Generalized Damping Torque Analysis of Ultra-Low Frequency Oscillation in the Jerk Space

Yichen Zhou, Yang Yang, Tao Zhou, Yonggang LiarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Ultra-low frequency oscillations (ULFO), typically occurring below 0.1 Hz, pose a significant threat to the stability of hydro-dominant power systems. These oscillations can lead to generator tripping or grid islanding. While Generalized Damping Torque Analysis (GDTA) is a standard tool for studying low-frequency oscillations (LFO), its application to ULFO is limited because ULFO is primarily a frequency stability issue rather than a rotor angle dynamic issue. This paper proposes a novel "jerk space" framework to provide a more accurate and intuitive analysis of ULFO mechanisms.

The Jerk Space Framework

The core innovation of this research is the shift from standard state-space analysis to the jerk space. By defining frequency acceleration ($\alpha$) as the first derivative of frequency and frequency jerk ($\zeta$) as the second derivative, the authors transform the complex turbine-generator dynamics into a manageable second-order differential equation.

This transformation allows for the establishment of a frequency-frequency acceleration ($\Delta f - \Delta \alpha$) phase space. Within this space, analytical expressions for damping torque can be derived, allowing for a clear decomposition of damping contributions from the generator, load, and various paths within the governor system.

System Modeling and Methodology

The study utilizes a Hydropower Single-Machine Single-Load (HSMSL) system model, which is the benchmark for stability analysis in hydro-dominant grids.

Detailed block diagram of the HSMSL model including the governor system, hydraulic turbine, and generator.

To ensure the robustness of the analytical formulas, the researchers tested them against 500 random system parameter sets. This large-scale validation confirmed that the governor system consistently acts as a "damping competitor," often providing excessive negative damping that triggers ULFO.

Key Insights and Parameter Tuning

The analysis reveals that the slow response of hydraulic turbines, caused by water inertia, inherently leads the governor system to provide negative damping in the ultra-low frequency range. ULFO occurs when this negative damping outweighs the positive damping provided by the generator and load.

The "jerk space" method's accuracy was verified by comparing its results with traditional eigenvalue analysis, yielding identical predictions for weakly damped modes. Furthermore, the framework provides clear engineering guidelines for suppressing oscillations.

Effects of parameter adjustment on system stability, showing root locus, damping torque components, and time-domain frequency response.

As shown in the results, stability can be improved by:

  • Increasing generator damping ($D$), inertia ($T_J$), and load sensitivity ($K_L$).
  • Decreasing the water flow inertia time constant ($T_W$).
  • Tuning the Governor: Reducing the integral gain ($K_{I1}$) or increasing the permanent droop ($b_p$) and specific proportional gains ($K_{P1}, K_{P2}$) effectively suppresses oscillations.

Conclusion

The jerk space framework offers a powerful new lens for analyzing frequency stability in power systems. By simplifying high-order dynamics into a second-order problem, it provides engineers with intuitive tools to identify instability mechanisms and implement effective tuning strategies. Future work will focus on extending this analysis to multi-machine systems and investigating the impact of integrated renewable energy sources.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhou2023generalized,
  author = {Yichen Zhou and Yang Yang and Tao Zhou and Yonggang Li},
  title = {{Generalized Damping Torque Analysis of Ultra-Low Frequency Oscillation in the Jerk Space}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2312.04148},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04148},
}
Figure