providing a preliminary indication of genetic influence.
  • Univariate Model Fitting (ACE model): This standard biometric model decomposes variance into additive genetic effects (A), shared environmental effects (C), and non-shared environmental effects (E) for individual traits.
  • Trivariate Cholesky Decomposition: A more advanced technique used to estimate the genetic and environmental contributions to the covariance between multiple traits (in this case, drawing at age 4, general intelligence at age 4, and general intelligence at age 14). This allows for the examination of shared genetic and environmental influences underlying the relationships between these traits.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Twins Early Development Study (TEDS), a large, ongoing longitudinal study of twins born in England and Wales between 1994 and 1996.

  • Sample Size: The study included a substantial sample of 7,752 twin pairs for the figure drawing analysis at age 4, with smaller but still significant subsamples for intelligence measures at age 4 (7,231 pairs) and age 14 (2,348 pairs).
  • Measures:
    • Figure Drawing: Assessed at age 4 using the "Draw-a-Child" test, where parents instructed children to draw a human figure. Drawings were scored objectively based on the presence and correct quantity of specific bodily features and clothing (scores ranging from 0 to 12).
  • General Intelligence (g): Measured at age 4 using a composite of verbal and nonverbal cognitive tests (including sentence construction, odd-one-out, design drawing, puzzle tests, and conceptual knowledge items). At age 14, intelligence was assessed using Raven's Standard Progressive Matrices and a vocabulary test.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Drawing is More Than Just Doodling: The study strongly suggests that individual differences in how children draw human figures are not solely due to environmental factors like parental encouragement or access to art supplies. Genetics plays a significant role.
  • A Shared Genetic Blueprint: The most striking finding is the substantial genetic correlation between drawing ability at age 4 and general intelligence measured a decade later. This implies that some of the same genes that influence a child's ability to draw a recognizable human figure also contribute to their cognitive abilities later in life.
  • Drawing as an Early Indicator: The strong phenotypic correlation between drawing at age 4 and intelligence at age 14, even stronger than the correlation between intelligence at age 4 and age 14, highlights the potential of figure drawing as an early, albeit indirect, indicator of later cognitive potential.
  • Ancient Behavior, Modern Insights: The paper connects the ancient practice of drawing to modern genetic research, underscoring that this fundamental human behavior has deep biological roots.

Key Results

  • Heritability of Drawing: Figure drawing at age 4 was found to be as heritable as general intelligence (g) at age 4, with a heritability estimate of .29 for both.
  • Phenotypic Correlations:
    • Drawing scores at age 4 correlated significantly with g at age 4 (r = .33).
  • Drawing scores at age 4 also correlated significantly with g at age 14 (r = .20). This correlation was surprisingly strong, nearly as high as the correlation between g at age 4 and g at age 14.
  • Genetic Correlation: The genetic correlation between drawing at age 4 and g at age 14 was substantial at .52, indicating that a significant portion of the relationship between these two measures is explained by shared genetic influences.
  • Environmental Influence: While genetics played a key role, shared environmental factors accounted for 23% of the variance in drawing scores at age 4, and non-shared environmental factors accounted for 51%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Representativeness: While TEDS is a large and representative UK sample, the authors acknowledge that individuals at the extreme ends of distributions (e.g., socioeconomic status) may be underrepresented in most studies.
  • Scoring Method: The "Draw-a-Child" test scoring is objective but simplified, ignoring aspects like artistic quality, proportion, or emotional expression. This means the findings are specific to the accuracy of feature representation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this research opens avenues for exploring the specific cognitive, motoric, perceptual, and motivational capacities that underpin this genetically influenced behavior. Further research could investigate how these drawing abilities develop and interact with other cognitive skills over time, and explore the specific genes involved. The ecological validity of the drawing test, given its ancient origins, also suggests it could remain a valuable tool for understanding cognitive development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Drawing is ancient; it is the only childhood cognitive behavior for which there is any direct evidence from the Upper Paleolithic. Do genes influence individual differences in this species-typical behavior, and is drawing related to intelligence (g) in modern children? We report on the first genetically informative study of children's figure drawing. In a study of 7,752 pairs of twins, we found that genetic differences exert a greater influence on children's figure drawing at age 4 than do between-family environmental differences. Figure drawing was as heritable as g at age 4 (heritability of .29 for both). Drawing scores at age 4 correlated significantly with g at age 4 (r = .33, p < .001, n = 14,050) and with g at age 14 (r = .20, p < .001, n = 4,622). The genetic correlation between drawing at age 4 and g at age 14 was .52, 95% confidence interval = [.31, .75]. Individual differences in this widespread behavior have an important genetic component and a significant genetic link with g.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arden2014genes,
  author = {Rosalind Arden and Maciej Trzaskowski and Victoria Garfield and Robert Plomin},
  title = {{Genes Influence Young Children’s Human Figure Drawings and Their Association With Intelligence a Decade Later}},
  booktitle = {Psychological},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1177/0956797614540686},
}
Figure