Generalized Finite Algorithms for Constructing Hermitian Matrices with Prescribed Diagonal and Spectrum

Inderjit S. Dhillon, Robert W. Heath Jr., Mátyás A. Sustik, Joel A. TroppSIAM J. Matrix Anal. Appl 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces new algorithms that can construct Hermitian matrices with specific diagonal entries and eigenvalues. These algorithms generalize existing methods, offering more flexibility in creating matrices for applications like signal processing and statistical experiments, by leveraging a sequence of plane rotations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the problem of constructing Hermitian matrices that simultaneously satisfy constraints on their diagonal entries and their eigenvalues. This is a fundamental problem with applications in various fields, including statistical experiments, signal processing (e.g., designing correlation matrices for wireless communications), and numerical analysis (e.g., generating test matrices for eigenvalue solvers).

Specifically, the problem can be framed as follows: given a set of desired eigenvalues and a set of desired diagonal entries, can we construct a Hermitian matrix that has exactly these eigenvalues and these diagonal entries? The Schur-Horn theorem provides a crucial condition for the existence of such a matrix: the desired diagonal entries must "majorize" the desired eigenvalues. Majorization is a mathematical concept that essentially means the desired diagonal entries have a more "spread out" or "averaged" distribution compared to the eigenvalues. Existing algorithms could construct such matrices for specific cases (e.g., starting from eigenvalues or aiming for unit diagonals), but a more general approach was needed.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in developing generalized algorithms that extend the capabilities of existing methods like the Bendel-Mickey and Chan-Li algorithms. These new algorithms use sequences of plane rotations to transform a given Hermitian matrix into one with a desired diagonal, while crucially preserving its original spectrum (eigenvalues).

The key innovation is in the strategy for selecting the planes of rotation. Instead of being restricted to moving to the "top" (e.g., unit diagonal) or "bottom" (e.g., diagonal of eigenvalues) of a "chain" of related matrices, the generalized algorithms allow for more arbitrary movement within this chain.

Two main algorithms are presented:

  • Generalized Bendel-Mickey Algorithm: This algorithm starts with an arbitrary Hermitian matrix and iteratively applies plane rotations to modify its diagonal entries to match a target vector, provided the target vector majorizes the current diagonal. The strategy for choosing which pair of diagonal entries to modify is key.
  • Generalized Chan-Li Algorithm: This algorithm, based on induction, also uses plane rotations but employs a different strategy for selecting the rotation planes. It's designed to be a more direct generalization of the Chan-Li proof of the Schur-Horn theorem.

The paper also extends these ideas to one-sided algorithms. By leveraging the fact that any positive semidefinite matrix can be factored as $X^*X$, the algorithms are adapted to construct factors $X$ with specified singular values and column norms, which directly relate to the eigenvalues and diagonal entries of $X^*X$.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on algorithmic development and theoretical construction rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Majorization as the unifying principle: The paper firmly establishes majorization as the fundamental condition governing the relationship between diagonal entries and eigenvalues of Hermitian matrices.
  • Plane rotations as the building blocks: The elegance of using simple 2D plane rotations (Givens rotations) to achieve complex matrix transformations is highlighted.
  • Generalized movement in Schur-Horn equivalence classes: The most significant insight is the development of algorithms that can move freely "up" a chain of Schur-Horn equivalent matrices, not just to the extremes. This greatly expands the set of constructible matrices.
  • Connection between two-sided and one-sided problems: The paper elegantly shows how the problem of constructing Hermitian matrices can be translated into constructing matrix factors with specified properties, bridging two related areas.

Key Results

The paper presents two generalized finite-step algorithms (Generalized Bendel-Mickey and Generalized Chan-Li) that can construct Hermitian matrices with a prescribed diagonal and spectrum, provided the majorization condition is met. These algorithms are shown to be more flexible than their predecessors, allowing for the construction of a richer set of matrices. The paper also provides a one-sided version of the Bendel-Mickey algorithm for constructing matrix factors. Numerical examples demonstrate the application of these algorithms, showing they can produce matrices with desired properties, sometimes with distinct sparsity structures compared to classical methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Moving "down" a chain: A key open problem is whether an algorithm can be developed to move "down" a chain of Schur-Horn equivalence classes, meaning constructing a matrix whose diagonal majorizes the eigenvalues but not necessarily the original diagonal. This would be a more direct way to construct matrices with eigenvalues as the diagonal.
  • Uniform random construction: The paper raises the question of whether it's possible to define a uniform probability measure on Schur-Horn equivalence classes and construct members uniformly at random.
  • Structure of equivalence classes: Understanding the general structure of Schur-Horn equivalence classes of Hermitian matrices is posed as an interesting theoretical question.
  • Iterative vs. Finite-Step: While the paper focuses on finite-step algorithms, it acknowledges that iterative algorithms might be useful for producing matrices with additional constraints.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{dhillon2005generalized,
  author = {Inderjit S. Dhillon and Robert W. Heath Jr. and Mátyás A. Sustik and Joel A. Tropp},
  title = {{Generalized Finite Algorithms for Constructing Hermitian Matrices with Prescribed Diagonal and Spectrum}},
  journal = {SIAM J. Matrix Anal. Appl.},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1137/s0895479803438183},
}
Figure