Generalized Imperfect D2D Associations in Spectrum-Shared Cellular Networks Under Transmit Power and Interference Constraints

Redha M. Radaydeh, Fawaz S. Al-Qahtani, Abdulkadir Celik, Khalid A. Qaraqe, Mohamed-Slim AlouiniIEEE Access 2020 · OpenReview

Introduction

Device-to-Device (D2D) communication is a pivotal technology for 5G and beyond, enabling direct communication between nearby terminals to offload traffic from base stations and improve spectrum efficiency. However, most theoretical models assume "perfect association," where receivers always connect to the optimal transmitter via the cleanest channel. In practice, hardware limitations, battery constraints, and strict interference requirements for primary cellular users often force "imperfect" associations. This paper presents a generalized analytical framework to address these real-world constraints in decentralized spectrum-shared networks.

System Model and Constraints

The study focuses on underlay D2D communication where D2D pairs share downlink resources with a primary cellular network. The framework incorporates three critical practical constraints:

  1. Transmit Power Constraints: D2D terminals are limited by their remaining battery life and maximum power levels.
  2. Processing Load Limitations: Hardware can only support a finite number of concurrent D2D links. A device's readiness to serve as a transmitter is heavily dictated by this hardware limit.
  3. Interference Thresholds: D2D links must not exceed specific interference levels to avoid disrupting primary cellular users.

The authors use order statistics to model these "imperfect" scenarios, allowing for the calculation of performance metrics like Signal-to-Interference-plus-Noise Ratio (SINR) for the $n$-th best available link, representing cases where the optimal choice is unavailable due to congestion or hardware limits.

Proposed Association Schemes

The paper proposes two decentralized schemes for establishing D2D links, varying in complexity and performance. These schemes aim to concurrently maximize desired link quality and minimize interference at D2D receivers.

Flowchart of the proposed decentralized D2D association schemes

Simultaneous D2D Association

In this scheme, the receiver searches for the optimal transmitter and reusable channel concurrently. While this maximizes potential link quality, it requires significant communication overhead and higher computational power at the terminal.

Sequential D2D Association

This more practical approach first identifies a suitable transmitter and then searches for an available channel. This reduces implementation complexity and is better suited for low-power devices, though it introduces a performance gap compared to the simultaneous method.

Key Insights and Results

Numerical simulations based on standard wireless channel models validated the analytical framework, revealing several key findings:

  • The Hardware Bottleneck: As the number of requested D2D services increases, the probability of a device being able to act as a transmitter drops sharply because it hits its hardware processing limit.
  • The Cost of Simplicity: Sequential association is easier to implement but comes with a quantifiable performance gap. The paper shows exactly how much reliability is traded for lower complexity.
  • Interference Sensitivity: The likelihood of finding any reusable channel drops significantly as the primary cellular network's interference threshold becomes stricter. In dense networks, the "universal" approach to channel reusability often fails, suggesting that pair-wise coordination is necessary.
  • Outage Performance: Settling for sub-optimal (imperfect) links—such as the second or third best transmitter—leads to significant drops in received SINR, highlighting the importance of accurate modeling for congested networks.

Conclusion

By moving beyond idealized models, this research provides a toolset for engineers to predict network behavior under practical constraints. The generalized results are applicable across various channel models and performance metrics, offering insights into the deployment of robust, decentralized D2D networks in spectrum-shared environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper studies imperfect underlay device-to-device (D2D) association in spectrum-shared cellular networks. It addresses important system and design interference constraints, processing load limitations and transmit power constraints at D2D terminals. The paper proposes decentralized schemes for D2D communication between D2D terminals when downlink channel resources can be reused in the D2D network. The D2D transmitters are characterized considering their processing load limitation and allocated transmit power constraints. Moreover, the downlink channels that can be reused in the D2D network are quantified while meeting interference constraints imposed by the primary cellular network. Two schemes to identify reusable channels, which vary in terms of their efficiency, communication overhead requirement and implementation complexity, are described. Moreover, two D2D association schemes, namely the simultaneous and sequential D2D associations, are proposed and both aim to concurrently maximize the desired link quality and minimize the effect of interference effect at D2D receivers. Generalized analytical results that are applicable for various imperfect association scenarios are presented. The findings are applicable for any D2D channel models and performance metrics. They provide insights into various imperfect underlay D2D association scenarios under the practical system and design constraints.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{radaydeh2020generalized,
  author = {Redha M. Radaydeh and Fawaz S. Al-Qahtani and Abdulkadir Celik and Khalid A. Qaraqe and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Generalized Imperfect D2D Associations in Spectrum-Shared Cellular Networks Under Transmit Power and Interference Constraints}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uU8TG4ZFOt},
}
Figure