General psychopathology, internalising and externalising in children and functional outcomes in late adolescence

Hannah Sallis, Eszter Székely, Alexander Neumann, Alexia Jolicoeur‐Martineau, Marinus H. van IJzendoorn, Manon H. J. Hillegers, Celia M.t. Greenwood, Michael J. Meaney, Meir Steiner, Henning Tiemeier, Ashley Wazana, Rebecca M. Pearson, Jonathan EvansJournal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study proposes a "general psychopathology factor" (GPF) that captures shared variance across internalizing and externalizing symptoms in children. This GPF, along with specific internalizing and externalizing factors, was found to predict long-term outcomes like depression, anxiety, and academic achievement, suggesting that a broad vulnerability is more predictive than specific symptom clusters.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Childhood psychopathology is often categorized into internalizing (e.g., anxiety, depression) and externalizing (e.g., conduct problems, aggression) symptoms. However, these categories frequently co-occur, making it challenging to understand their distinct and shared contributions to long-term outcomes. Existing models struggle to adequately account for this comorbidity. This paper aims to disentangle the structure of childhood psychopathology by proposing a model that separates unique symptom contributions from a general underlying vulnerability, and to assess how these components predict later life functioning.

Methods

The researchers employed structural equation modeling (SEM), specifically a bifactor model, to analyze the data. This approach allows for the estimation of both a general factor (GPF) that influences all symptoms and specific factors (internalizing and externalizing) that capture variance unique to those symptom groups. They also incorporated "rater factors" to account for the influence of different informants (parents, teachers, fieldworkers). Model fit was assessed using standard indices like RMSEA, CFI, and TLI. To evaluate the predictive utility of the model, linear and logistic regressions were used to link childhood psychopathology factors to later adolescent and adult outcomes.

Datasets

The study utilized data from three large, independent birth cohort studies:

  • Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC): N = 11,612
  • Generation R: N = 7,946
  • Maternal Adversity, Vulnerability and Neurodevelopment (MAVAN): N = 408

These datasets provided longitudinal data on childhood psychopathology and later life outcomes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "General Psychopathology Factor" (GPF) is Key: The most significant finding is the robust evidence for a GPF that underlies both internalizing and externalizing symptoms. This suggests a broad vulnerability to psychopathology rather than distinct, independent pathways.
  • GPF Predicts Broad Outcomes: The GPF was a strong predictor of a range of adverse outcomes, including depression, anxiety, and academic difficulties, highlighting its importance for understanding long-term functional impairment.
  • Specific Internalizing Factor Matters, Specific Externalizing Less So: While the GPF was broadly predictive, the specific internalizing factor also predicted later internalizing problems. Surprisingly, the specific externalizing factor, after accounting for the GPF, did not predict adverse outcomes. This implies that the shared variance (GPF) is more critical for externalizing-related outcomes than unique externalizing symptoms.
  • Informant Variance is Important: Accounting for different informants (parents, teachers, etc.) significantly improved model fit, underscoring the value of multi-informant assessments in capturing the complexity of child psychopathology.
  • Transdiagnostic Approaches May Be Beneficial: The findings support the idea that interventions targeting general vulnerability (e.g., transdiagnostic approaches) might be more effective for preventing long-term adverse outcomes than focusing solely on specific symptom clusters.

Key Results

  • The bifactor model, including a GPF, specific internalizing and externalizing factors, and rater factors, provided the best fit across all three cohorts.
  • The GPF was significantly associated with:
  • Increased risk of depressive disorder (β = .117, p = .001).
  • Decreased psychological well-being (β = -.062, p = .001).
  • Increased likelihood of failing mathematics GCSE (β = -.235, p<.001) and English GCSE (β = -.260, p < .001).
  • Reduced risk of problem drinking (β = -.102, p < .001).
  • The specific internalizing factor was associated with increased risk for depression (β = .085, p = .030) and anxiety (β = .184, p < .001), and decreased well-being (β = -.089, p<.001).
  • The specific externalizing factor showed minimal predictive power for adverse outcomes when the GPF was included.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Differences: While efforts were made to harmonize measures, there were some differences in the specific psychopathology measures used across cohorts. Child self-reports were also unavailable in ALSPAC for the relevant age group.
  • Missing Data Imputation: Missing data were imputed to maximize sample size, which could introduce some bias, although sensitivity analyses on complete cases in ALSPAC yielded consistent results.
  • Cross-Sectional Outcomes: While the study examined longitudinal associations, the outcomes were assessed at specific time points, not continuously, limiting insights into the trajectory of symptoms over time.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research should replicate these findings in independent cohorts and explore the developmental pathways of these factors over time. They also highlight the potential for interventions to focus on the co-occurrence of symptoms to prevent long-term impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

Early symptoms of psychopathology carry information that is syndrome-specific as well as indicative of general vulnerability and the informant reporting on the child. The 'general psychopathology factor' might be more relevant for long-term outcomes than specific symptoms. These findings emphasise the importance of considering the co-occurrence of common internalising and externalising problems in childhood when considering long-term impact.
BibTeX
@article{sallis2019general,
  author = {Hannah Sallis and Eszter Székely and Alexander Neumann and Alexia Jolicoeur‐Martineau and Marinus H. van IJzendoorn and Manon H. J. Hillegers and Celia M.T. Greenwood and Michael J. Meaney and Meir Steiner and Henning Tiemeier and Ashley Wazana and Rebecca M. Pearson and Jonathan Evans},
  title = {{General psychopathology, internalising and externalising in children and functional outcomes in late adolescence}},
  journal = {Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1111/jcpp.13067},
}
Figure