General Procedure to Provide High-Probability Guarantees for Stochastic Saddle Point Problems

Dongyang Li, Haobin Li, Junyu ZhangJ. Sci. Comput 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a general framework, PB-SSP, to provide high-probability guarantees for finding solutions to stochastic saddle point problems (SSPs). It achieves this with only a modest increase in sample complexity, significantly improving upon existing methods that often struggle with high-probability guarantees or require excessive samples.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stochastic saddle point problems (SSPs) are fundamental in many areas, including adversarial learning, reinforcement learning, and robust optimization. A key challenge in solving these problems is not just finding a solution that performs well on average (in expectation), but one that is guaranteed to perform well with a high probability. Existing methods often provide good expected performance but lack strong guarantees on the probability of achieving a desired solution quality. This gap is particularly problematic in applications where reliability is paramount. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a general procedure that can boost the high-probability guarantees of existing SSP oracles.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution is the PB-SSP framework. This is a meta-framework that takes an existing SSP oracle (which provides expected guarantees) and enhances it to provide high-probability guarantees. The PB-SSP framework leverages two key ideas:

  1. Inexact Proximal Point Algorithm (IPPA): This is a classical optimization technique adapted to SSPs. By iteratively solving perturbed subproblems with increasing regularization, IPPA helps to mitigate the dependence on the condition number of the problem, which is a common bottleneck.
  2. Robust Distance Estimation (RDE): This technique, borrowed from prior work, is used to extract candidate "good" points from a set of generated samples with high probability.

The PB-SSP framework combines these by iteratively applying IPPA to generate candidate solutions and then using RDE to select the best one with high probability. The paper also shows how this framework can be applied to specific oracles like Sample Average Approximation (SAA) and first-order methods, leading to improved sample complexity bounds.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical guarantees and algorithmic frameworks, using synthetic or simulated data for experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Expectation-Probability Gap: The most significant insight is the development of a general method (PB-SSP) to reliably boost the confidence of existing SSP solvers from "good on average" to "good with high probability." This is crucial for real-world applications where robustness is key.
  • Synergy of IPPA and RDE: The paper demonstrates a powerful synergy between the iterative refinement of IPPA and the probabilistic selection power of RDE. IPPA helps manage problem complexity, while RDE ensures the final selected solution meets the high-probability target.
  • Condition Number Mitigation: The IPPA component is crucial for reducing the dependence on the problem's condition number (κ), a common issue in optimization. PB-SSP achieves this by making the condition number appear only in logarithmic factors in the sample complexity.
  • Generalizability: The PB-SSP framework is designed to be general, applicable to various SSP oracles (SAA, first-order methods) and both unconstrained and constrained problems, showcasing its broad utility.

Key Results

The paper establishes theoretical guarantees for its PB-SSP framework. Specifically, it shows that:

  • PB-SSP can equip an arbitrary SSP oracle with high-probability guarantees (e.g., P[ΔΦ(x, y) < ε] ≥ 1-p) with only an O(log poly(log κ)) overhead in sample complexity.
  • When applied to the Sample Average Approximation (SAA) oracle, PB-SSP improves the sample complexity by a factor of poly(κ) compared to naive approaches.
  • The paper provides concrete sample complexity bounds for various scenarios, including SC-SC unconstrained, SC-SC constrained, and even general convex-concave SSP problems. For instance, for SAA, it achieves an Õ(1/√n) bound with high probability, improving from the O(1/n) expected bound.
  • Numerical experiments on MDPs and stochastic matrix games demonstrate that PB-SSP significantly outperforms SAA and RDE in achieving high-probability guarantees, often reaching 0% probability of exceeding a target duality gap with a reasonable number of calls.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Tuning: The authors acknowledge that the theoretical parameter settings can be excessive for practical applications, and they suggest that users have flexibility in adjusting parameters like T and m.
  • Constrained Problems: While the framework is extended to constrained problems, the techniques for these settings are more complex due to non-vanishing gradient terms, and the paper proposes a hybrid approach combining SAA with variance-reduced methods.
  • Sub-Gaussian Assumption: Some prior works rely on sub-Gaussian assumptions for stochastic gradients, which this paper aims to relax. However, certain parts of the analysis might still implicitly benefit from such assumptions or require careful handling of heavy-tailed noise.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests exploring extensions to more general settings and potentially improving the sample complexity further. The experimental results also hint at the benefits of entropy regularization for certain problem structures, which could be a direction for future theoretical analysis.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2024general,
  author = {Dongyang Li and Haobin Li and Junyu Zhang},
  title = {{General Procedure to Provide High-Probability Guarantees for Stochastic Saddle Point Problems}},
  journal = {J. Sci. Comput},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s10915-024-02567-5},
}
Figure